Preview GRAND FINAL - Collingwood Magpies vs Brisbane Lions • Saturday 30 September 2023 • 2:30 PM • Melbourne Cricket Ground

Remove this Banner Ad

Status
Not open for further replies.

Log in to remove this ad.

With a nod to POBT (who stole the idea from Inside Football anyhow)... A power ranking of each teams likely best 22.

Note, these aren't matchups, just a ranking of importance for each team. Fair warning, I gave this about 5 minutes thought, so take it with a grain of salt. Or rip s**t out of it... your choice.

RankBrisbaneCollingwood
1​
AndrewsN. Daicos
2​
NealePendelbury
3​
DunkleyMoore
4​
DaniherJ.Daicos
5​
C. CameronDe Goey
6​
McInerneyMaynard
7​
ColemanSidebottom
8​
McCluggageD.Cameron
9​
McKennaCrisp
10​
ZorkoElliott
11​
GardinerMurphy
12​
HipwoodQuaynor
13​
StarcevichMihocek
14​
RaynerHowe
15​
BaileyMitchell
16​
LesterCox
17​
WilmotMcCreery
18​
BerryLipinski
19​
McCarthyHill
20​
Ah CheeHoskin-Elliott
21​
FletcherFrampton
22​
RobertsonMarkov

Bias aside, I think we've got an edge on raw talent, but we all know footy isn't always that simple. Collingwood at their best play greater than the sum of their parts.
To be honest I would probably have DeGoey as their most important player for them to have success.
So therefore is Dunkley our most important player in stopping him?
 
With a nod to POBT (who stole the idea from Inside Football anyhow)... A power ranking of each teams likely best 22.

Note, these aren't matchups, just a ranking of importance for each team. Fair warning, I gave this about 5 minutes thought, so take it with a grain of salt. Or rip s**t out of it... your choice.

RankBrisbaneCollingwood
1​
AndrewsN. Daicos
2​
NealePendelbury
3​
DunkleyMoore
4​
DaniherJ.Daicos
5​
C. CameronDe Goey
6​
McInerneyMaynard
7​
ColemanSidebottom
8​
McCluggageD.Cameron
9​
McKennaCrisp
10​
ZorkoElliott
11​
GardinerMurphy
12​
HipwoodQuaynor
13​
StarcevichMihocek
14​
RaynerHowe
15​
BaileyMitchell
16​
LesterCox
17​
WilmotMcCreery
18​
BerryLipinski
19​
McCarthyHill
20​
Ah CheeHoskin-Elliott
21​
FletcherFrampton
22​
RobertsonMarkov

Bias aside, I think we've got an edge on raw talent, but we all know footy isn't always that simple. Collingwood at their best play greater than the sum of their parts.
Bobby Hill should be above Mitchell. He’s potentially their 2nd/3rd best forward, and on his day be as dangerous as Cameron.
 
Bobby Hill should be above Mitchell. He’s potentially their 2nd/3rd best forward, and on his day be as dangerous as Cameron.
Yeah Hill to me is the one you don't want getting off the chain.

We've got some players in that 12-20 category who can be really dynamic on their day.

Just need a couple of those to have a day out.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

With a nod to POBT (who stole the idea from Inside Football anyhow)... A power ranking of each teams likely best 22.

Note, these aren't matchups, just a ranking of importance for each team. Fair warning, I gave this about 5 minutes thought, so take it with a grain of salt. Or rip s**t out of it... your choice.

RankBrisbaneCollingwood
1​
AndrewsN. Daicos
2​
NealePendelbury
3​
DunkleyMoore
4​
DaniherJ.Daicos
5​
C. CameronDe Goey
6​
McInerneyMaynard
7​
ColemanSidebottom
8​
McCluggageD.Cameron
9​
McKennaCrisp
10​
ZorkoElliott
11​
GardinerMurphy
12​
HipwoodQuaynor
13​
StarcevichMihocek
14​
RaynerHowe
15​
BaileyMitchell
16​
LesterCox
17​
WilmotMcCreery
18​
BerryLipinski
19​
McCarthyHill
20​
Ah CheeHoskin-Elliott
21​
FletcherFrampton
22​
RobertsonMarkov

Bias aside, I think we've got an edge on raw talent, but we all know footy isn't always that simple. Collingwood at their best play greater than the sum of their parts.
Lester a tad high 🙃
 
What's up with McCarthy's calf ?

Is he a farmer ?
Cow Beef GIF by Nutrena Feed
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Remove this Banner Ad

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top