I think it'd be difficult to argue that he wasn't up to scratch against Gold Coast or Hawthorn this year. Wasn't great against Geelong, but certainly wasn't our worst. Poo against Essendon, but nor orphan there.
Considering the above and his stupidly low ToG%, '1 in 5' is a poor call.
1 in 5 is a poor call, in fact it’s lewd, lascivious, salacious, outrageous........ given the above, 1 in 4.