D3 D3 Section 2008

Remove this Banner Ad

Status
Not open for further replies.

Log in to remove this ad.

hawkner said:
well congratulations to edwards, by shutting down big ogge for a half he let his team go down by more than double their score.

unlike power house, hawthorn dont rely on one player
Click to expand...


Reminder: Power House beat league leader Willy without Eddo 1 and 1/2 weeks ago, so your argument doesn't stack up.

Yes, the House had a tough day at the office on Saturday, however the House will bounce back.
 
vegemite said:
Reminder: Power House beat league leader Willy without Eddo 1 and 1/2 weeks ago, so your argument doesn't stack up.

Yes, the House had a tough day at the office on Saturday, however the House will bounce back.
Click to expand...

Reminder: Hawthorn also beat league leader Willy, so i cant really see your point
 
hawkner said:
Reminder: Hawthorn also beat league leader Willy, so i cant really see your point
Click to expand...


I have another reminder in my memory bank, however unlike your good self, I am not a cocky fool who believes that it means anything or that the premiership is a forgone conclusion.

When would you like the cup delivered?
 
Coach Hollywood said:
Gas,
Yeah struggling with Injuries at present but can't use that as a excuse for playing complacent football on the weekend and Monash were the better team on the day. Still happy with 6/8 wins at home and 3 wins away with Swinburne this week and UHS at home last round we're still expecting to play finals, which was our goal at the start of the season so nothing to worry about at the moment! 8-10 players back over the next 2 weeks also, so looking forward to this weekend!!!

As for finals talk, Powerhouse have La Trobe this week & then Elsternwick and 1 win will guarantee them finals and we have Swinburne & UHS.
Monash & Elsternwick would have to win both or hope for Either of us to lose both and they play Hawthorn & Willy away this week so I'd suggest we need some major upsets for the 4 to change in my opinion! Let's see what happens this weekend and good luck to all..:thumbsu:
Click to expand...

Coach another one following instructions but got caught????

From August 2

*John Galvin, Eltham. Attempting to strike, 1 match.

:thumbsdown:

​
 
get_a_kick said:
Being a first year player in D3, I have read and been quite amused by this forum but it has become a bit boring in the last few weeks probably for three reasons:
1. A couple of teams being out of the finals race
2. The Hawks being genuine contenders which wouldn't sit well with most of you - and yes I play at Hawthorn
3. Most of the contributors don't actually know what they are talking about and have realised this. (I can't wait to get replies on this one!!)

There has been much talk about different players and how good they are (with most not living up to hype) so I thought I would try and spark a bit of debate on the genuine top 10 players that we have played in D3 this year.
Here are mine:
1. L. Piccolo (Haw)
2. J. Wong (Willy)
3. R. Ogge (Haw)
4. D. Lee (Willy)
5. D. Burnside (PHouse)
6. Rutherford (Monash)
7. Gorringe (UHS)
8. B. Mahony (E'Wick) I think its "B"
9. D Pritchard (Haw)
10. P Edwards (PHouse)

Your thoughts please gentlemen.
Click to expand...


Piccolo at No.1????? what have you been smoking????

He has played 16 games and has been in your best 3 times.....those 3 games must have been good!!

Anyone with half a football brain knows Edwards is higher than 10!!
 
FootyFan27 said:
Piccolo at No.1????? what have you been smoking????

He has played 16 games and has been in your best 3 times.....those 3 games must have been good!!

Anyone with half a football brain knows Edwards is higher than 10!!
Click to expand...


I should have explained myself a little clearer......performance based on THIS YEAR you peanut. I haven't had the pleasure of playing in this grade for 10 years so my opinion is based upon what I have seen this year. If you want to rank players in regards to what they have done previously then I probably couldn't comment.
In regards to Piccolo, you obviously haven't seen any of our games. If you had, someone with half a football brain might tend to agree with me. I haven't seen Rutherford's name in the best for Monash too often either but he is clearly one of the best onballers in the comp.
 
get_a_kick said:
I should have explained myself a little clearer......performance based on THIS YEAR you peanut. I haven't had the pleasure of playing in this grade for 10 years so my opinion is based upon what I have seen this year. If you want to rank players in regards to what they have done previously then I probably couldn't comment.
In regards to Piccolo, you obviously haven't seen any of our games. If you had, someone with half a football brain might tend to agree with me. I haven't seen Rutherford's name in the best for Monash too often either but he is clearly one of the best onballers in the comp.
Click to expand...


Performance THIS YEAR you say??.....Piccolo.....He has been in Hawthorns best in 3 games....that means 13 games he has not been in their best....?? Dont follow your argument there.....For a guy you rate as best in the competition i would have thought he needed a few more games in the best players!! Maybe we wait and see how many votes he gets in the league B&F this yr??

As per Rutherford.....havent followed his progress but if he hasnt been in Monash best too often THIS YEAR then your argument as one of the best onballers in the league is a bit strange....maybe he touched you guys up when you played??
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

FootyFan27 said:
Performance THIS YEAR you say??.....Piccolo.....He has been in Hawthorns best in 3 games....that means 13 games he has not been in their best....?? Dont follow your argument there.....For a guy you rate as best in the competition i would have thought he needed a few more games in the best players!! Maybe we wait and see how many votes he gets in the league B&F this yr??

