Discussion Round 1 Best 22

[SK_MD_#7]

Including possible recruits/Membrey etc.. Let's see how we all go.

It is a bit early but i'm bored.

FB: Jimmy Webster, Luke Delaney, Sean Dempster
HB: Shane Savage, Sam Fisher, Nathan Wright
C: Leigh Montagna, Luke Dunstan, Jack Steven
HF: Jack Billings, Nick Riewoldt, Tim Membrey
FF: Eli Templeton, Spencer White/Josh Bruce/Tom Lee, Billy Longer
R: Tom Hickey, Sebastian Ross, David Armitage
INT: Jarryn Geary, Jack Newnes, Blake Acres, Sam Gilbert
EMG: Farren Ray, Maverick Weller, Brodie Murdoch

Tough gig to do.. Very early one obviously so mine will change a heap no doubt over the pre-season.

I think we'll go with the Longer/Hickey combo to start the year off.

 

[cuzo]

FB: Dempster, Delaney, Geary
HB: Webster, Fisher, Newnes.
C: Savage, Armitage, Montagna
HF: Billings, Riewoldt, Templeton
FF: Petracca, White, Membrey
R: Longer, steven, dunstan
Int: Ross, Hickey, Acres, Wright
Emg: Markworth, Murdoch, Minchington.

Could see any of the emergencies being in for round one with a huge preseason. Few stiff to miss out eg. weller, gilbert (i'm tipping he'll have another foot injury), also think bruce may be in instead of hickey/longer.

 

[Defacto]

B Wright Bruce Fisher
HB Webster Delaney Dempster
C Montagna Armitage Geary
HF Eli Riewoldt Membrey
F Billings White Hickey
R Longer Dunstan Steven
I/C Gilbert Newnes Savage
SUB Petracca

VFL
B Shenton Roberton JBT
HB Murdoch Simpkin Acres
C Saunders Ross Ray
HF Minchington Lee Markworth
F Daniel Holmes Siposs
R Pierce Neal-Bullen Weller
I/C Curren Schloathie Johansen Creeper Winton

 

[L_W_P]

Dempster - Delaney - Geary
Roberton - Fisher - Savage
Montagna - Dunstan - Newnes
Curren - Riewoldt - Steven
Saad - White - Bruce
Hickey - Armitage - Ross
Billings - Ray - Webster
(Neal Bullen)

 

[Saint_Dos]

B: Dempster, Delaney, Geary
HB: Webster, Fisher, Savage
C: Ray, Dunstan, Steven
HF: Billings, Riewoldt, Montagna
F: Curren, White, Longer
R: Hickey, Armitage, Weller
I: Gilbert, Newnes, Murdoch, Membrey
Sub: Templeton

 

[joop]

B: Dempster, Delaney, Geary
HB: Webster, Fisher, Savage
C: Montagna, Dunstan, Acres
HF: Billings, Riewoldt, Petracca
F: Templeton, White, Weller
R: Hickey, Armitage, Steven
I: Newnes, Curren, Wright
Sub: Garlett

 

[Persevering Saint]

2 Tall defensive backs: Delaney, Fisher
2 Small defensive backs: Dempster, Geary
3 Offensive backs: Webster, Gilbert, Wright

5 Inside mids: Dunstan, Steven, Montagna, Armitage, Curren, Petracca
3 Outside mids: Ray, Savage, Newnes
1 Tagger: Weller

2 Rucks: Longer, Hickey

2 Tall Forwards: Riewoldt, Bruce,
1 Small Forwards: Billings
1 Medium Forwards: Lee

 

[hayes]

FB: Gilbert Delaney Dempster

HB: Webster Fisher Savage

C: Montagna Dunstan Newnes

HF: Billings Roo Murdoch

FF: Eli Bruce Lee

R: Hickey Steven Armo

Int: Ross Wright Weller Geary

 

[Barrels]

Budgeted for Membrey, Petracca, McKenzie and Cockatoo to come to us through the drafts, and Taylor Grace and Le Grice as rookie picks.

Schneider stays on the list until I hear otherwise, and Hickey and Gilbert start slow due to recovery from injury.

I'm impressed by reports of Sippo in the gym already, so he gets a shot.

SENIORS:
FB: Geary - Delaney - Bruce
HB: Dempster - Fisher - Savage
CR: Newnes - Dunstan - Montagna
HF: Templeton - Riewoldt - Billings
FF: Membrey - Lee - McKenzie
RK: Longer - Steven - Armitage
Int: Acres - Wright - Webster - Petracca*

'RESSIES':
FB: Roberton - Le Grice - Simpkin
HB: Ray - Gilbert - Shenton
CR: Ross - Murdoch - Curren
HF: Siposs - White - Markworth
FF: Schneider - Hickey - Pierce
RK: Holmes - Weller - Minchington
Int: Saunders - Grace - Cockatoo

EDIT: edited for you whiny bastards...

