Best 22 For Next Year

Remove this Banner Ad

Status
Not open for further replies.
FB Welsh Michael Fletcher
HB Lovett Ryder Nash
C Stanton Watson Winderlich
HF Mcfee Lucas Jetta
FF Davey Lloyd Gumbleton
FOL Hille Mcveigh Monfries
INT Laycock, Houli, Hislop, Dempsey
 
FB Welsh Michael Fletcher
HB Lovett Ryder Nash
C Stanton Watson Winderlich
HF Mcfee Lucas Jetta
FF Davey Lloyd Gumbleton
FOL Hille Mcveigh Monfries
INT Laycock, Houli, Hislop, Dempsey
It's not really our "best 22", but it's not a bad looking side at all. Hopefully some of those youngsters can work their way into the best 22 throughout the year.
 

Log in to remove this ad.

B: A.Welsh.... M.Michael..... Slattery
HB: Ryder ......Fletcher ...... Nash
C: McPhee .... Watson .......Winderlich
HF:Gumby ......Lucas .........Lovett
F: A.Davey .....Lloyd ......... Jetta
R: Laycock......McVeigh ......Stanton
IC: Hislop ........JJ ............DC ....... Monfries

That would be a good side to start with.
 
thats a real worry if people have Hille in the ruck, Watson in the middle and none of the draft picks in the starting 18. Thats a real worry.

B:Hislop Michael Reimers
HB: Lovett-Murray McPhee McVeigh
C:Myers Stanton Lovett
HF: Davey Gumbleton Jetta
F:Lucas Lloyd Neagle
R: Ryder Winderlich Monfries
Int: Hooker Dyson Rama Slattery
Emg: Welsh Pears Hille
 
thats a real worry if people have Hille in the ruck, Watson in the middle and none of the draft picks in the starting 18. Thats a real worry.

B:Hislop Michael Reimers
HB: Lovett-Murray McPhee McVeigh
C:Myers Stanton Lovett
HF: Davey Gumbleton Jetta
F:Lucas Lloyd Neagle
R: Ryder Winderlich Monfries
Int: Hooker Dyson Rama Slattery
Emg: Welsh Pears Hille

I would of thought not having Fletcher in the team is what you would call a real worry.
So too would be to have Ryder ruck by himself all game.
Where is Nash?
 
thats a real worry if people have Hille in the ruck, Watson in the middle and none of the draft picks in the starting 18. Thats a real worry.

B:Hislop Michael Reimers
HB: Lovett-Murray McPhee McVeigh
C:Myers Stanton Lovett
HF: Davey Gumbleton Jetta
F:Lucas Lloyd Neagle
R: Ryder Winderlich Monfries
Int: Hooker Dyson Rama Slattery
Emg: Welsh Pears Hille

i think u forgot houli
 
B:Hislop Michael Fletcher
HB: Lovett-Murray Myers McVeigh
C: McPhee Stanton Lovett
HF: Davey Gumbleton Jetta
F:Lucas Lloyd Neagle
R: Ryder Winderlich Monfries
Int: Nash Pears Rama Laycock
Emg: Welsh Houli Hille

A new recruit to walk into the "best 22" team and play CHB, No wonder we drafted him :cool:
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Hey..no need to start fighting..whilst Myers wouldn't have been my choice. Is he a bad choice, nope. He is extremely talented. And I am willing to give the bloke a go!

I'm not fighting but i don't think you got my point.

Do you expect an 18 year old kid to walk into our best 22 and hold down CHB in front of Fletcher or Ryder?
 
Slatts Mal NLM
McPhee Ryder Nash
Winders Stants McVeigh
Welsh Lucas Lovett
Hille Lloyd Davey

R: Laycock Watson Monfries

INT(from): JJ Pev Rama Houli Myers Johns
Would have thought our AA from last season would manage to scrape onto the bench if not a starting 18 position?:D
 
Do you expect an 18 year old kid to walk into our best 22 and hold down CHB in front of Fletcher or Ryder?

Yes I do as frankly I see Ryder as a ruckman, and Fletcher is better when loose anyway.
 
Most people seem to have left JJ and Pev out of the best 22. I think this is based more on hope than reality. I would like nothing more than for a number of young players to force them into retirement next year, but at the moment they are both definately in the best 22. Whether or not they are ahead enough to play in front of younger players is another issue.
 
Most people seem to have left JJ and Pev out of the best 22. I think this is based more on hope than reality. I would like nothing more than for a number of young players to force them into retirement next year, but at the moment they are both definately in the best 22. Whether or not they are ahead enough to play in front of younger players is another issue.

JJ is past it, it really is time to move on. Hopwever I see him play a vital role for Bendigo in the development of youngsters, same with Peverill to be honest.
 
B: Slattery - Michael - Ryder
HB: NLM -Fletcher - McPhee
C: Lovett - Watson# - Winderlich
HF: Davey - Lucas - McVeigh*
F: Monfries+ - Lloyd - Gumbleton
R: Hille - Stanton+ - Welsh*
INT: Laycock - Nash# - Jetta - Houli

I think our backline is starting to look alot more promising than it has in previous years, with Fletch and Mal still the anchors. Just bear in mind that it will get worse when those two retire before it gets better.

Midfield is still not quite up to the standards of the top sides but I think in 2-3 years we could have an A-Grade midfield. I've put in a few possible changes for the on-ballers which is basically just my own opinion. I think Welsh really stepped up last season and I would like to see if he has what it takes to play in the middle. In alot of the games last year we were getting smashed in the ruck while Hille was on and then when Laycock came on the game completely swung, I would like to see him step up a bit more and take charge.

The forward line is our strongest point as it has been for quite awhile. Lloyd and Lucas should have another 50+ year each. I like Davey hanging around the 50 so he can trap the ball in and also push up the ground a bit when needed.

I know alot of people will disagree with my line-up. This is how I kind of imagine the team for the first couple rounds then I would like to see a lot of rotating and experimenting with the younger players.
 
Yes I do as frankly I see Ryder as a ruckman, and Fletcher is better when loose anyway.

But you want an 18 year old kid to play out of position and play on some of the best forwards in the comp when Hille and Laycock will be playing ruck anyway?
 
But you want an 18 year old kid to play out of position and play on some of the best forwards in the comp when Hille and Laycock will be playing ruck anyway?

Hille is not in my starting 22.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Remove this Banner Ad

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top