Banter Carlton is better in 2024. Who will be better in 2025? Carlton or Collingwood? Part 3

[carlton_99]

Your window slams shut the second Cripps hangs up the boots IMO, he’s that influential for you. The way he plays how many years til he breaks down?

So it’s not any old year, it might be 2-3 years til you’re entirely out of the mix again, maybe for another 30 years… it’s also not every year a dual AA A-grader childhood fan wants to get to your club, right when you’re at the zenith of your list build and meant to be contending. The timing is impeccable.

The way they seem to be trying to cut loose Owies and Kennedy tells me salary cap may be an issue, yes, but if it’s just about wanting a draft pick too it’s sheer stupidity IMO. Even if the 50/50 of the player making it goes your way, it’s unlikely to coincide with your captain still carrying the team on his shoulders, and you win nothing and die wondering what could have been….

Trust me as a Pies fan I’m pleased by what I’m seeing, and we may well be the beneficiaries, just can’t make heads or tails of what Carlton are thinking.

Glad you are pleased

 

[Fadge]

Again what's the point . I could throw silvagni into my top 15 and he laughs it off as it doesnt suit the narrative. Everything I suggest he contests. Do you not agree ?

You nominated Silvagni in your top 15 and I laughed it off because he's not in your top 15.

On this forum, it's not about who 'says something', it's about 'what they say'....

I agree with many things that many Carlton posters say.

 

[Worm4]

I agree with many things that many Carlton postars say

It's as rare as Halley's Comet and only when you know you can't prove them wrong.

 

[Worm4]

You nominated Silvagni in your top 15 and I laughed it off because he's not in your top 15.

Here is the thing - he is in my top 15
He is just not in your top 15

 

[CarmenSandiego]

McSpud has a 13-6 record with us, he's an excellent target who rarely gets outmarked, possibly our 3rd most important player after Daics and De Goey

Yet when we bring up our 17-0 (or whatever it was) with Fogarty you laugh at it.

You lot are genuinely unreal . The lack of self awareness is genuinely staggering.

 

[Worm4]

Let's be clear.

You've then gone on a rant about me refuting other posters' claims because they're not in agreeance (which isn't even a word) with me.


Wowee.

Again , another case of you trying to prove others wrong

 

[Fadge]

Carlton posters now claiming McStay isn't in Collingwood's best and most important 15 players, and if he is, then the likes of Silvagni and Fogarty are in theirs.

Boy oh boy wowee.

If that's the case, we'll I guess it's clear why Collingwood regularly contend for premierships, where's Carlton haven't contended for a quarter of a century...

 

[Do_Beta_Rapport]

I wonder if Carlton will get handed a soft ass draw for 2025 like they did in 2024?

 

[Do_Beta_Rapport]

Carlton posters now claiming McStay isn't in Collingwood's best and most important 15 players, and if he is, then the likes of Silvagni and Fogarty are in theirs.

Boy oh boy wowee.

If that's the case, we'll I guess it's clear why Collingwood regularly contend for premierships, where's Carlton haven't contended for a quarter of a century...

Collingwood don’t win either of their first 2 finals in 2023 without McStay. Simple as that.

 

[Fadge]

Collingwood don’t win either of their first 2 finals in 2023 without McStay. Simple as that.

I can understand why the Carlton posters may have tuned out of the 2023 finals series...

 

[Fadge]

I wonder if Carlton will get handed a soft ass draw for 2025 like they did in 2024?

Given they have a traditional round 1 fixture against Richmond, there's a likely double up and therefore immediate leg up there...