Phew... I was worried this rumour had legs...Stevojust said on Gane day that Carlisle is a lock at Carlton and the dogs are out of the race, was adamant it was happening.
Rumour Bluemour Discussion thread
- Thread starter The Old Dark Navy's
- Start date
- Tagged users None
- Status
Jabba73
Hall of Famer
Players or potential coaches?
The Old Dark Navy's
Moderator
- Thread starter
- Moderator
- #5,028
Well ... you have a point.
But potential coaches .... which is like not having a list at all.
We've ruled out the cleaner and let me tell you, he's not happy and the board are meeting to decide whether to add him back again.
Rumoured coaching short list is too long. Spill the board...
Beveridge thinks Carlisle is a flog and won't have him at the club.
Get Beveridge!!!!!!!!
The Old Dark Navy's
Moderator
- Thread starter
- Moderator
- #5,033
I'm pretty sure you glossed over it and looked just for #bluemour tags and posts that appeared to be addressing them ... right?
The board has had this discussion this year and we have it any time the thread goes off topic. We get it, some people want their round pegs in round holes and nothing else. Their minds are ordered and they want quick access to all info in tidy packages. Others enjoy not being so regimented and letting some community levity spontaneously break out.
It's the reason we made two rumour threads so people can see if any new rumours have been posted, then go sifting through the discussion thread to see what people are saying about it. No new rumours in the Bluemour File, no new discussion in the Bluemour Discussion thread.
We know what is happening, we know how people feel about it. We know it is not for everybody. For some reason every time it happens, someone still has to point out how much they don't like it.
We can't please everybody ... we tried, but we can't.
Not much detail and I don't know my source very well but he is a friend of Adam Treloar's parents. They expect him to be back in Victoria next season, so something really unexpected needs to happen for him to re-sign with GWS. Just hope it's not Collingwood.
#bluemour
#bluemour
Last edited by a moderator:
Surprised to hear that Carlisle would be a lock, would this be because we have felt as though we have lost Henderson, and what would you give up to get Carlisle? Is he contracted and if not, with Essendon's history of being non trade friendly (polite version), if not contracted, can we pick him up for free in PSD?
thylacine60
Post-Human
- Banned
- #5,036
I'll say it again, Carlisle can play. It's whether he will be allowed to play plus * will want Kreuzer and Cripps and one of Carrots' kids to close the deal.
Tony Lynn 15
Hall of Famer
- Banned
- #5,037
- Jun 3, 2015
- 515
- 1,465
- AFL Club
- Carlton
If Carlisle was to come to Carlton, How would it be done trade? PSD? Its hard to see Gold coast or Brisbane letting him slip. I understand he would say i only want to play for Carlton don't pick me but if offer enough money he might go up north. Trade is unlikely cause Essendon over value all their players (maybe yarran and swap of 3rd rounders)
Tony Lynn 15
Hall of Famer
- Banned
- #5,039
I have started my shortlist of the 20.
1. Any current coach that is well past his best but has a big name.
2. Pagan.
3. Sheedy.
4. Brittain.
5. ..........
They can play hardball all they want.
If Carlisle is adamant he wants out, there's nothing they can do.
Ryder went to Port for Pick 17, and he d showed a lot more than Carlisle has so far
Plus there's the risk of the ban hanging over his head that d affect his price.
An pick between 17-21 would do the job.
If Carlisle is adamant he wants out, there's nothing they can do.
Ryder went to Port for Pick 17, and he d showed a lot more than Carlisle has so far
Plus there's the risk of the ban hanging over his head that d affect his price.
An pick between 17-21 would do the job.
The Old Dark Navy's
Moderator
- Thread starter
- Moderator
- #5,041
5 is intriguing.
Multiple full stops .... an ellipsis .... a pause? Pause ... paws ... Lions have paws .... a Lion is going to coach us ... maybe a former Lion. 10 periods, former Lion .... c r a z y v o s s y. Such a tease TL.
Tony Lynn 15
Hall of Famer
- Banned
- #5,042
You are bloody good!!!
- Oct 10, 2011
- 718
- 450
- AFL Club
- Carlton
My mate used to play with treloar and is close friends (guest at his wedding) Says his leaning towards Geelong. With Adam unhappy with the culture at Collingwood. Having said that Essendon were pushing hard for him too.
The Old Dark Navy's
Moderator
- Thread starter
- Moderator
- #5,044
Ryder went for #17 and #37 and we will be needed our late 30s pick for f/s bidding.
The one advantage we have is #2 in the PSD ... if not #1 when it all comes out in the wash. Some leverage there, especially if Lions spend up big on Dixon.
Brisbane will get one of Weitering or Schache in the draft, as well as Hipwood from their academy & are very keen on Dixon, so it is hard to imagine then chasing Carlisle.
The Suns may consider Carlisle if they are going to lose Dixon however they are also in the running for one of Weitering or Schache & of course already have Wright from the 2014 draft.
MC_Doggy_Frog18
Club Legend
Carlisle is a ****head
- Oct 10, 2011
- 718
- 450
- AFL Club
- Carlton
Come home Treloar... And please let it be for us
I hope he comes to us. But from what I heard, he feels, Geelong is closer to challenging.
Sigh... Okay then. But if he goes to Essendon I'll lose my shit.
OK so Geelong are getting Dangerfield, Treloar and Henderson, not to mention S.Selwood.
Off season will be brutal, forced retirement Johnson, Enright, Bartel, Kelly, Lonergan/Rivers, McIntosh, Stokes?, Mackie?
Revitalise Menzel, Vardy and Clark
Bews, Lonergan/Rivers, Taylor
Guthrie, Henderson, Thurlow
Duncan, Dangerfield, Blicavs
Menzel, Vardy, Motlop(maybe)
Clark, Hawkins, Gregson
Stanley, Treloar, Selwood
Caddy, Murdoch, Lang, Selwood
Horlin-Smith, Cockatoo, Kersten, Jansen, Simpson, Walker, Kolodjashnij and a few others still developing
Pretty awesome "rebuild" if it happens. The old boys won't be missed too much
- Status
Similar threads
