Autopsy Autopsy v Dog

bog


  • Total voters
    151

Remove this Banner Ad

26- 41 clearances
8 - 16 centre clearances
18- 25 stoppage clearances
Forget everything else we did or didn't do right
This is where we lost the game

Yep. Dogs got silver service while our mids were chasing random hits with seemingly no system or method.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
Anyone that thinks the club can just call out s**t umpiring and not have it become infinitely more shitty against us probably went to one of those schools where the they have to wear mittens, helmets and use blunt scissors.

Also they're probably ******ed.
Bullshit! Dogs and pies rarely lose a
Free kick count, and have openly called out the AFL and umpires on several occasions in the last several years and that hasn’t hurt them has it?
 

Log in to remove this ad.

This seems contradictory to me.

You say we shouldn’t play the older players, but Ryan shouldn’t have played.

We can’t ONLY play him in dry conditions surely?
No, but the selection this week wasn't the right week to manage Riewoldt and play Ryan instead.

If the plan is to manage Riewoldt and promote Ryan that's great, but once we knew the conditions we probably needed to recognise that this isn't the week that's going to allow Ryan to prove it's a good move. As opposed to Riewoldt who has always been a handy forward in the wet as far as KPFs go.
 
Must persist with the kids and the play on style. I would also like to see Dow come in.
Areas to tidy up include addressing clearances - Nank probably needs to be upgraded and just making less errors on the kick ins. Although Tigers lost I was actually happy with Hardwick’s coaching as they finally played with speed. Melbourne are clearly the best side so it’s time to just enjoy the rebuild and be thankful for the three flags.
I enjoyed Clarke’s game today as well as how Ralphsmith, Cumbo and Young.
 
Here's the sad reality of 2023.

-Our midfield, even with our additions, is close to the worst in the competition.
-Our game plan doesn't work anymore. Forcing turnovers and trying to win the territory battle is failing.

These are the BIG TWO!

How is it possible that we went and got two inside mids with questionable disposal YET still want to play the turnover game?

It's clear that Hopper and Taranto were "gettable" by the GWS because they can't hit a target. Yet, we still play a structure that is reliant on turnovers. Taranto and Hopper are in and under/hack it forward mids. Both have made horrendous turnovers on 20/30m passes that we haven't seen from permanent mids for years.

It's like Dimma has addressed a weakness in the list, but hasn't adjusted the game plan to suit. It hasn't helped that Grimes and Vlastuin's intercept games have diminished and we have guys like Young (not his fault) who would prefer to "Nick Maxwell" a double fisted spoiler, rather than mark.
 
26- 41 clearances
8 - 16 centre clearances
18- 25 stoppage clearances
Forget everything else we did or didn't do right
This is where we lost the game
It would really help if our Ruckman could win a hit out to advantage... In fact I would love to know how many Nankervis hit outs have gone to the opposition advantage??. It would be some kind of record... Around the ground our Ruckman take very little marks and have very little presence. I would rather play another mid...
 
A disgrace from our club to be 1-1-2 after recruiting tarant and hopper and with the next 2 games chances are we will be. 1-1-4. Pick 12, 19, and whats looking like a top 10 pick and pick 31 only to lose the clearances 44-22.

Dickhead coaching performance. Bolton SHouldve been in the middle straight away.

Dimma and the recruiters who pusshed for Taranto and Hopper should be under the pump for this. 3 premierships doesnt mean you can throw away the clubs future.

reeks of Hawthorn Jager deal.
 
A disgrace from our club to be 1-1-2 after recruiting tarant and hopper and with the next 2 games chances are we will be. 1-1-4. Pick 12, 19, and whats looking like a top 10 pick and pick 31 only to lose the clearances 44-22.

Dickhead coaching performance. Bolton SHouldve been in the middle straight away.

Dimma and the recruiters who pusshed for Taranto and Hopper should be under the pump for this. 3 premierships doesnt mean you can throw away the clubs future.

reeks of Hawthorn Jager deal.

Nice melt
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Must persist with the kids and the play on style. I would also like to see Dow come in.
Areas to tidy up include addressing clearances - Nank probably needs to be upgraded and just making less errors on the kick ins. Although Tigers lost I was actually happy with Hardwick’s coaching as they finally played with speed. Melbourne are clearly the best side so it’s time to just enjoy the rebuild and be thankful for the three flags.
I enjoyed Clarke’s game today as well as how Ralphsmith, Cumbo and Young.
Into season two how do most think the dual captain situation is panning out.
 
Into season two how do most think the dual captain situation is panning out.
we all knew it was wrong when it was announced, but the club knows better ah

nank is barely best 22 and hes captain 🤪
 
Bullshit! Dogs and pies rarely lose a
Free kick count, and have openly called out the AFL and umpires on several occasions in the last several years and that hasn’t hurt them has it?
Mmmmmm but we aren't the filth or dogs now are we? Do you honestly believe if we are to speak up on perceived mistreatment that we will magically shoot up the free kick ladder? Are you high? More likely dimma will get to see some 'special angles' of our frees against and then the supporters will hear absolutely ****en nothing like with the lynch goal.

If we are in fact receiving unfair treatment then it will not stop until every last person that has stepped foot into tigerland from 2015 - 2023 is long gone from the organisation.

When we do speak out, nothing happens.

Why would we risk pissing off the powers that be when we could put that energy into making a team capable of overcoming it like '17-'20.

But it's a fair enough point you raise. I hadn't considered them.
 
Game plan is all over the shop. Some weeks we're trying to play like Collingwood, other weeks playing like Geelol 2022.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Autopsy Autopsy v Dog

Back
Top