And there it is. Took about 5 seconds to come up with itSilvagni, Martin and Cottrell in Carlton's top 15 players...
No wonder you haven't contended for a quarter of a century!
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
AFLW 2024 - Round 8 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
And there it is. Took about 5 seconds to come up with itSilvagni, Martin and Cottrell in Carlton's top 15 players...
No wonder you haven't contended for a quarter of a century!
Didn't seem to have an issue with my ranking when I had Cripps 49th in 2023. Funny that.Be careful - it's at this point where he cuts and pastes his contending post , on a regular basis.
I dunno....Why do you think it's imperative that people have the same opinion as yours ?
Maybe you should be more accepting of other peoples opinions. World would be a pretty boring place if we all shares the same view.I dunno....
What would you think if I made a statement that I had Cripps ranked the 10th best player in 2024?
After all, it is only an opinion...
Oh well, it's confirmed then.Didn't seem to have an issue with my ranking when I had Cripps 49th in 2023. Funny that.
There are reasonable opinions, and unreasonable opinions that are clouded by inherent biases.Maybe you should be more accepting of other peoples opinions. World would be a pretty boring place if we all shares the same view.
When did I ever bring up Cripps/Daicos performance comparison over the last two seasons? Think this is an argument you were having with someone else. Once again this is MY opinion which does not show anything other than MY view.Oh well, it's confirmed then.
Daicos ranked 4th and 7th over each of the past two seasons has been comfortably better than Cripps who has been ranked 1st and 49th....
Yes it is very unreasonable to have had Daicos as a top 8 player in 2023 and 2024. How inherently biased of me!There are reasonable opinions, and unreasonable opinions that are clouded by inherent biases.
Well given the lowest position he's finished in any of the 3 main individual awards across the two seasons is 3rd, you'd be doing well to have 7 players ranked ahead of him....Yes it is very unreasonable to have had Daicos as a top 8 player in 2023 and 2024. How inherently biased of me!
I don't care about the individual awards - if I was inherently biased why would I post that I had Cripps 49th in 2023?Well given the lowest position he's finished in any of the 3 main individual awards across the two seasons is 3rd, you'd be doing well to have 7 players ranked ahead of him....
So Nick not the best player in the AFL at any stage . ConfirmedOh well, it's confirmed then.
Daicos ranked 4th and 7th over each of the past two seasons has been comfortably better than Cripps who has been ranked 1st and 49th....
I suspect you just made up a number.I don't care about the individual awards - if I was inherently biased why would I post that I had Cripps 49th in 2023?
Confirmed by Carlton_99's 'subjective opinion'.So Nick not the best player in the AFL at any stage . Confirmed
Works both ways. Your opinions can be clouded as wellThere are reasonable opinions, and unreasonable opinions that are clouded by inherent biases.
When did I say I had 7 players ahead of Daicos over the past two seasons. I had him 7th in 2023 alone and 4th in 2024 alone. If you average it out he's probably 2nd overall behind Bontempelli.I suspect you just made up a number.
Who are the 7 players you have ahead of Daicos over the past 2 seasons, given one of them can't be Cripps due to his poor 2023 (based on your personal ranking)?
Who says he needs to kick 50 goals next season - that's a ridiculous expectation.
he's a 50+ goal year small fwd
What position has Williams played in 10.5/11 of those years again?A player who has kicked 47 goals in an 11 year career can kick 50+ goals in a season....
Oh no.What position has Williams played in 10.5/11 of those years again?
Half serious for identifying that a player's goal tally from HB is irrelevant to the goals he is predicted to kick as a full time forward?Oh no.
You're half serious...
30 would be enough . Would win Collingwoods goalkicking with that haulA player who has kicked 47 goals in an 11 year career, and has averaged 10 games a year since he's been at Carlton, can kick 50+ goals in a season....
Trading up in a draft with no clear top end and a very even spread of top talent? Ballsy. You’d rather 12 and 14 in a draft like thisBoy oh boy... Rumour mill has it that the Blues have secured a deal for Pick 3 with the Weagles while the Pies Houston play is up in smoke with good ol Leppa at the wheel... Oh my.