winty
Moderator
- Moderator
- #1,626
AFLW Latest News - AFL.com.au/aflw
Latest breaking AFLW news from the official website of the Australian Football League.
www.womens.afl
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
I'd see myself agreeing with the grading (5/10), but not the overall sense of optimism in this piece. With other teams clearly continuing to improve as well, we're not likely to be shooting the lights out with even a reasonable trajectory of development going into next year.AFLW Latest News - AFL.com.au/aflw
Latest breaking AFLW news from the official website of the Australian Football League.www.womens.afl
Agree they would be important additions. But we're about to be short of an experienced tall to lead the forward line as well, and our on-ball division's best contributor is seriously limited in her disposal effectiveness. I don't see Prespakis hanging around for the long term either and, Nina aside, the rest of the mids group is 'developing' at best.I think the two pieces of the puzzle we need to fix at the moment is a decent ruck to be able to feed our emerging on-ball division and another key defender so we can free Maddy McMahon up to play more of a sweeper role like Tom Stewart does at AFL level.
Mark Soderstrom, Adelaide-based footy journo, perhaps?The follow up comments I've seen have mentioned the name Soda (not sure who that it), and apparently they said it twice
McDonald was never a chance for AA
McMahon is the unlucky one
I'm a fan of Amy, for sure. But there are just too many really talented mids in the system for her to make the final AA team. She does a fantastic job for the Cats. considering the somewhat limited skillset she brings to the game. But she's not going to get picked ahead of players who are more rounded overall and have higher proficiency in some of the basic skills of the game. Amy's clearance game is elite; her distribution after winning it is far less imposing. So I actually think she's done brilliantly well to make the squad, and don't think it's surprising at all that she didn't make the team.McDonald was never a chance for AA.
I'm a fan of Amy, for sure. But there are just too many really talented mids in the system for her to make the final AA team. She does a fantastic job for the Cats. considering the somewhat limited skillset she brings to the game. But she's not going to get picked ahead of players who are more rounded overall and have higher proficiency in some of the basic skills of the game. Amy's clearance game is elite; her distribution after winning it is far less imposing. So I actually think she's done brilliantly well to make the squad, and don't think it's surprising at all that she didn't make the team.
Agree with all of that. And, like you, I'd love to see Maddy win the B&F. Had a brilliant season, incredibly consistent, and don't think she was clearly beaten by a single opponent throughout the year.Totally agree with everything you've said - great contributor & player for the club, definitely a valuable asset to the midfield, but I think she'd struggle to break into a number of the better/stronger teams because of her disposal & her kicking can be a real weakness at times
I'm glad she was recognised with selection in the AA squad, but to see her going further would have been a real surprise
Meanwhile, McMahon looked a look earlier in the season, but thinking how our season panned out worked against her in the end. I expect her to be right up there at our B&F though, and wouldn't be surprised if she won
Adelaide Crows | TBC |
Carlton | Breann Moody |
Collingwood | Alana Porter |
Fremantle | Hayley Miller |
Geelong | Nina Morrison |
Gold Coast SUNS | Lucy Single |
GWS GIANTS | Brodee Mowbray |
Melbourne | TBC |
North Melbourne | Daisy Bateman |
Richmond | Poppy Kelly |
St Kilda | Kate McCarthy |
West Coast Eagles | Belinda Smith |
Western Bulldogs | Bonnie Toogood |
I don't know how successful you'll be in attempting to troll Lions fans on our own board. Nice try, though.I didn't notice that