Welcome to East Germany Carlton and Collingwood - who finishes higher in 2023? Collingwood Ofcourse

[Robertio]

Another Carlton supporter who thinks your last round choke wasn’t the most embarrassing moment in the history of your club.

I look ahead and you're another Pie supporter who won't be in a Carlton thread next season.

 

[South of the Yarra]

Carlton has 16 flags, Collingwood 15.

That’s nice for you just a shame you have been left with the Saints as the least successful clubs in the modern game. Sad to see this once great club what it is today

 

[Robertio]

How do Carlton supporters not just disappear til next year after the way they were embarrassed and humbled in their last game of the season... Completely self unaware/cringe

We're not like you blokes.

 

[Arr0w]

We can play with Maths however we like how about we go with Collingwood have one 1 flag in the last 12 years, Carlton have won 0 in the last 27 years. We could even go with Collingwood have won twice as many as Carlton in the last 32 years

You catching on yet?

Same amount of flags in 3 and 4 decades, beyond that, we have you covered over the next 40 years

Stop making out you are so superior

 

[Robertio]

That’s nice for you just a shame you have been left with the Saints as the least successful clubs in the modern game. Sad to see this once great club what it is today

The game has been going nearly 200 years mate.

 

[Fadge]

Nice backtrack, same as last year. Same as doppelganger that stated we would be fighting to stay out of the bottom 4 with the Dockers.

See, this wager would be controlled by a mod, where they could suspend your account from the last H&A game of 2023, to the first game of 2024. So you won't have the chance to welch on the wager

But, you don't have the character to back it up.

GET. SOME. FRIENDS. IN. THE. REAL. WORLD.

 

[Fadge]

I look ahead and you're another Pie supporter who won't be in a Carlton thread next season.

Just another off-season in the 21st Century for the Carlton Crew....

One would think they would have learned by now, but no.....

 

[Robertio]

Just another off-season in the 21st Century for the Carlton Crew....

One would think they would have learned by now, but no.....

Another one who thinks footy started in the year 2000, can't count or in denial.

 

[Arr0w]

GET. SOME. FRIENDS. IN. THE. REAL. WORLD.

Another boring deflection.

 

[Kipz]

We're not like you blokes.

Nah I know, you didn't play finals

 

[rye]

the consistent raising of pre-afl era flags as if they should be treated as equal with a premiership won during the current era is very funny mental gymnastics being used to push an argument by some here

 

[Robertio]

the consistent raising of pre-afl era flags as if they should be treated as equal with a premiership won during the current era is very funny mental gymnastics being used to push an argument by some here

Flags are flags mate, don't the AFL still count them?

 

[Arr0w]

the consistent raising of pre-afl era flags as if they should be treated as equal with a premiership won during the current era is very funny mental gymnastics being used to push an argument by some here

Same could be said with merger flags

 

[Arr0w]

"Another mediocre year ahead for the Blues in 2023. Put as much as you can on the circa $2.50 odds on them again missing the finals next year. Money for jam."

Go on Fadge, doubled your betting regime from $1 to $2?

 

[RAPPA]

"Another mediocre year ahead for the Blues in 2023. Put as much as you can on the circa $2.50 odds on them again missing the finals next year. Money for jam."

Go on Fadge, doubled your betting regime from $1 to $2?

Of course it’s money for jam when you’re constantly betting with the man in the mirror - guaranteed 100% strike rate.

 

[Arr0w]

Of course it’s money for jam when you’re constantly betting with the man in the mirror - guaranteed 100% strike rate.

Hedges his position over the course of a preseason. In season does the same

Countless posts where his so called betting superamcy, have been major fails

So far he claims we will finish last, then 11th, while the Pies finish 1st

 

[Madblue]

Another Carlton supporter who thinks your last round choke wasn’t the most embarrassing moment in the history of your club.

Just like your 1 point choke against Geelong which was Colliwobbles at its best yet again

 

[South of the Yarra]

Just like your 1 point choke against Geelong which was Colliwobbles at its best yet again

Umm we didn’t lose by 1 point to Geelong. CRASH! BURN!

 

[BringouttheGimp]

If Carlton finishes higher than Collingwood.. I'll turf my Oud.. Penhaligon.. Amouage.. straight in to the bin mate.. and I'll wear Pino Silvestre for a whole year at the bars and clubs and on dates and that mate.

Now that's a corker of a bet mate.. that theerrre.. is the very definition of doing the hard yards mate.. now that's a real bet mate.. now that's a real bet mate.. that's it mate.

 

[Robertio]

If Carlton finishes higher than Collingwood.. I'll turf my Oud.. Penhaligon.. Amouage.. straight in the bin mate.. and I'll wear Pino Silvestre for a whole year at the bars and clubs and on dates and that mate.

Now that's a corker of a bet mate.. that theerrre.. is the very definition of doing the hard yards mate.. now that's a real bet mate.. now that's a real bet mate.. that's it mate.

 

[doppleganger]

The hubris is delicious.

Ha, that is my view of the Carlton fans who still talk about Carlton being a power because of wins half a century ago.

Melbourne were a powerhouse in the 50s and 60s, but you dont see many Melbourne fans continually mention it.

For all of the supreme dominance, it has yielded what, 2 premierships when you like to use your 'AFL era' metric?

Double the premierships
Double the finals wina
More than 80+ additional overall wins
1/5 of the spoons

Carlton have won the most spoons (5) in the AFL era, they have been a shit show.

Given Collingwood's propensity to $hit the bed when it makes it to the big stage and the ultimate success being materialised in the form of winning a premiership, I'll happily take the option of Carlton winning another before Collingwood, notwithstanding there may be another Collingwood GF loss before then

Carlton used to just buy flags, cant do that in AFL era. AFL era says Carlton are due for another spoon soon.

And yes, Pies will just continue to win our way deep in finals more often than not.

 

[doppleganger]

Of course it’s money for jam when you’re constantly betting with the man in the mirror - guaranteed 100% strike rate.

Pies have finished above Carlton in 18 of the last 20 seasons.

Money for jam.

 

[Arr0w]

Ha, that is my view of the Carlton fans who still talk about Carlton being a power because of wins half a century ago.

Melbourne were a powerhouse in the 50s and 60s, but you dont see many Melbourne fans continually mention it.

Double the premierships
Double the finals wina
More than 80+ additional overall wins
1/5 of the spoons

Carlton have won the most spoons (5) in the AFL era, they have been a s**t show.

Carlton used to just buy flags, cant do that in AFL era. AFL era says Carlton are due for another spoon soon.

And yes, Pies will just continue to win our way deep in finals more often than not.

This is funny

Every club was buying flags in another era, clearly we spent that money more effectively than the Pies. Glorious isn't it

More participant wins? Sure, but still can't translate that to flags

Laughable that you think you are constent contenders, when in fact you are merely pretenders

 

[Madblue]

Umm we didn’t lose by 1 point to Geelong. CRASH! BURN!

6 point loss to Cats and 1 point loss to Swans so even worse

 

[Arr0w]

Pies have finished above Carlton in 18 of the last 20 seasons.

Money for jam.

Carlton have 4 times the flags over the last 6 decades

We can do this all day if you want to persist in going back to the past