In his draft year Arlo Draper was being pushed by a few as a 1st rounder and some even tried pushing for Murley in the 1st round, Harrison was always a late Pick I guess.
No one is perfect especially so called Draft experts
He's far from the worst ego wise, Pie 4 Life keeps calling himself "The messiah of draft watching"
That title is far too clunky, however if you're staring a cult following, I wouldn't be opposed to it.
you realise every single recruiting manager has made the same mistakes?
Nah, **** him
Tim English as a wing is another that springs to mind!!
He has publicly said he is better than full time recruiters.
Farren Ray says hi.
Knocking on a young guy for doing something that he loves, for no money, is a low act. Not to mention the fact that recruiting is an opinion based business. Having a crack at a guy for posting on Bigfooty, whilst you're also on Bigfooty is flawed logic. He watches more footy than you, so he knows more than you. That's a fact.
Kind of agree with this. Knightmare certainly had a significant ego but those are the types that you are drawn to as a casual poster. I admired the way he stuck his neck out hard on several youngsters ability early on in their careers.
And most of you guys do it for little (knightmare) or no money? (Davo, RMC, Etc.).Everyone in the draft watchers space makes mistakes, no one is at 100%, but I think we all strive to get close, Knightmare, RMC, Cal, the Hun, myself and others I would say are in the 90s percentile which I think is a good resource for people, picking out the odd error is bad form when people do great work sifting through hundreds of players each year, watching approx 100 games or more of these juniors and getting it approx 95% right, I think more respect should be shown to people who get off their ass do the work, answer the inane questions and have the balls to make calls, unlike most who are scared to make decisions, who copy others work, then bitch and whine, rant over
briztoon haha, it's amazing what happens when someone keeps you accountable. Don't throw stones when you live in a glass house.
Far out, I know draft experts can make mistakes but this one is actually pretty bad from Nightmare. Putting aside the misread on Quaynor, the most shocking thing is he's rating a guy (Gown) as a potential pick 13 (When Gown was picked at 60 and was delisted before playing a game). Just not quite sure you can be considered an expert and be this far off the mark.
huh? strange take my you. so melbourne took Toumpas at pick 4. so they aren't experts? freo took Liam Henry at pick 9, Ryley Dunn & Marcus Drum at pick 10, Michael Apeness at 17 etc. so they aren't experts? Carlton took Dow at 3 so they aren't experts? Literally every club has bad misses. So you either have a personal agenda against Nightmare or you just don't know the draft all that well.
A couple of points.
