Rumour Bluemour Discussion XXXVII

[Blue Reaper]

So looking like we get pick 3.

Great now I need to actually go and look at all the draft highlights.

The answer you’re looking for is Draper

Edit: I actually have no idea. Just the vibe of the thing.

 

[mjonc43]

The answer you’re looking for is Draper

Ironically, who was his midfield partner in crime all year?

 

[Garters]

Collingwood have done well.

They were very fortunate to have both Noble and Richards in demand from the two clubs who were linked via Luko.

They are also in a better financial position given most of their top-liners are on more modest contracts due to age. It made less sense for us to 'go all in' given our top-heavy list profile.

The seas parted and they found a way through.

They have paid a very high price for it. Old list and have traded themselves out of this year's and next year's drafts. Then Tas coming on the scene. Hard to see how they rejuvenate their list.

 

[Blue Reaper]

Ironically, who was his midfield partner in crime all year?

Yes!

 

[C4[2]Yo`DooR]

Port are going to be spending the next day trying to convince Dan to join North.

 

[Benaly28]

Shoutout to ‘Yazz’ who posted in NO DISC on the 12th what this trade might look like and it’s pretty much spot on.


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[Blue Reaper]

Question now is, how do we get #3 and Houston. I’m not greedy. You are.

 

[Stamos]

Port are going to be spending the next day trying to convince Dan to join North.

What was it that made them pull out of the deal?

 

[windows1]

wonder if Richmond would be interested in offering 10 and baker for 3?

They should.

I am tipping if it happens they will be in the 3 way trade with us and I suspect they slide 10 to 12, get 14, give Baker, get Kennedy. WC get Owies 10 and Baker. Blues give Kennedy Owies 12 and 14.

Hunch only.

 

[CrippaTheGoat9]

Ironically, who was his midfield partner in crime all year?

 

[C4[2]Yo`DooR]

What was it that made them pull out of the deal?

I’m not sure - I’m reading between the lines that they’d rather send him to North for a better return or keep him?

 

[windows1]

Can’t agree with this enough. Laser focused. Love it.

Think I may be on my own in not seeing it with Draper. I just really don’t like the kicking.

 

[Revenant1965]

What was it that made them pull out of the deal?

 

[tarczonandjane]

Shoutout to ‘Yazz’ who posted in NO DISC on the 12th what this trade might look like and it’s pretty much spot on.


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

Don’t forget Yazz also said it would go through Tuesday morning. Worth keeping an eye on.

 

[Blue and Silver]

I think that the media getting a pretty robust wind of the deal might also be annoying trading partners

On Pixel 7a using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[Uncle Fester]

Ooft.



On Pixel 7a using BigFooty.com mobile app

I’m not sure - I’m reading between the lines that they’d rather send him to North for a better return or keep him?

Maybe they looked at it and realised it was an appalling deal

 

[Y Goat]

I’m really on the fence, I think I prefer taking 12 & 14 into the draft, but if 3 is an outstanding talent then it makes more sense as it really could impact immediately & we are more likely to get games into the kids right away.

Either way I hope we make bold selection decisions in MC & really roll our young players thru the midfield rotations & forward/back line.

I wonder if going for pick 3 is finding a compromise between now vs future focus.

3 could play 15 years but also impact from round 1. That is far less likely with the players available at 12 and 14.

Agree re the above posts and the trade-offs here..

12 & 14 a lot to give up, the notion of percentages and some safety in 2 good picks etc.. but I imagine what would tip the scales on it, is if LM team see someone at 3, bankable ‘low/uncertainty’ type :

• who’s got ‘breakaway-mid-speed’ traits, and,
• can impact in our midfield right away, next year

IMO that speed into the midfield next year what would make it worth the trade up

Need bankable kid/s who can impact and not flange of hit/miss/bust

Footnote :
1. One of 12/14 plus steak knives to Port for Houston also worth some thought if they have a really strong prospect likely around 12/14
(So it all depends how LM rate kids around 3 and 12/14)

2. The posters suggesting 14 plus something to GC for 13 - absolutely love that one, pure Machiavellian

 

[Blue Reaper]

Think I may be on my own in not seeing it with Draper. I just really don’t like the kicking.

That’s fair. I’m no draft watcher/expert. Just an armchair YouTube highlights hero . I trust the club - with their time and resources - to make a judicious decision.

 

[HereComesJuddy]

Was initially thinking it was going to be a 3 way trade but think it actually could be a 4 way trade.

Without going into all of the moving pieces I think it might be something like at a rough guess.

Carlton get: pick 3, Richmond’s pick 24
Give: 12, 14, Owies, Kennedy

WCE get: 12, Hawks F1, Baker, Owies
Give: 3, Barrass

Hawks get: Barrass
Give: F1, F2

Richmond get: pick 14, Kennedy, Hawks F2
Give: Baker, pick 24

 

[CCurnow3votes]

Really loving how Austin and club are conducting themselves.

All they need to do is stay quiet - the other club calamities make us look amazing!

 

[Ninja Worrier]

Ironically, who was his midfield partner in crime all year?

There's a passage of play against Vic country where they transition from half back like an AFL side, was good to watch

 

[DEliades]

Keep Kennedy out of any trade please.

 

[windows1]

Was initially thinking it was going to be a 3 way trade but think it actually could be a 4 way trade.

Without going into all of the moving pieces I think it might be something like at a rough guess.

Carlton get: pick 3, Richmond’s pick 24
Give: 12, 14, Owies, Kennedy

WCE get: 12, Hawks F1, Baker, Owies
Give: 3, Barrass

Hawks get: Barrass
Give: F1, F2

Richmond get: pick 14, Kennedy, Hawks F2
Give: Baker, pick 24

We would be making off like bandits.

 

[HereComesJuddy]

Keep Kennedy out of any trade please.

He doesn’t have a position. Best we move him on if there’s a taker and also clear his 2025 salary off the books also

 

[Jell]

Smith vibes like a bust?????

What the actual ****.

Sorry, thought this was an opinion based thread Not sure why it’s so crazy to you. Every single season there are players that are hyped up, sold as a combination of Chris Judd and Jesus Christ, but then turn out to be Jimmy Toumpas. My gut feel is that Jagga Smith is that guy this year.