Bluemour Discussion Thread XIV - Facts Not Welcome

[Jabba73]

Meanwhile Saints get Hannerbury for peanuts

Has been good, may be on a permanent decline. Does not look like he is moving freely at all during the year. May be a good move by the Swans

 

[Wickzki]

How the mighty have fallen.
Hannebery worth a high first rounder a few years ago, basically a non-event today.

That's what happens when your footy club destroys your body.

There wont be many Swans players from this era who are too pleased with them post-retirement.

 

[footyfan1978]

Wow. Hanneberry sold for chicken feed if that legit. That in essence is not much more than we got for Hampson from Richmond and less than we got for Yarran from Richmond.

 

[mrkyuss]

Meanwhile Saints get Hannebery for peanuts

Woukd prefer the peanuts to be honest...

 

[Navara79]

Are Sydney saying that Hannebery's body is cooked

 

[JustaBattler]

When it does fall over, they can keep Shiel and we can make an offer for Cognilio instead.

Shiel can walk next year to whomever he pleases.

You got the feeling the deal might fall over Jabsta?

 

[RedFury]

Has been good, may be on a permanent decline. Does not look like he is moving freely at all during the year. May be a good move by the Swans

Yeah the swans would know most about the state his body is in and his likelihood of returning to top form. That they are willing to give him away for so little speaks volumes.

 

[ericpascoe]

Hi. Thought I’d just pop back in to calm the farm. Reliably informed that Setterfield will get done and won’t involve our future first

 

[jj1978]

ANDRE's PRESS RELEASE
Could all those Carlton supporters having a whinge about not having brought in any mature agers please read and consider:

• We missed out on the main A grade target - not many of those to be had each year - we tried
• We got Fasolo as a UFA in the FA window - 26yo - tick
• We traded for McGovern during opening days of trade week - 23yo - tick
• We are in negotiations for Setterfield - OK only 20 but still better than a skinny 18yo - half tick
• So basically 2fwds and a mid
• Trade period is only half over, and maybe the reason we haven't heard anything is that the ones who provide reasonable to good rumours got lambasted by some knobs - probably the same ones having a whinge about no mature agers
• A lot of clubs won't delist mature players until further list lodgements closer to draft - may be one or 2 there we can use. An example is Newman from Sydney, can play a bit and worth a spot for us and likely to be DFA as Sydney can't give him away
• The Drafts haven't happened, we can pick older players with later picks, same as the Rookie Draft, where would could take H Goddard, M Grigg, Gibbons or any other state leaguer Agresta has identified (not that I want any of those)

POint being, wait until we're done before going the whinge, don't make the 8th wonder of the world come over there and dish out a 500lb body slam!!

McGov as of yesterday is 24yo

 

[harrisendblue]

Are Sydney saying that Hannebery's body is cooked

Partly and more about they don't want his salary in their cap.

 

[passmark]

Are Sydney saying that Hannebery's body is cooked

Sounds it.

 

[Navara79]

Hi. Thought I’d just pop back in to calm the farm. Reliably informed that Setterfield will get done and won’t involve our future first

 

[jj1978]

Hi. Thought I’d just pop back in to calm the farm. Reliably informed that Setterfield will get done and won’t involve our future first

Appreciate, also seems the media is backing us on this (future 2nd)... probably feel with talks of Scully, Wingard etc going to Hawthorn for a bag of peanuts can't expect Carlton to pay overs for unproven injured talent.

 

[WeninRome]

Wonder why SOS hasn't pursued Scully if this is the case. He would be ideal for us.

Maybe he is.

 

[SurreyBlue]

StKilda’s 1st pick is also involved. I’m sure of it. That is the peanuts part of the trade. I think.

 

[chipzac]

Hi. Thought I’d just pop back in to calm the farm. Reliably informed that Setterfield will get done and won’t involve our future first

Thanks EP. Maybe packaged with another GWS player?

 

[Sector 7G]

So who are you going to throw in the middle if Cripps gets hurt?

Garlett, Pickett, Cuningham, Polson?

Give me a break!!!!

No, I have been advocating that we go recruit a B Grade midfielder, Tyson, Dunstan, Ken, VanDenBurg Etc not someone who is no longer up to AFL standard. Have been saying we are 4 mids short on our list for some time (5 if you include Graham to be delisted)

 

[harrisendblue]

Hi. Thought I’d just pop back in to calm the farm. Reliably informed that Setterfield will get done and won’t involve our future first

Thanks a heap EP. Great to see you about again.

 

[BOSOJSOSAGSOS]

http://www.sydneyswans.com.au/news/2018-10-12/hannebery-heads-to-saints

As part of the trade, Sydney will receive St Kilda’s 2019 second-round pick and pick 39 in this year’s draft in exchange for Sydney’s pick 28 in 2018 and Hannebery.

That is NOTHING

 

[WeninRome]

Hi. Thought I’d just pop back in to calm the farm. Reliably informed that Setterfield will get done and won’t involve our future first

Anything else for us, legend?

 

[Zlatan]

Hi. Thought I’d just pop back in to calm the farm. Reliably informed that Setterfield will get done and won’t involve our future first

Good news. No way should we be paying a future first for Setterfield. Either a combination of picks or future second is more than enough.

Everyone knows their salary cap issues, this is all posturing from them.

 

[HARKER]

Hi. Thought I’d just pop back in to calm the farm. Reliably informed that Setterfield will get done and won’t involve our future first

Good on you dear fellow.

 

[FairKouta]

Welcome back old friend. Missed you is an understatement ericpascoe

 

[4thchicken]

That is NOTHING

At that price, would have been a useful target for us

 

[ericpascoe]

I doubt it. I think it might be a future second and a third for Setterfield. He’s a really good player with an injury cloud. Without the injury he’d be a first round pick, no question. SOS would have taken him with pick one in 2016.

Thanks EP. Maybe packaged with another GWS player?