 

[hayes]

^^Zero chance Webster is playing ressies if fit.

 

[Half Back Pocket]

depends if we want to win games or pump games into the kids....

My team (based on the latter)

FB: Dempster Delaney Webster

HB: Wright Fisher Savage

C: Montagna Dunstan Acres

HF: Billings Riewoldt Petracca

F: Templeton White Bruce

R: Hickey Armitage Steven

Int: Newnes Ross Murdoch Cockatoo


Roberton, Saunders, Lee, Shenton, Ray, Pierce, Minchi, Markworth, Longer, Gilbert, Curren, Simpkin, Siposs, Weller, McKenzie, McDonald, Membrey

 

[Barrels]

^^Zero chance Webster is playing ressies if fit.

Who's spot is he taking in the 1s?

 

[hayes]

Who's spot is he taking in the 1s?

There's five talls in your team which is probably too many, so any of McKenzie, Siposs, Membrey or Lee. At the very least he gets an interchange spot.

My point though is Webster isn't someone you find a place for, he's a lock.

 

[Barrels]

There's five talls in your team which is probably too many, so any of McKenzie, Siposs, Membrey or Lee. At the very least he gets an interchange spot.

My point though is Webster isn't someone you find a place for, he's a lock.

Not sure I agree; we have 3/4 locks and that's it.

Webster is a wing/hbf, and while I'm a big big fan, unless he can play forward he's not displacing any of the blokes you mentioned. Membrey is a burly 3rd forward - something we need to spread the load - with some midfield potential, Siposs is a hff whom I'd like to see push up the ground, and in my team McKenzie is playing fwd/ruck and Lee is KPF, so they're a different issue. Webster isn't displacing Savage or Dempster on half back, nor Newnes or Joey on the wings.

As for the bench, I'd potentially switch him with Ray or Wright, but that's as far as I'd go.

 

[Adam H]

There's five talls in your team which is probably too many, so any of McKenzie, Siposs, Membrey or Lee. At the very least he gets an interchange spot.

My point though is Webster isn't someone you find a place for, he's a lock.

Yep Webster plays every game he is fit.

 

[Rors]

For those who've put CP in their teams for round 1, we'll have to wait & see if his hip is right by that stage

http://www.heraldsun.com.au/sport/a...h-no1-draft-pick/story-fni5f9q3-1227093037607

 

[hayes]

Not sure I agree; we have 3/4 locks and that's it.

Webster is a wing/hbf, and while I'm a big big fan, unless he can play forward he's not displacing any of the blokes you mentioned. Membrey is a burly 3rd forward - something we need to spread the load - with some midfield potential, Siposs is a hff whom I'd like to see push up the ground, and in my team McKenzie is playing fwd/ruck and Lee is KPF, so they're a different issue. Webster isn't displacing Savage or Dempster on half back, nor Newnes or Joey on the wings.

As for the bench, I'd potentially switch him with Ray or Wright, but that's as far as I'd go.

He's a lock in that he's not a fringe player like a Siposs, Murdoch or anyone else who comes in and out. He's either in the Saints team or injured (barring his little stint in the VFL for off field stuff). Definitely best 22.

 

[Barrels]

He's a lock in that he's not a fringe player like a Siposs, Murdoch or anyone else who comes in and out. He's either in the Saints team or injured (barring his little stint in the VFL for off field stuff). Definitely best 22.

We'll agree to disagree.

 

[Half Back Pocket]

fight!! fight!! fight!!

 

[SK_MD_#7]

Get your hand off it Barrels.

 

[Barrels]

fight!! fight!! fight!!

 

[Periphery]

Webster is easily best 22 and would be in the main group of our kids that the club will aim to get games into ASAP.

 

[Barrels]

Webster is easily best 22 and would be in the main group of our kids that the club will aim to get games into ASAP.

Would you prefer me to take Siposs out, switch Savage to hf and Webster into a hbf?

Bunch of ****en whiners...

 

[Periphery]

Would you prefer me to take Siposs out, switch Savage to hf and Webster into a hbf?

Bunch of ****en whiners...

Siposs out, Templeton to HF Webster on the bench.

 

[Barrels]

Siposs out, Templeton to HF Webster on the bench.

Beat you to it you whiny flog!