-
AFLW 2024 - Round 10 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
Josh Fraser & the great ruck debate
- Thread starter Rustin Cohle
- Start date
- Tagged users None
Re: Josh Fraser - **** Off and Don't Come Back
How about we play someone WHO WANTS TO ****ING PLAY FOR COLLINWOOD.
We can ****ing keep Leigh ****ing Brown in as second ruck and give Jolly a spell whenever he has a run. **** if Miller can ruck against us, why not have Reid or Cloke ruck if we need to give Jolly a break. Certainly don't give this muppet another game.
Trade him for a ****ing Powerade so we actually get something positive out of it.
How about we play someone WHO WANTS TO ****ING PLAY FOR COLLINWOOD.
We can ****ing keep Leigh ****ing Brown in as second ruck and give Jolly a spell whenever he has a run. **** if Miller can ruck against us, why not have Reid or Cloke ruck if we need to give Jolly a break. Certainly don't give this muppet another game.
Trade him for a ****ing Powerade so we actually get something positive out of it.
Strachuniee
Team Captain
Re: Fraser - you are a disgrace
Really he shouldn't play again. Absolutely pitiful performance. Cannot understand how Wood was dropped for him. FFS he was beaten in the ruck by miller
Really he shouldn't play again. Absolutely pitiful performance. Cannot understand how Wood was dropped for him. FFS he was beaten in the ruck by miller
PieBeast
Brownlow Medallist
Re: Fraser - you are a disgrace
Where are all the Fraser defendants now? Up there with weakest blockes that ever represented Black and White. ****ing fuming that a soft**** like this gets a guernsey for us
Where are all the Fraser defendants now? Up there with weakest blockes that ever represented Black and White. ****ing fuming that a soft**** like this gets a guernsey for us
- Banned
- #30
Re: Josh Fraser - **** Off and Don't Come Back
I'll never forget seeing Fraser after he was a late withdrawal before that epic overtime final against west coast, laughing it up and acting like the happiest bloke in aus.. Thought it was a strange reaction for a guy who had just been ruled out of the biggest game of the year so far and who's team was 1 kick away from being in a granny. The guy is simply a pea heart
I'll never forget seeing Fraser after he was a late withdrawal before that epic overtime final against west coast, laughing it up and acting like the happiest bloke in aus.. Thought it was a strange reaction for a guy who had just been ruled out of the biggest game of the year so far and who's team was 1 kick away from being in a granny. The guy is simply a pea heart
PieBeast
Brownlow Medallist
Re: Josh Fraser - **** Off and Don't Come Back
I've hated the soft**** for years now. We can all thank Malthouse for continually playing him to justify his number one selection in the draft.
I've hated the soft**** for years now. We can all thank Malthouse for continually playing him to justify his number one selection in the draft.
- Banned
- #32
Josh Fraser - I don't know
What to say.
I like Josh, I believe early doors, MM ran him into the ground with no adequate support.
A year ago, before the Anzac Day, My Grandfather (son of Syd) spent a day with him when him, Lloydly & another vet were on the frontpage. All day he had his head down carrying on about not being awarded the captaincy.
Know Jolly's manager pretty well. Josh was absolutely roapable that we traded to get Jolly.
These 2 motives are a big reason why his sulking is costing the club. I've been attending matches since 1984 & that is the lamest effort I've seen from a Collingwood player.
Josh, you lost me today.
What to say.
I like Josh, I believe early doors, MM ran him into the ground with no adequate support.
A year ago, before the Anzac Day, My Grandfather (son of Syd) spent a day with him when him, Lloydly & another vet were on the frontpage. All day he had his head down carrying on about not being awarded the captaincy.
Know Jolly's manager pretty well. Josh was absolutely roapable that we traded to get Jolly.
These 2 motives are a big reason why his sulking is costing the club. I've been attending matches since 1984 & that is the lamest effort I've seen from a Collingwood player.
Josh, you lost me today.
Dicky_Knee
Team Captain
Re: Fraser - you are a disgrace
i concur - retire Josh you obviously have better things to do.
i concur - retire Josh you obviously have better things to do.
Re: Josh Fraser - **** Off and Don't Come Back
Did anyone see Jamar after the game? Absolutely shattered after rucking his heart out all day with basically no support. I wish Fraser could show some heart like that.
Did anyone see Jamar after the game? Absolutely shattered after rucking his heart out all day with basically no support. I wish Fraser could show some heart like that.
Re: Josh Fraser - **** Off and Don't Come Back
The Jamar mark and goal was plain awful in regard to Fraser. How he could let his opposite number get 40 metres ahead of him is astounding. I think all Pies fans should be rightly disgusted in him.
The Jamar mark and goal was plain awful in regard to Fraser. How he could let his opposite number get 40 metres ahead of him is astounding. I think all Pies fans should be rightly disgusted in him.
Re: Josh Fraser - **** Off and Don't Come Back
Don't think I've seen so many asterixes in a thread before haha.
Don't think I've seen so many asterixes in a thread before haha.
- Sep 25, 2006
- 18,365
- 14,636
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
- Other Teams
- FC Barcelona, Liverpool, FC Bayern
Re: Josh Fraser - **** Off and Don't Come Back
So Jamar rucked "his heart out" on his own and was shattered they lost.
Hmm.
Josh has rucked solo many times for years (not just 1 season) ala vs Dean Cox where he beat him and we even managed to win with Josh "rucking his heart out".
Some have short memories.
However, he was very poor today.
So Jamar rucked "his heart out" on his own and was shattered they lost.
