List Mgmt. Carlton's 2018 Draft Thread (cont. in Part 2)

Remove this Banner Ad

Status
Not open for further replies.
I think one kid SOS will monitor pretty closely during the year will be Bailey Williams. Was really impressed with what I saw of him in last years U18 Nationals. There aren't many ruck prospects I'd part with a 1st Rounder for, but this kid I would. He's a unique talent in this years draft I'd expect him to go easily inside the Top 10.
 
Send all the picks to GC...

We need the what they have!!
But do we really? If McKay charlie and Jack stay the course why throw pics and money on something we already have makes 0 sense. We have key forwards no point wasting picks drafting forwards to just trade in someone to not let them develope sorry but i would so much love our rebuild more if we just started developing our own

On [device_name] using BigFooty.com mobile app
 

Log in to remove this ad.

561555-tlslargeportrait.jpg

:(

I want someone with a bit more silk and creativity.

Basically I want Rankine.

Bonar is nice, though.
 
It won’t be about money if he comes to Melbourne...;)

Maybe not purely about money, but you do you think his decision won't be swayed by the dollars in the end? He could have 4 or 5 clubs seriously going after him so he won't go cheap.

Even if Lynch plays at 2016 form and kicks 66 that's still about $23k a goal... double our current Casboult 'value'. I know you can't money ball everything but the laws of diminishing returns definitely come into play with these marquee/messiah 'super contracts'.

I don't want us to throw $1.5M at a single player, I'd rather get two $750k players for that. What's better value for (the same) money, 3 goals a game from a key forward or 50-60 quality disposals from two top end midfielders?
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

2 x top 10 picks please.

We've got one already - now for SOS to work his magic and trade the 2 x 2nd round picks for 1 x 1st (as he did with the Bulldogs a few years ago).

Would set us up really nicely in a strong draft.

Agree and to that scope I'd consider next year's 1st rounder too. The 2018draft is a strong draft the top 10 are special and the next 10 are not shoddy. So two top ten would set with some great young talent.
 
It’s a draft for free agents as it looks like clubs are willing to trade to get picks, do we trade 2x2nds to upgrade to another 1st and use it to get a required player, my bet will be yes...

We will land a fish this year as we have plenty of room and there are players wanting out of their sides and want the big stage, enter CFC...
 
2 x top 10 picks please.

We've got one already - now for SOS to work his magic and trade the 2 x 2nd round picks for 1 x 1st (as he did with the Bulldogs a few years ago).

Would set us up really nicely in a strong draft.
Walk away with Walsh and lukosius. Future sorted.
 
I'm an unabashed Rankine fan. He's something special that kid with skills that I can't remember seeing from many other players. The only questions I have are on his ability to consistently accumulate the ball, and his strength inside the contest. If he prove himself in those areas I just can't look past him as a prospect. The kids potentially the greatest player to ever play the game.
 
June 2017: Lukosius, Rankine......then daylight.
Sep 2017: Lukosius, Rankine.....then daylight
Feb 25 2018: Lukosius, Rankine......then daylight

with a great pack trying to run them down by November......but byjeezus they'll be panting if they catch them.
Edited for Accuracy

Lukosius is outrageously gifted but so is Rankine, an absolute jet - Judd with exceptional skill

Free agent acquisition decides favourite for us, get Lynch take Rankine....get a Gaff type and wink/nod from Shiel then take Lukosius.

They both really are generational types in respective positions.
 
Last edited:
This is the player we need to create an intelligent and mobile goal kicking forward line, Lukosiuos will be an absolute star of the game.

Best young talent i have seen in 25 odd years of watching elite junior footy.

Plays similar to N Riewoldt, but with elite kicking.

Will be a star of the game
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Remove this Banner Ad

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top