Analysis Hawks 2022 Hypothetical trades (read the pinned post)

Remove this Banner Ad

Status
Not open for further replies.
  • Thread starter
  • Moderator
  • #2
Firstly, the "No Kane Cornes" Rule is back




 
Last edited by a moderator:
If he was better than Harry this year, it's only marginal. Harry is three years younger too.
Wouldn’t hurt to have options especially on the cheap with no real draft capital given up my point is if you saw those assessments you would think that’s a 600k Player not 350k
 
Wouldn’t hurt to have options especially on the cheap with no real draft capital given up my point is if you saw those assessments you would think that’s a 600k Player not 350k

Yeah but I think these days with an offensive wing like Amon, the others going to be defensive and drop back.

Harry is obviously rock solid defensively and interestingly Nash played as a defensive wing the last three rounds.

He's a perfect fit for Blues but Acres. And you're right, that's an amazing deal for them.
 

Log in to remove this ad.

If he was better than Harry this year, it's only marginal. Harry is three years younger too.

Acres was in All Australian form early. He absolutely destroyed us over there in Perth until he did his hamstring (I believe it was that game).

Carlton have done well here.
 
Dammit, i was progressing well through the 5 stages of grief, coming out of depression into acceptance and Tops and Mark Stevens had to go and give me hope again :'(
 
Acres was in All Australian form early. He absolutely destroyed us over there in Perth until he did his hamstring (I believe it was that game).

Carlton have done well here.

Very good pickup agree.

But stats can be misleading. Especially for wings that play in WA.

Acres (missed 4 games) didn't finish top 10 in Freo's BF and they've not battered an eyebrow to losing him, didn't think he was going to be best 22 next year by media reports. Hence the deal.

Acres really only started playing good AFL footy at 25, Harry had a really good year at 23 this year.

I'd rather Harry tbh. Especially opposite Amon.
 
Last edited:

(Log in to remove this ad.)

How bad is the media that they have read through this entire thread to find the link to Scrimmers

Media have reported every possible outcome now, so they will claim they got it right regardless. Throw enough darts and all that
Similar to the old ' its fluid and things change '

Sent from my SM-G960F using Tapatalk
 
Yep, it’s extraordinary. I would have thought we make a play for him and/or Hunt who went to WC as a FA.
The difference though is acres was marked as above average or elite in all main categories the us year. Hunt was average or below average. Acres would have been a great fit well done blues.

Im going to drop a sheckel on Carlton for the flag next year. They have that feeling about them for me.
 
This thread is giving me Cogs to Hawthorn flashbacks from 2020... think I need to call my therapist

I'm the same. Has a Cogs feel about it.
Nah, nothing like it for me. It's 50/50 where as with Cogs we had people saying it was a done deal and could "take it to the bank".
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Remove this Banner Ad

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top