Hmm.
Josh has rucked solo many times for years (not just 1 season) ala vs Dean Cox where he beat him and we even managed to win with Josh "rucking his heart out".
Some have short memories.
However, he was very poor today.
Re: Fraser - you are a disgrace
Is Dawes injured? Someone else mentioned he played reserves this week? From what I've seen of him he gives it his all, has plenty of mongrel and can kick a goal. Would've thought he'd be a better option than Brown, and/or Fraser for that matter?
Is Dawes injured? Someone else mentioned he played reserves this week? From what I've seen of him he gives it his all, has plenty of mongrel and can kick a goal. Would've thought he'd be a better option than Brown, and/or Fraser for that matter?
Re: Josh Fraser - **** Off and Don't Come Back
Yeh fair point, Fraser has shown plenty of heart rucking solo in the past. Today however he only has to ruck less than 50% yet Jamar manages to run off him when he's been rucking all day.
Yeh fair point, Fraser has shown plenty of heart rucking solo in the past. Today however he only has to ruck less than 50% yet Jamar manages to run off him when he's been rucking all day.
Re: Josh Fraser - **** Off and Don't Come Back
Couldn't agree more with OP.
Unfortunatley I've been saying it since about 2006 without any success so look forward to seeing him as #2 ruckman in 2014
Couldn't agree more with OP.
Unfortunatley I've been saying it since about 2006 without any success so look forward to seeing him as #2 ruckman in 2014
Re: Josh Fraser - **** Off and Don't Come Back
When was Fraser rucking his heart out against Cox? 4-5 years ago?
Short memories?
When was Fraser rucking his heart out against Cox? 4-5 years ago?
- Aug 17, 2009
- 29,156
- 26,026
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
- Other Teams
- Phila 76ers , Phila Eagles , Man U
Re: Fraser - you are a disgrace
Yeah he played on Saturday and kicked 5 goals. Would prefer him to do a bit of ruck then Fraser that's for sure.
Yeah he played on Saturday and kicked 5 goals. Would prefer him to do a bit of ruck then Fraser that's for sure.
Re: Fraser - you are a disgrace
Nothing new about today. Josh has been performing like this for the last 6 years. Posssibly played about 6 good games in the last 6 years.
The thing that the club never learned is that you should never recruit ruckmen who lack physical presence. Josh was bad enough in this aspect, but to then go and waste a number 14 pick on Wood, who has the same deficiency, it is easy to understand why we have 1 premiership in 50 years.
SO we call for Fraser to be dropped.....and bring in Wood??????? IMO, no difference either way.
Nothing new about today. Josh has been performing like this for the last 6 years. Posssibly played about 6 good games in the last 6 years.
The thing that the club never learned is that you should never recruit ruckmen who lack physical presence. Josh was bad enough in this aspect, but to then go and waste a number 14 pick on Wood, who has the same deficiency, it is easy to understand why we have 1 premiership in 50 years.
SO we call for Fraser to be dropped.....and bring in Wood??????? IMO, no difference either way.
mattys123
Hall of Famer
- Mar 24, 2008
- 31,426
- 20,284
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
- Other Teams
- LAK, NUFC, SAS, SFGiants, 49ers,
Re: Josh Fraser - **** Off and Don't Come Back
I am usually "Mr Positive" when it comes to our players, but my patience has run out with Josh Fraser.
That last goal to Jamar was a ****ing disgrace.
He left Jamar alone in the middle to handball twice, then didn't follow him forward and let him mark easily.
Fraser was 40 metres off his direct opponent.
First time all year I have uttered something similar to the thread title to a Collingwood player, and oh yeah, Jaxson Barham can join him.
I am usually "Mr Positive" when it comes to our players, but my patience has run out with Josh Fraser.
That last goal to Jamar was a ****ing disgrace.
He left Jamar alone in the middle to handball twice, then didn't follow him forward and let him mark easily.
Fraser was 40 metres off his direct opponent.
First time all year I have uttered something similar to the thread title to a Collingwood player, and oh yeah, Jaxson Barham can join him.
macleodboy07
Senior List
Re: Fraser - you are a disgrace
fraser......................oh dear..........thats all that can be said.
and this
...........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
you are one sorry exuse for a player these days. u may of got away with playing the way u do when we were losing week in week out but now this side is trying to go places and u are standing in the way. like really u just stand there and do nothing!
please just go away and never come back.
the plan fact i would rather brown in the side then u just shows how bad u have gotten. at least with brown we no we will get a contest. with u fraser u just take up space and do NOTHING!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
fraser......................oh dear..........thats all that can be said.
and this
...........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
you are one sorry exuse for a player these days. u may of got away with playing the way u do when we were losing week in week out but now this side is trying to go places and u are standing in the way. like really u just stand there and do nothing!
please just go away and never come back.
the plan fact i would rather brown in the side then u just shows how bad u have gotten. at least with brown we no we will get a contest. with u fraser u just take up space and do NOTHING!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Re: Josh Fraser - **** Off and Don't Come Back
I am going to buy into total negativity and say that Josh Fraser should never wear a Collingwood jumper again. He is totally gutless and does not put any physical pressure on the opposition. He never takes a contested mark and he does not put any goal-scoring pressure on the opposition. As Dermot Brereton said on te SEN tonight, he was very disappointing! End of story. I would play either Cameron Wood for every game for the rest of the year, or alternatively play Leigh Brown and Chris Dawes as a combination of back-up ruckmen and/or key forwards. But never, never, never, never, ever again Fraser!!!!!!!
