Preview Collingwood v Geelong, 17 March 7.40pm

[timokane]

FB: Murphy Moore Howe
CB: N Daicos Frampton Maynard
C: Pendles Crisp J Daicos
CF: Hill McStay Adams
FF: Elliott Michochek Side
R: Cameron De Goey Mitchell
INT: Cox WHE Carmicheal McCreery

 

[timokane]

If Frampton doesnt play then play either Marcov or even say Kelly there at chb.

 

[Gone Critical]

FB: Murphy Moore Howe
CB: N Daicos Frampton Maynard
C: Pendles Crisp J Daicos
CF: Hill McStay Adams
FF: Elliott Michochek Side
R: Cameron De Goey Mitchell
INT: Cox WHE Carmicheal McCreery

You need Noble in. He is a certainty

 

[Timmy from Thomastown]

I highly doubt we will play all of frampton/Murphy and Cameron/cox. One will have to give way. I’m inclined to stick with a more proven undersized Murphy ahead of frampton at this early stage.

Similarly I think they will stick with the proven formula in the ruck and play both.

 

[Eric Shin]

FB: Murphy Moore Howe
CB: N Daicos Frampton Maynard
C: Pendles Crisp J Daicos
CF: Hill McStay Adams
FF: Elliott Michochek Side
R: Cameron De Goey Mitchell
INT: Cox WHE Carmicheal McCreery

Nice side, but need to find room for Quaynor and Noble in there


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com

 

[Finnishpie]

or Jack Watts when everyone Tackles the Sook

Or Byron Pickett hip and shoulder into the shadow realms.....

 

[TheGreatGrundy]

Nice side, but need to find room for Quaynor and Noble in there


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com

Who would you take out of the side for Quaynor and Noble?

 

[Bianconeri]

Who would you take out of the side for Quaynor and Noble?

Carmichael and Murphy

Why would anyone even contemplate leaving two of our best rebounders out of the side?

 

[The Magnificent Seven]

Who would you take out of the side for Quaynor and Noble?

I'd swap WHE for Noble and make him emergency

 

[Jen2310]

Getting pretty confident it'll line up like this player wise.

Maynard. Frampton. Howe
Quaynor. Moore. NDaicos
Sidebottom. Mitchell. JDaicos
Hill. McStay. Adams
Elliott. Mihocek. McCreery
Cameron. De Goey. Crisp
Pendes. WHE. Cox. Noble
Sub: Reef/Carmichael

 

[TheGreatGrundy]

Getting pretty confident it'll line up like this player wise.

Maynard. Frampton. Howe
Quaynor. Moore. NDaicos
Sidebottom. Mitchell. JDaicos
Hill. McStay. Adams
Elliott. Mihocek. McCreery
Cameron. De Goey. Crisp
Pendes. WHE. Cox. Noble
Sub: Reef/Carmichael

So no Murphy? What if Hawkins doesn't play?

 

[Fat Jesus]

I'd swap WHE for Noble and make him ememergency

WHE is our best runner. No way he will be sub.
Same with Noble.
Carmichael sub.

 

[Jen2310]

So no Murphy? What if Hawkins doesn't play?

Don’t think it really matters. Frampton will just allow Howe and Moore to play naturally. But this is going off today. Still a few days before the main session going into selection for round 1 things could change


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[Eric Shin]

Who would you take out of the side for Quaynor and Noble?

OUT: Murphy, Carmichael
IN: Noble, Quaynor

Murphy is stiff but WHE is too versatile to leave out.


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com

 

[Wearmouth]

FB: Murphy Moore Howe
CB: N Daicos Frampton Maynard
C: Pendles Crisp J Daicos
CF: Hill McStay Adams
FF: Elliott Michochek Side
R: Cameron De Goey Mitchell
INT: Cox WHE Carmicheal McCreery

I’m not really too fussed about Noble.

But IQ is another thing altogether. He is one of the non negotiable’s. He is in our top 10 let alone the top 23.

I would dump one of,
Sidey
WHE
Carmichael
Hill
Mitchell
Adams
Murphy
Howe
Frampton

Before allowing IQ to not be named.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

[iGNITER]

Getting pretty confident it'll line up like this player wise.

Maynard. Frampton. Howe
Quaynor. Moore. NDaicos
Sidebottom. Mitchell. JDaicos
Hill. McStay. Adams
Elliott. Mihocek. McCreery
Cameron. De Goey. Crisp
Pendes. WHE. Cox. Noble
Sub: Reef/Carmichael

Agreed. Reckon that will be the 22 come game day.

 

[thommo_legend]

Menegola, Henry and Kolodjashij all ruled out. Duncan and Hawkins unlikely, its a must win now

 

[The Magnificent Seven]

WHE is our best runner. No way he will be sub.
Same with Noble.
Carmichael sub.

Yeah I know he runs a ridiculous amount to help make better emergency escapes from the back-line.

But in the scenario above it would be better, as it means you still have Noble, Daicos, Maynard, Howe and Crisp all able to offer run and a damaging kick outside of D50 and WHE's role is not as critical.

WHE's role will be purely to balance team structure as the year wears on and I reckon he'll drift in and out of the side based on our opponents and tactics. He's still a very handy weapon with his ability to fly and mark, run like he stole something and be damaging by foot around goal.

 

[TradeDraft]

Menegola, Henry and Kolodjashij all ruled out. Duncan and Hawkins unlikely, its a must win now

Henry too scared to play against us

 

[Timmy from Thomastown]

So no Murphy? What if Hawkins doesn't play?

Frampton out then as a late change

 

[Timmy from Thomastown]

Getting pretty confident it'll line up like this player wise.

Maynard. Frampton. Howe
Quaynor. Moore. NDaicos
Sidebottom. Mitchell. JDaicos
Hill. McStay. Adams
Elliott. Mihocek. McCreery
Cameron. De Goey. Crisp
Pendes. WHE. Cox. Noble
Sub: Reef/Carmichael

That’s almost spot on, depending upon the frampton/Murphy dilemma

Players like noble and WHE and IQ are certainties and people leaving them out have rocks in their heads. Outside chance one of them might becsub but I’d doubt even that. I’d like Reef to be sub over Carmichael but that’s just a personal choice. Both good options, Carmichael maybe safer but reef might be a game changer

 

[stormskye]

Henry too scared to play against us

His brother mate

 

[TradeDraft]

His brother mate

Okay. There are 2 Henry's and I thought you meant the Sook Olie

 

[Timmy from Thomastown]

Okay. There are 2 Henry's and I thought you meant the Sook Olie

Nah it’s the good one

 

[Mick F]

Menegola, Henry and Kolodjashij all ruled out. Duncan and Hawkins unlikely, its a must win now

The pleasing aspect of the first round is that they are no certainties.