wicksy
Cancelled
- Feb 23, 2007
- 8,505
- 7,259
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
- Other Teams
- Clippers, Daniel Ricciardo Racing
Senior list of 38 with 6 rookies.... JT and Keeffe being two of them.
-
AFLW 2024 - Round 4 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
List Mgmt. Collingwood Trade Talk 2015
- Thread starter popin
- Start date
- Tagged users None
- Status
Senior list of 38 with 6 rookies.... JT and Keeffe being two of them.
Just jumped on. Alot of sooks on here. I thought I was on the Carlton forum for a minute there.
Don't understand what the big deal is. Treloar will be done. Leon Cameron has even said as much this afternoon.
Aish likely to be nabbed with 2 2nd rounders (one coming from St Kilda).
Kennedy and Seedsman were not making our team look any better. At least Howe brings something a little different to the team. Kennedy was just another small to add to our other smalls. Seedsman just all over the place. I think Howe could pose a problem with his additional flexibility in the forward line. Also, is versatile enough to play back if need be.
I don't think we gave up much at all to get him.
Never going to improve unless you move people who are not improving on. Otherwise we end up looking like Carlton's list.
Don't understand what the big deal is. Treloar will be done. Leon Cameron has even said as much this afternoon.
Aish likely to be nabbed with 2 2nd rounders (one coming from St Kilda).
Kennedy and Seedsman were not making our team look any better. At least Howe brings something a little different to the team. Kennedy was just another small to add to our other smalls. Seedsman just all over the place. I think Howe could pose a problem with his additional flexibility in the forward line. Also, is versatile enough to play back if need be.
I don't think we gave up much at all to get him.
Never going to improve unless you move people who are not improving on. Otherwise we end up looking like Carlton's list.
- Aug 16, 2009
- 4,213
- 7,609
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
- Other Teams
- Celtics, Canucks
m39! Nuts to promote Gault...I'm just raising possibilities of who will fill list spots
I was a fan of Gault in his first year as a lead up forward...the experiment of trying to teach him in the backline seems to have set him back further than he can recover.
I think he's too weak in the contest, not impressed with his second efforts, and doesn't appear to have the game smarts needed. That's a fair whack to give but that's exactly where he's at.
Last edited:
That is really only improving our draft place by 12 places in exchange for pick 68. So its not really that shit.
Superfooty Podcast with Jay Clark, Mick Warner and Sam Landsberger
- James Aish - will get to Pies. Very good deal on offer from North Melbourne. Probably for Pick 26 and maybe a low pick
- Jeremy Howe - seems the info is out of date (they were saying Kennedy and 3rd round for Howe)
- Adam Treloar - Intrigued by the story. Bad blood between two clubs. Not a lot of follow up with op story, but GWS filthy on not knowing about it. Manager's responsible for club's not knowing about it. GWS suspects Pies may have known (we knew about the injury) and unhappy about the insinuation that they misdiagnosed the injury. Apparently it was Tassie Docs who tipped off GWS. AFL ticked off on what happen. They think Pies paying overs.
Thinks with Howe on forward flank, Aish on a wing and Treloar in centre we need to make finals (Sam thinks we could go top four).
- James Aish - will get to Pies. Very good deal on offer from North Melbourne. Probably for Pick 26 and maybe a low pick
- Jeremy Howe - seems the info is out of date (they were saying Kennedy and 3rd round for Howe)
- Adam Treloar - Intrigued by the story. Bad blood between two clubs. Not a lot of follow up with op story, but GWS filthy on not knowing about it. Manager's responsible for club's not knowing about it. GWS suspects Pies may have known (we knew about the injury) and unhappy about the insinuation that they misdiagnosed the injury. Apparently it was Tassie Docs who tipped off GWS. AFL ticked off on what happen. They think Pies paying overs.
Thinks with Howe on forward flank, Aish on a wing and Treloar in centre we need to make finals (Sam thinks we could go top four).
It could be improved by 16! If?
Kenendy pick 44 for Howe
Seedsman pick 28 force the geelong pick of them
Uh yes, that's what Adelaide gave up to get him.
Scodog10
Brownlow Medallist
Sorry to interject, but doesn't the fact that we didn't do that deal indicate it wasn't an option? It's clearly a better deal so Melbourne obviously weren't keen on it beause Kennedy just wasn't worth it...
PicaBoo
Soldaat van Oranje
FFS . Days of whinging to get a trade done. Now we do one and immediately meltdown. And before you ask, am I happy? Sort of . We got Howe which is a start. We want to improve our best 22 , not our depth. If we get all we want and it costs us some picks, so be it. Let's see how the rest unfolds.
- Jan 12, 2011
- 25,405
- 35,588
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
Like all of our trading recently, in the end people will be saying how well we did and how badly the others did
I am not that excited by a draft order upgrade to be outraged by it to be honest, you gotta give some to get some. Add to the fact that Melbourne would have baulked at Kennedy & 44.
Seedsman is fair value and Kennedy is lucky to be worth Melbourne's 3rd rounder (about 46).
Melbourne would have wanted a second round draft pick from us for Howe and I am pretty sure we need those up our sleeve for Aish, Treloar etc.
- May 7, 2011
- 59,398
- 14,052
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
- Other Teams
- Celtics, Tottenham, Oakland Raiders
Apart from the injuries etc, does he have the aggression necessary?
How is this trade going to help get treloar? The pick 68?
We could of given our own pick 65 if they wanted that.
Hine better reveal a pearl in this treloar trade, like getting pick 20 or 21 from GWS ( the pick they will receive after carlton trade for all those players ) instead of pick 27
I think you are harsh on Langdon. Best 22.
Aish actually doesnt turn 20 until November. He is very young. Must have just scraped in as an 18 year old in the 2014 draft by days.
Darcy Moore, De Goey will be in our best 22 next year.
Wayne Arnold
Club Legend
- Jun 15, 2012
- 1,776
- 3,153
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
- Other Teams
- ASADA, Good Thymosin, Prahran U 9s
- Banned
- #30,094
I think it's best to wait and look at the whole trade period to see if we've done well or paid too much. Just looking at one deal in isolation isn't the best way to make a judgement. If we land all three players and still have a second and third round pick this year, then I'll be happy.
- May 7, 2011
- 59,398
- 14,052
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
- Other Teams
- Celtics, Tottenham, Oakland Raiders
For one trade - our strike rate isn't very good!
- Apr 20, 2015
- 6,653
- 10,470
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
To be fair this thread has been open long before trade period even started
tassiemaniac
Debutant
Surely Treloar is the pearl?
Why on earth did we hav to involve 3 other clubs. Crows always wanted to swap 32 for seedsman. Deal done
Doing a trade for the sake of doing a trade is not good trading. Kennedy was under contract too ffs, that should of given us even more bargaining power.
We caved
Obviously, but getting a better deal out of this trade is important considering we just had our ass handed to us in todays trade
- Status
