"At the same age" we'd have to wait until 2025 for Sheezel perhapsTo be in the discussion (which I admit to being still unsure of your rationale behind putting him in it), I'd expect him to have some sort of impact in votes. At the same stage in their second seasons, Daicos was clearly in the lead of the coaches MVP, and likely would have won it barring a late season injury. Sheezel isn't in the top twenty.
Is age the number 1 factor? No, but early on and until both players find some form of mature, it's an important factor
Sheezel 2024, Goatie 2022, both playing the entire year as 19 year oldsIn continuation of the above, your assertion that we must consider Sheezel a first year player when compared to 'Goatie' is disingenuous. The fact he is 9 months younger doesn't make him a first year player, it makes him a younger second year player with two full pre-seasons behind him.
If people troll, I'll respond in kind, but prefer balanced footy debatesAppreciate your candour. I don't rate Walsh the best player in his draft either (though he's not too far off it). Slightly less, but still somewhat sceptical given you're such a prolific contributor to this thread. Not quite top 4, but top 5 (if you'll allow it).
Happy to discuss any player, or previous thoughtsReveals a certain passion or revulsion for the subject matter which suggests anything but neutrality, and I suspect it's not related to Harry Sheezel.
List Mgmt. - Carlton's 2018 Draft Thread (cont. in Part 2)
How many list spots do we have available? Out: Byrne, Lamb, Graham, Kerridge, ASOS (rookie), Rowe, JGM (rookie), Wright. In: setterfield, mcgovern, fasolo, Newman Does that leave 2 list spots and 2 rookie spots? Don’t we need to draft 3 players minumum in national draft or van that be over...
www.bigfooty.com