-
AFLW 2024 - Round 10 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
Official Trade Thread.
- Thread starter Iva Bigun
- Start date
- Tagged users None
- Status
Navicular bone injury (foot).
Sunny_
Brownlow Medallist
As TBD said, the talk about Caddy's father have been greatly exaggerated. That journo Robbo has made this a huge mess.
Long story short, if he goes, the only place he will go to is Essendon. This is because the Bombers have put a huge amount of cash on the table for him. Something I'm not sure the Suns will be able to match with his second contract renewal. Hirdy is very keen on him.
With that said, Essendon will have to do something pretty major I think to get him this year. Might just have to wait 12 months to snag him, unless we opt to keep him, which I'm not sure we should anymore.
By the time we lose Caddy next year through out of contract circumstances, we'll gain access to O'Meara. We'd clear up some cap room as well as list space. Club is no doubt thinking about this.
Long story short, if he goes, the only place he will go to is Essendon. This is because the Bombers have put a huge amount of cash on the table for him. Something I'm not sure the Suns will be able to match with his second contract renewal. Hirdy is very keen on him.
With that said, Essendon will have to do something pretty major I think to get him this year. Might just have to wait 12 months to snag him, unless we opt to keep him, which I'm not sure we should anymore.
By the time we lose Caddy next year through out of contract circumstances, we'll gain access to O'Meara. We'd clear up some cap room as well as list space. Club is no doubt thinking about this.
Sunny_
Brownlow Medallist
Sorry Teff, edited my post. Explained a bit more.
A lot changes when they play a couple of games, actually feel part of things.
Hamilton/Ashcroft have confirmed talks are still alive.
All depends on who Brisbane rate. They were one of the clubs who expressed interest for Jenkins, last week.
- Banned
- #209
Yeah right.
It's just a coincidence that he happens to be a one eyed Essendon supporter.
On the table?
How much is "under" the table?
Other clubs need to step up to the plate.
supernova_
Premiership Player
Ashcroft on the radio now.
Confirmed he wants to head back to Melb, and has only had talks with Essendon. Other clubs are welcome to chat, but Essendon is the only club in talks at present. I dont think it's an actual case of Caddy nominating Essendon as people have said. I just think they are the first club to offer some decent coin.
Confirmed he wants to head back to Melb, and has only had talks with Essendon. Other clubs are welcome to chat, but Essendon is the only club in talks at present. I dont think it's an actual case of Caddy nominating Essendon as people have said. I just think they are the first club to offer some decent coin.
Yeah right.
It's just a coincidence that he happens to be a one eyed Essendon supporter.
On the table?
How much is "under" the table?
Other clubs need to step up to the plate.
god I love seeing your paranoid meltdowns like this
- Banned
- #212
I expect this to change by 9 o'clock this morning.
Makes perfect sense to me.
Hold off for a better deal.
WrongUn
White Line Fever
As we all know when the player is still contracted it's a sellers market. It all comes down to how badly Hird wants Caddy next season in his team plan, and how much "over" he is prepared to pay. If Hird thinks Caddy is destined for a breakout season ie. Heppell, he will want him now at the Dons rotating through his midfield/fwd flank and becoming part of the Dons culture as they have a shot at the flag. He is very much like Hird as a player, maybe thus is why Jimmy wants him so bad?!
If Caddy stays a Sun this trades period, a lot could change for both clubs and for Caddy in 12-months. If Caddy plays a full season at the Suns his bonds will be much greater with the senior GC boys and his might start second guessing his choices. It also gives other Victorian clubs time to come up with a $$$ strategy to grab him Aka Mitch Clark style. They will all surely be in his head throughout the season with enticing offers for seasons end.
If the Hird wants him, I think his best decision is to throw the kitchen sink at the Suns and secure Caddy now. If they don't they risk losing him. Again the only questions to be answered is how badly does Hird want him and is he willing to risk waiting another 12-months?
If Caddy stays a Sun this trades period, a lot could change for both clubs and for Caddy in 12-months. If Caddy plays a full season at the Suns his bonds will be much greater with the senior GC boys and his might start second guessing his choices. It also gives other Victorian clubs time to come up with a $$$ strategy to grab him Aka Mitch Clark style. They will all surely be in his head throughout the season with enticing offers for seasons end.
If the Hird wants him, I think his best decision is to throw the kitchen sink at the Suns and secure Caddy now. If they don't they risk losing him. Again the only questions to be answered is how badly does Hird want him and is he willing to risk waiting another 12-months?
Sorry to hear that Caddy's father is sick, but I still wouldn't trade the kid. He is an elite talent. We could surely give him time off when required, whether that is letting him stay in Melbourne & just fly to the Coast occasionally or go home for fortnightly blocks during the season or whatever. Hopefully he could still play some games for the Suns in 2012, but more importantly we want him available in 2013, 14 & 15.
Sunny_
Brownlow Medallist
This is very exciting. Can't wait to see what happens today regarding this whole Caddy thing.
- Oct 2, 2008
- 9,076
- 19,277
- AFL Club
- Richmond
- Other Teams
- Brothers of Destruction
GC supporters, Richmond's Pick 15 + Bock Compensation Pick for Caddy, any takers?
Much better than that shit Essendon have served you.
I think Melbourne or Geelong would be primed to pounce on this however.
Much better than that shit Essendon have served you.
I think Melbourne or Geelong would be primed to pounce on this however.
supernova_
Premiership Player
being a weaker draft, you would think a pick in the single digits. Otherwise a solid starting 22 player would be needed I would think.
The talk is GC are happy with 1 pick in this draft; only want compo picks for subsequent years.
WrongUn
White Line Fever
If Suns dont get a cpl decent experienced bodies today, it will be very disappointing. Warnock seems to be still on the way, maybe Melbourne will enter into the Caddy situation and offer some sweeteners?
That's how I'd see it too. Clayton stated he wanted the compo picks back.
edit: in reply to Slattery_20
edit: in reply to Slattery_20
- Oct 2, 2008
- 9,076
- 19,277
- AFL Club
- Richmond
- Other Teams
- Brothers of Destruction
Pick 15 + Bock Comp Pick + Mitch Morton for Caddy? Lots of upside in Morton if he can get himself right. No one can give top 10 picks, GWS have them all
Sunny_
Brownlow Medallist
Apparently getting Warnock from the Dees for pick 50. Very likely to happen according to the boys at TWR.
supernova_
Premiership Player
I dont think a deal will get done for Caddy. Nobody seems to be offering enough to satisfy GC panel.
Warnock seems to be making his way north though Hopefully they stretch it out for another 4 hours so they cant deal Caddy
Warnock seems to be making his way north though
Hopefully they stretch it out for another 4 hours so they cant deal Caddy
Sunny_
Brownlow Medallist
Also note that Bate for pick 39 was not enough. Seems that Dees aren't keen on shedding him.
I dont think a deal will get done for Caddy. Nobody seems to be offering enough to satisfy GC panel.
Warnock seems to be making his way north though
That would be a good result.
- Status
Similar threads
