List Mgmt. Mid-Season Draft - Who do we take?

[ManInTheArena]

Did he do his ACL last year?

Not that I can ascertain.

 

[spenze]

Nominations from South Australia

Jonathon Beech (West Adelaide), Jack Blair (North Adelaide), Luke Bogle (South Adelaide), Jordon Boyle (Adelaide), Lachlan Burrows (Sturt), Declan Carmody (North Gambier), Oscar Chapman (North Adelaide), Bradley Close (Glenelg), Sam Colquhoun (Sturt), Angus Coxon (Henley), Abe Davis (South Adelaide), Liam Fitt (South Adelaide), Jordan Foote (Woodville-West Torrens), Cory Gregson (Glenelg), Joseph Haines (South Adelaide), Jack Hayes (Woodville-West Torrens), Joshua Hone (Sturt), Lachie Hosie (Glenelg), Daniel Johnston (Norwood), Michael Knoll (South Adelaide), Mihail Lochowiak (Sturt), Jesse Lonergan (Woodville-West Torrens), Marlon Motlop (Glenelg), Hugo Munn (Sturt), Jydon Neagle (Central District), Matt Neagle (Central District), John Noble (West Adelaide), Mark Noble (South Adelaide), Matthew Nunn (Norwood), Luke Partington (Glenelg), Angus Rana (West Adelaide), Thomas Read (Sturt), Hayden Sampson (South Adelaide), Isaac Saywell (Norwood), Will Snelling (West Adelaide), Luke Surman (Norwood), Cameron Sutcliffe (Port Adelaide), Jimmy Toumpas (Woodville-West Torrens), Aidan Tropiano (North Adelaide), Matthew Uebergang (Glenelg)

Really hope we go Brad Close from Glenelg

 

[Geoffa32]

No nomination from Mitch Grigg?

Sent from my SM-G930F using Tapatalk

 

[Squiba]

Sampson developable as a small defender?

 

[diligaf473]

Sampson developable as a small defender?

No

 

[diligaf473]

Abe Davis to the Saints

 

[Apsaalooke]

Nominations from South Australia

Jonathon Beech (West Adelaide), Jack Blair (North Adelaide), Luke Bogle (South Adelaide), Jordon Boyle (Adelaide), Lachlan Burrows (Sturt), Declan Carmody (North Gambier), Oscar Chapman (North Adelaide), Bradley Close (Glenelg), Sam Colquhoun (Sturt), Angus Coxon (Henley), Abe Davis (South Adelaide), Liam Fitt (South Adelaide), Jordan Foote (Woodville-West Torrens), Cory Gregson (Glenelg), Joseph Haines (South Adelaide), Jack Hayes (Woodville-West Torrens), Joshua Hone (Sturt), Lachie Hosie (Glenelg), Daniel Johnston (Norwood), Michael Knoll (South Adelaide), Mihail Lochowiak (Sturt), Jesse Lonergan (Woodville-West Torrens), Marlon Motlop (Glenelg), Hugo Munn (Sturt), Jydon Neagle (Central District), Matt Neagle (Central District), John Noble (West Adelaide), Mark Noble (South Adelaide), Matthew Nunn (Norwood), Luke Partington (Glenelg), Angus Rana (West Adelaide), Thomas Read (Sturt), Hayden Sampson (South Adelaide), Isaac Saywell (Norwood), Will Snelling (West Adelaide), Luke Surman (Norwood), Cameron Sutcliffe (Port Adelaide), Jimmy Toumpas (Woodville-West Torrens), Aidan Tropiano (North Adelaide), Matthew Uebergang (Glenelg)

Wow some of those are extremely speculative. Hope the application fee wasn't too steep. Jimmy Toumpas? Marlon Motlop?

 

[CutAboveTheRest]

Is that Jesse Lonergan ex GCS playing for WWT?

 

[Dudersaurus]

No, he's said when asked that if he wasn't good enough before and his SANFL GF wasn't enough to get drafted, he won't get picked up now.

No nomination from Mitch Grigg?

Sent from my SM-G930F using Tapatalk

 

[ams4crows]

Hugo Munn could become the KPP defender that we're lacking. Talia aint gonna last forever, Otten is over the Hill, Hartigan is mediocre thank god we unearthed Keath but he's already 27

 

[Sidthehat]

AFL.com.au were talking up Michael Talia as a pick few weeks ago.

 

[Bicks]

Is that Jesse Lonergan ex GCS playing for WWT?

Indeed. WWT's new coach Sam Lonergan is his Uncle

 

[chazwazza]

This is f***ed. Consider if Sturt had Munn and Read drafted which is a possibility that would be season over, throw in Sam Colquhoun who racked up 40 disposals last week and you may as well shut the doors for the year.
What a c*** of an idea to impose on the State League stand alone clubs that gain no benefit whatsoever and against their will.
**** you AFL. Go **** a goat

 

[craig crowing]

Sorry chazzwaza I believe without seeing a lot of ,that Mann is the type of pick up we need short term and long term.