As per Rutherford.....havent followed his progress but if he hasnt been in Monash best too often THIS YEAR then your argument as one of the best onballers in the league is a bit strange....maybe he touched you guys up when you played??
Click to expand...


Do you actually watch any games or just read the record??
Here's a tip - get to a game or two, watch these guys run around, then maybe you'll understand what I'm talking about.
If you think that you can work out who the dangerous players in each team are by reading the record, then my friend saying you have half a brain is over stating things immensely.
And another thing, my opinion is based upon what I have SEEN not READ...
 
FootyFan27 said:
As per Rutherford.....havent followed his progress but if he hasnt been in Monash best too often THIS YEAR then your argument as one of the best onballers in the league is a bit strange....maybe he touched you guys up when you played??
Click to expand...
I would doubt Rutherford will finish in Monash's top 5 players in this years B&F. Gomma will out poll him.
 
get_a_kick said:
Do you actually watch any games or just read the record??
Here's a tip - get to a game or two, watch these guys run around, then maybe you'll understand what I'm talking about.
If you think that you can work out who the dangerous players in each team are by reading the record, then my friend saying you have half a brain is over stating things immensely.
And another thing, my opinion is based upon what I have SEEN not READ...
Click to expand...

Gee...you must be pretty good to watch every game every weekend.... and play as well....unless your name is Piccolo??
 
FootyFan27 said:
Gee...you must be pretty good to watch every game every weekend.... and play as well....unless your name is Piccolo??
Click to expand...

Dear FootyFan27, thank-you for replying to my posts. My intention was to stimulate some debate and i am glad you have taken interest in it.
Unfortunately you read my posts but you haven't understood them as you have clearly missed the point. My top 10 players is from what I have seen and I what I interpret as a quality player. I have never stated or inferred that I have seen each and every game.
I'll put it this way for you - based upon what I have seen this year, they would be my top 10 players I would pick in my team.
Just my opinion tiger.
 
get_a_kick said:
Dear FootyFan27, thank-you for replying to my posts. My intention was to stimulate some debate and i am glad you have taken interest in it.
Unfortunately you read my posts but you haven't understood them as you have clearly missed the point. My top 10 players is from what I have seen and I what I interpret as a quality player. I have never stated or inferred that I have seen each and every game.
I'll put it this way for you - based upon what I have seen this year, they would be my top 10 players I would pick in my team.
Just my opinion tiger.
Click to expand...


no problems - i completely understand where you're coming from....i was just stating what i have seen also. Everyone has different opinions!
 
get_a_kick said:
Being a first year player in D3, I have read and been quite amused by this forum but it has become a bit boring in the last few weeks probably for three reasons:
1. A couple of teams being out of the finals race
2. The Hawks being genuine contenders which wouldn't sit well with most of you - and yes I play at Hawthorn
3. Most of the contributors don't actually know what they are talking about and have realised this. (I can't wait to get replies on this one!!)

There has been much talk about different players and how good they are (with most not living up to hype) so I thought I would try and spark a bit of debate on the genuine top 10 players that we have played in D3 this year.
Here are mine:
1. L. Piccolo (Haw)
2. J. Wong (Willy)
3. R. Ogge (Haw)
4. D. Lee (Willy)
5. D. Burnside (PHouse)
6. Rutherford (Monash)
7. Gorringe (UHS)
8. B. Mahony (E'Wick) I think its "B"
9. D Pritchard (Haw)
10. P Edwards (PHouse)

Your thoughts please gentlemen.
Click to expand...
Well, you are right. Most of us are over the bragging of the season. And Yes. Hawthorn are in the mix for a flag. But, history has a habit of repeating....So. Jonny-come-lately, if we don't know what we are talking about, we'll see. Shall we? Any, Pichandle, or whowever you are, seeing that we forum posters are not as knowledgeable as you say you are, please enlighten us.

Your selections for top ten are probably picked out of the amateur footballer.
Who is going to win the D3 B&F? What does your crystal ball say?
 
sidewinder said:
GET A KICK, I'll paraphrase it for you.
Go to your corner and get out your spankerchief!
Palmerfan!
Click to expand...


I was going to give you a decent bake in a post but then I realised that you don't actually play, and you probably never played at a decent level so I won't waste my time...
In regards to reading the record, try and think up your own material and stop stealing mine you peanut....
 
get_a_kick said:
I was going to give you a decent bake in a post but then I realised that you don't actually play, and you probably never played at a decent level so I won't waste my time...
In regards to reading the record, try and think up your own material and stop stealing mine you peanut....
Click to expand...

What are your football credentials get_a_kick??
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Remove this Banner Ad

Similar threads

Mr Platinum
A Section Premier A 2025
2 3 4
Replies
93
Views
11K
XXXXAFL
X
J
C Section Premier C 2025
2 3 4
Replies
83
Views
7K
bedford
B
S
B Section Premier B - 2025
2 3
Replies
70
Views
7K
SeaSide
SeaSide
Mr Platinum
A Section Premier Section 2024
24 25 26 27 28
Replies
698
Views
105K
XXXXAFL
X
B
B Section Premier B - 2024
15 16 17 18 19
Replies
451
Views
70K
Nvent
N

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top