Rioli is being traded for pick 6Pick 11 (or in that range) for Houston seems like a very straight forward trade to me
Houston is a far superior player to dan rioli.
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
AFLW 2024 - Round 6 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
Rioli is being traded for pick 6Pick 11 (or in that range) for Houston seems like a very straight forward trade to me
Rioli is being traded for pick 6
Houston is a far superior player to dan rioli.
Geez that’s a fair bit of money already tied up in servicing their back flank.Newman - 31 years 8 months
Docherty - 30 years 11 months
Saad - 30 years 2 months
Williams - 30 years
What an awful assessmentNewman - 31 years 8 months
Docherty - 30 years 11 months
Saad - 30 years 2 months
Williams - 30 years
Cincotta - 27 years 9 months - rated so highly by your club he's on the rookie list at almost 28 years old
Boyd - 26 years old - also rated so highly by your club he's on the rookie list at 26 years old
Add to that the fact that Wilson hasn't even played yet and could be a complete bust.
List management is about operating on a three year future forward window. So what will Carlton's halfback situation look like in three years time?
Newman, Docherty, Saad and Williams will be retired or close to the end and Cincotta and Boyd aren't good enough to be put on the main list.
So really, the real reason why Carlton don't want to pony up for Houston is because they thought that they would be winning a flag by now - Paddy Dow drafted with Pick 3 in 2017, Mitch McGovern traded for in 2018, Newman traded for and Kemp drafted in 2019, Saad traded for in 2020, Cerra traded for in 2021...
So what they want to do is address a future need (replace their aging half-backs with an elite kick) while still retaining a draft pick to address a current need.
The problem is, Port probably has exactly the same needs as Carlton does (as seen by the fact that we have played Narkle, McEntee and Evans in the forward line of a preliminary finalist over the course of the year), so the idea that we would even entertain accepting Pick 12 over Pick 11 in any transaction is absolutely delusional from a Carlton perspective.
Why should Port accept “fair value” while Richmond get overs for Rioli, when we paid overs for Soldo and when we paid overs for an ooc Esava after being rejected the year before?So... GC would be over paying for Rioli.
Not sure why hanging your hat on another clubs trading here.
Fair value for Houston would be around pick 8-15 for mine. Maybe a favourable swap of later picks too
No, no it won't.if Melbourne circle around and chase Houston, I'm done with my club. Even some dees supporters seem to be delusional enough to think that this would be a good decision. A future 1 is going to be a top 5 pick next year. We need to go full rebuild.
We've lost Neal-Bullen, and bringing in Tom Campbell and Wade Derksen. For heaven's sake. How has Tim lamb still got a job!
Yeah, let's trade in a gun because we think we're in the premiership window despite Oliver going off the rails, Petracca disgruntled and will be a distraction all year, May slowing down, Gawn a few years left, still no key forward to help Van Rooyen. The fact that we even chased Houston should mean that Tim Lamb should be instantly sacked.
Not trying to hard we won't deal pick 11, if pick 12 is obtainable for a F1 and chips and that satisfies port we will grab him otherwise we tried and move on to filling the real holes in our list.You that but they seem to.be trying to move a lot of pieces around to make it work
Why should Port accept “fair value” while Richmond get overs for Rioli, when we paid overs for Soldo and when we paid overs for an ooc Esava after being rejected the year before?
We always pay overs. It’s time Port actually gets overs for once, and Houston is the exact player they should take a stand on.
Well considering I do not have a seat at the trade table, no idea. Kinda up to list managers to decide what is fair.
From an outsider looking in:
Pick 11 + F2 for houston and f3 or 54
Noting that Houston is contracted, no need to trade.
Cannot really see Houston pushing the needle for Carlton though
It’s a media beat-up.Reports are that its between Carlton and north, with calrton being the frontrunner.
Or go back to his original trade request of Melbourne for 2 first roundersThere is no way they accept that. The steak knives need to be like pick 20.
Given how this has started it does seem like he either needs to get comfortable with playing for the Roos or staying.
Newman - 31 years 8 months
Docherty - 30 years 11 months
Saad - 30 years 2 months
Williams - 30 years
Cincotta - 27 years 9 months - rated so highly by your club he's on the rookie list at almost 28 years old
Boyd - 26 years old - also rated so highly by your club he's on the rookie list at 26 years old
Add to that the fact that Wilson hasn't even played yet and could be a complete bust.
List management is about operating on a three year future forward window. So what will Carlton's halfback situation look like in three years time?
Newman, Docherty, Saad and Williams will be retired or close to the end and Cincotta and Boyd aren't good enough to be put on the main list.
So really, the real reason why Carlton don't want to pony up for Houston is because they thought that they would be winning a flag by now - Paddy Dow drafted with Pick 3 in 2017, Mitch McGovern traded for in 2018, Newman traded for and Kemp drafted in 2019, Saad traded for in 2020, Cerra traded for in 2021...
So what they want to do is address a future need (replace their aging half-backs with an elite kick) while still retaining a draft pick to address a current need.
The problem is, Port probably has exactly the same needs as Carlton does (as seen by the fact that we have played Narkle, McEntee and Evans in the forward line of a preliminary finalist over the course of the year), so the idea that we would even entertain accepting Pick 12 over Pick 11 in any transaction is absolutely delusional from a Carlton perspective.
Carlton position seems to be we don’t need an elite HB so won’t pay.
This is why Carlton have been crap forever.
There is a real opportunity to add a genuine A grade player in their prime that will elevate their list and they baulk at paying the price.
Instead they overpay for genuine plodders.
This is your Shaun Burgoyne 2009 moment.
You'd get a big f*** right off, pick 5 on its own is an overpay let alone another first round pick.Or go back to his original trade request of Melbourne for 2 first rounders
On SM-G975F using BigFooty.com mobile app
Hopefully a port fan can also inform us of how many years he has left on his deal and how that exponentially increases his trade value. Surprised no one has mentioned that yet.Should be an easy trade. Pick 11 plus steak knives. But because of the teams involved, it won't be.
The thread should be fun. Hopefully we can find out know how old he is and how many AA's he has.
Carlton position seems to be we don’t need an elite HB so won’t pay.
Question is why bother pursuing a player and then putting forward a trade offer which is so far unders it could never be accepted.
Blues should just move on. They look like tyre kickers of the worst kind.
Pretty sure Houston is the one who has pursued Carlton.Carlton position seems to be we don’t need an elite HB so won’t pay.
Question is why bother pursuing a player and then putting forward a trade offer which is so far unders it could never be accepted.
Blues should just move on. They look like tyre kickers of the worst kind.
Should be an easy trade. Pick 11 plus steak knives. But because of the teams involved, it won't be.
He has a two year deal on the table from us.Until Carlton offer Owies a contract, isn't he worth absoutely nothing? He goes to delisted free agency if not offered a deal.
Our last trade was Matthew Lobbe?God no wonder Port are already sick of dealing with Carlton if this is how their supporters are acting
Car 54 where are you?If gc would accept port and Carlton's future second for luko I could see port doing that.
Port
Out Houston and 54
In pick 11 and luko
Carlton
Out pick 11 future 2nd
In
Houston pick 54
Gc
Out
Luko
In
Port future 2nd Carlton future 2nd
We're not pursuing him. He's pursuing us.Carlton position seems to be we don’t need an elite HB so won’t pay.
Question is why bother pursuing a player and then putting forward a trade offer which is so far unders it could never be accepted.
Blues should just move on. They look like tyre kickers of the worst kind.