 

[Jarman3]

This is f***ed. Consider if Sturt had Munn and Read drafted which is a possibility that would be season over, throw in Sam Colquhoun who racked up 40 disposals last week and you may as well shut the doors for the year.
What a c*** of an idea to impose on the State League stand alone clubs that gain no benefit whatsoever and against their will.
**** you AFL. Go **** a goat

My objection is more that the mid season draft gives an unfair advantage to (AFL) teams that cop injuries in the first half of the season vs those who cop them later. Any team that loses a player up to the week of the draft has the opportunity to draft a replacement. Lose a player the week after the draft, and you just have to go a man short for the rest of the year. There are plenty of opportunities to assemble your list during the off season. Once the season starts, you should have to go with the list you've got.

 

[Fivel_79]

My objection is more that the mid season draft gives an unfair advantage to (AFL) teams that cop injuries in the first half of the season vs those who cop them later. Any team that loses a player up to the week of the draft has the opportunity to draft a replacement. Lose a player the week after the draft, and you just have to go a man short for the rest of the year. There are plenty of opportunities to assemble your list during the off season. Once the season starts, you should have to go with the list you've got.

Maybe they should just have a list of younger players (Under 23) or something like that outside the main list that clubs can develop and call on if injury strikes?

They could call it a Rookie list, it’s crazy enough it might just work.

What am I saying? The AFL would just twist it so far away from its original concept that they’d need to come up with something else half baked.

 

[chazwazza]

Sorry chazzwaza I believe without seeing a lot of ,that Mann is the type of pick up we need short term and long term.

You can have Mann, it’s Munn that I’m concerned about.

 

[Crowbots are dead]

Given our conservative selection policy why would we do this as they’d have no chance of playing in the firsts

 

[Houston]

Given our conservative selection policy why would we do this as they’d have no chance of playing in the firsts

It's basically a free swing to see how a mature aged player can develop in an AFL environment. We'd be mad not to at least have a look at someone if they're even a 10% of reaching depth standard.

 

[Footypie32]

Definitely think we should take a KPD if anyone one. We're good for Forwards and Midfielders. Don't think you'd find any worthwhile Rucks.

 

[Mego Red]

I think it would be good to have a look at Hugo Munn.

Bring him in, get a sense of what he has, and keep him or not at the end of the year based on what he shows.

 

[Bicks]

I think it would be good to have a look at Hugo Munn.

Bring him in, get a sense of what he has, and keep him or not at the end of the year based on what he shows.

What's the point, unless he plays AFL he has to play for Sturt doen't he?

Hardly setting the World on fire for Sturt either, 5 Disposal, 4 kicks, 1 handball, 3 marks, 2 Hit Outs against the roosters

 

[Mego Red]

What's the point, unless he plays AFL he has to play for Sturt doen't he?

Hardly setting the World on fire for Sturt either, 5 Disposal, 4 kicks, 1 handball, 3 marks, 2 Hit Outs against the roosters

Why would a draftee keep playing for their previous team??

Whoever we draft would immediately come into our system, surely.

 

[Bicks]

Why would a draftee keep playing for their previous team??

Whoever we draft would immediately come into our system, surely.

That's not my understanding of how it works, the players club in this case Sturt would have to agree.

https://www.afl.com.au/news/2019-02-07/midseason-draft-when-is-it-and-how-will-it-work

How will state league clubs be compensated for losing a player?
It's understood AFL clubs will be made to provide them with a reimbursement. That could include a payment of up to 50 percent of any sign-on bonus given to the player by their state league club.
The League has also moved to offset state league clubs' concerns by introducing a number of conditions.
A player drafted from a state league will not be asked to play against their original club unless all parties agreed. For example, should Williamstown defender Sam McLarty be selected by Carlton, he will not be allowed to represent the Blues' VFL-affiliated Northern Blues against Williamstown, unless the Seagulls approve.
State league players also have the ability to return to their original club to participate in finals if their AFL club's season is over.

 

[Relaxed]

That's not my understanding of how it works, the players club in this case Sturt would have to agree.

https://www.afl.com.au/news/2019-02-07/midseason-draft-when-is-it-and-how-will-it-work

How will state league clubs be compensated for losing a player?
It's understood AFL clubs will be made to provide them with a reimbursement. That could include a payment of up to 50 percent of any sign-on bonus given to the player by their state league club.
The League has also moved to offset state league clubs' concerns by introducing a number of conditions.
A player drafted from a state league will not be asked to play against their original club unless all parties agreed. For example, should Williamstown defender Sam McLarty be selected by Carlton, he will not be allowed to represent the Blues' VFL-affiliated Northern Blues against Williamstown, unless the Seagulls approve.
State league players also have the ability to return to their original club to participate in finals if their AFL club's season is over.

Bicks - think you may be reading this wrong?
Mid-season draft takes place on May 27th.
If Crows picked up Munn from Sturt, then for SANFL RD 11, (June 29th) the SANFL Crows would not be allowed to field Munn against Sturt, unless Sturt agreed to let him play.
If the AFL Crows were out of finals contention after the 24th of August and the AFL season was done, but Sturt had made the SANFL finals, then Munn would be able to go back and play for Sturt for the SANFL finals series if Sturt wanted him back, even if the SANFL Crows also made the finals against Sturt.