I wonder what you see if you 'open the other eye'?Well derrrrr
Your opinion on Carlton means very little to me too.
Would it be a second steaming pile of ?
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
AFLW 2024 - Round 8 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
I wonder what you see if you 'open the other eye'?Well derrrrr
Your opinion on Carlton means very little to me too.
Peak bigfooty.
Modern day Carlton fans telling Pies fans how to build a list.
No. If I open the other eye it will be the one same steaming pile of . It just looks bigger, closer and in greater focus.I wonder what you see if you 'open the other eye'?
Would it be a second steaming pile of ?
Perryman and Houston won’t make a difference to your defence if your midfield keeps getting belted. There are only so many D50 entries that can be defended.
This is a dumb trade period by the Pies, did not address the real weaknesses in their team in the mid or fwd line.
Misery needed company...Awwwwwwwww, the little Carlton stooge is back. How sweet.
Says a lot that you think picking up a player in the draft means you're rebuilding.I am going to be fascinated to sit back and watch this Carlton rebuild. Will it be different to the others? I admire the honesty of the club in realising this current list cannot win a flag and not bothering to top it up with stars to have a crack at a flag. Brutally honest but harsh. Back to the draft, the rebuild begins.
I just feel sorry for the poor kid they take at pick 4...I am going to be fascinated to sit back and watch this Carlton rebuild. Will it be different to the others? I admire the honesty of the club in realising this current list cannot win a flag and not bothering to top it up with stars to have a crack at a flag. Brutally honest but harsh. Back to the draft, the rebuild begins.
Let the rebuild begin.Says a lot that you think picking up a player in the draft means you're rebuilding.
What iteration is this since they last contended?Let the rebuild begin.
It's amusing but I also find it a bit concerning what Carlton have done..... I 100% expected them to try to top up thinking they were still in the window. But their lack of delusion this time is a worry.I am going to be fascinated to sit back and watch this Carlton rebuild. Will it be different to the others? I admire the honesty of the club in realising this current list cannot win a flag and not bothering to top it up with stars to have a crack at a flag. Brutally honest but harsh. Back to the draft, the rebuild begins.
I am going to be fascinated to sit back and watch this Carlton rebuild. Will it be different to the others? I admire the honesty of the club in realising this current list cannot win a flag and not bothering to top it up with stars to have a crack at a flag. Brutally honest but harsh. Back to the draft, the rebuild begins.
Membrey will helpPerryman and Houston won’t make a difference to your defence if your midfield keeps getting belted. There are only so many D50 entries that can be defended.
This is a dumb trade period by the Pies, did not address the real weaknesses in their team in the mid or fwd line.
I am trying not be too parochial in relation to this topic. However I know that both Collingwood & Carlton experienced an usually high level of injuries during the 2023 season. Now whether Carlton had more or not, I am not sure & I am open to the relevant statistical data. OK. Now I think that the acquisition of both Perryman & Houston will certainly improve the Pies going forward. On the flip side, I have to say that I admire Carlton's creative draft strategy in order to get Pick 3 in this forthcoming draft. Obviously the Blues have a particular target in mind. Whether it is Callaghan or Lalor or Smith or someone else I am not sure. However I am sure that Carlton will end up with a quality player. Goodnight & good luck.The reality check was that we had more injuries to our best 22 tho...
Membrey will help
How many collingwood forwards kicked 33 goals in 2024 ?How many more 33 goals a year forwards are gonna walk from their side?
Please explain how is it a rebuild ? We have offloaded a couple of fringe players ( like collingwood did with Noble ) , identified that the top half dozen player's in the draft are really really good prospects so have traded a future 1st and 2nd to obtain that pick 3 ( collingwood yet again have traded future 1st for Houston) , and have acquired points to bring in 2 father/sons which was always going to happen.I am going to be fascinated to sit back and watch this Carlton rebuild. Will it be different to the others? I admire the honesty of the club in realising this current list cannot win a flag and not bothering to top it up with stars to have a crack at a flag. Brutally honest but harsh. Back to the draft, the rebuild begins.
They've been dodoro'dStaggering that some Collingwood fans in this thread think that this was a successful trade period for them.
It was certainly over after 50 minutes.Did the final only go for 50 minutes?
What you may be too dull to have observed is that we’ve already begun finding mid-career replacements for the outgoing players before they retire. IeWhich part was wrong?
Will Sidey & Pendles play on in 2026?
Will Howe, Cox, Elliott still be around and/or serviceable at AFL level?
Do you have picks & other currency to trade with to replace these players?
You have 1x F/S coming (McGuane), is that incorrect?
Did you not finish 9th? Thus having to improve your position from 9th to Top 4 to be a real shot at the flag?
It's a 1-year shot. A Last Dance approach based on slim hope rather than actual evidence - sorry the evidence is 'we beat brisbane twice in the h&a season'.
For success to be sustained you have to be successful to begin with.Rebuilding lol - it's called team balance. We want to put ourselves in a position where we can have some sustained success not contend for 2 years and then fall to the bottom 4 again. We will not sell the farm to fill a position that is not a pressing need. With Tasi coming in soon and compromising the draft the time is now to bring in some elite young talent.
I agree with you there mate.Geez some people on this thread have a bad case of little club syndrome
It's not like Nick doesn't single handedly drag Collingwood across the the line in games is it ? Is that any different ?I’d be more worried about the cliff awaiting the Blues when Cripps stops single handedly dragging you across the line in games, wonder how many top tier years he’s got left? Clocks ticking…