Marsh Community Series Discussion Thread

[Hai_Newman]

Convinced my mate to join.

Give him a nice Bigfooty sc board welcome lads

Rano83

He's smart enough to never listen to any SC advice i give him too.

Rano83 post puppies

 

[Leftyitis]

Steven looks a little unfit, but a gun. Going to miss him at the saints badly. I’ve locked him in

 

[Gysberts2Bate]

Very easy Smith to Steven move

****

 

[Deliverance]

Does freako still do his preseason newsletters?

 

[Leftyitis]

J Steven I think is a must have. The End!
I can't remember him ever being 'fit' looking. Same comments D Swan would receive. Both have had no problems finding the pill/ball.

 

[balmainforever]

Pretty ridiculous to assume he’ll score flat line 80’s the whole way through.
He has a fairly cruisy run to the bye. Only NN, Goldy and maybe Witts who could cause trouble. No Grundy, Gawn, Lycett, Marshall/Ryder at all.
Plus, it’s all about lowering his break even. I’d rather see a 60 followed by a ton than just 80 after 80 after 80.

It was a exercise only to work out what he’d be increasing in value. We all know that no one has ever scored the same every week.

 

[stevebbb]

J Steven I think is a must have. The End!
I can't remember him ever being 'fit' looking. Same comments D Swan would receive. Both have had no problems finding the pill/ball.

Dane Swan had no issue finding pills, that bloke was cooked every weekend

 

[Jiska]

Zerk Thatcher / Devon Smith / Jack Steven / Danger all still locks for me.

LOL.

 

[kananooks]

Naismith (80) + Whitfield (110) is better than Gawn (130) + fwd rookie (50)

no its not lol.

 

[Phoenix_9]

no its not lol.

I’ve gone Gawn and Brander over Whitfield and Naismith. Just safer to go with the majority. I’ll take my risks elsewhere.

 

[CrozaN]

Dane Swan had no issue finding pills, that bloke was cooked every weekend

Swan was a beast, i remember his 2016 year only scored under 100 once.

 

[nameless]

Swan was a beast, i remember his 2016 year only scored under 100 once.

Low blow

 

[Moustachio]

This game withstanding, he's a terrible SC scorer.

Seems fair to make that conclusion from 15 career games...

 

[Moustachio]

Love it how everyone automatically drops Gawn. He should be your R1.

Take his injury game against Brisbane out and he averaged 132.5 last year while Grundy averaged 130.

Then there's this:

What about take out the 200 in R23 when nobody cared?

What about take out that game where Grundy had an.ouchie and didn't deliver a quality score? O wait

 

[Seymour Skinner]

What about take out the 200 in R23 when nobody cared?

What about take out that game where Grundy had an.ouchie and didn't deliver a quality score? O wait

Why would you not care about the 200?

 

[VainGlorious]

Well they don't have any decent Senior players....

 

[Andrew Birch]

Seems fair to make that conclusion from 15 career games...

Has ZGuthrie put on 6kgs of muscle over this off season that I don't know about?

 

[Moustachio]

Why would you not care about the 200?

soft**** effort in R23. Give it to me when the season is on the line.

More seriously, it skews the average and if you looked at say a median score, Grundy comes out more appealing.

Mainly I wanted to argue with Uncle J

 

[Andrew Birch]

Gees, Zerk-Thatcher is interesting. Just put him in for Roberton and all of a sudden have a bucket of cash to play with. Worst case he gets dropped before his price rise and Stephen Hill comes back and it's a straight swap?

And what if Zerk is not dropped?

Going by the assumption that Hill won't miss any more than 3-4 weeks I'm toying with keeping him at D8/F8 depending on the Rd1 rookie situation. I figure a trade is worth more than 1 potential 25-30k price rise from a low scoring def/fwd bench rookie who in all likelihood will be dropped before he even plays 3 games. Can use Hill as a floating loophole donut with Brander across 2 lines in the short term to mitigate unacceptable D6/F6 scores. Downside is it ties up 65k.

 

[WaynesWorld19]

And what if Zerk is not dropped?

Going by the assumption that Hill won't miss any more than 3-4 weeks I'm toying with keeping him at D8/F8 depending on the Rd1 rookie situation. I figure a trade is worth more than 1 potential 25-30k price rise from a low scoring def/fwd bench rookie who in all likelihood will be dropped before he even plays 3 games. Can use Hill as a floating loophole donut with Brander across 2 lines in the short term to mitigate unacceptable D6/F6 scores. Downside is it ties up 65k.

Given Hills history with the same injury, do we believe this timeframe ......sounding like a Bennell calf scenario now

 

[Andrew Birch]

Given Hills history with the same injury, do we believe this timeframe ......sounding like a Bennell calf scenario now

In that scenario he remains a useful D/F loophole donut until a 'must have' (hopefully 123k or under) Def or Fwd bench rookie presents and is on the bubble and we make a 67-73k+ profit from it.

 

[WaynesWorld19]

In that scenario he remains a useful D/F loophole donut until a 'must have' (hopefully 123k or under) Def or Fwd bench rookie presents and is on the bubble and we make a 67-73k+ profit from it.

$190K is a lot to have sitting on your bench ....Hill makes a good trade down prospect upon his return, after his 2nd game ...to ensure he doesn't breakdown yet again

Different approaches ....each have merit

 

[Andrew Birch]

$190K is a lot to have sitting on your bench ....Hill makes a good trade down prospect upon his return, after his 2nd game ...to ensure he doesn't breakdown yet again

Different approaches ....each have merit

I started with 300k+ in the bank in the previous 2 seasons and currently have 230k in the bank with Hill on the bench. There are many ways to play this game, friend.

 

[Deliverance]

I started with 300k+ in the bank in the previous 2 seasons and currently have 230k in the bank with Hill on the bench. There are many ways to play this game, friend.

How many midpricers this year? I'm currently on 11, and liking the looks.

 

[Bollox]

Ok just got home missed the cats vs bombers game, how did steven look any others worth looking at

Half time they rolled him in flour and hosed the back of his shorts. Seemed to work.