-
AFLW 2024 - Round 10 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
Round 10 Trading.
- Thread starter Liuy
- Start date
- Tagged users None
- Status
- May 27, 2006
- 44,736
- 88,812
- AFL Club
- Melbourne
- Other Teams
- I'm aware of and love the Miami Dolphins
- Moderator
- #77
Whoops! Accidentally added money on rather than subtracting going from Davey to Johnson, but I can still make the trades (just!).
Bomber Billy
Debutant
Who do you experts think is the best player to trade out:
Krakour @ 395,000
Higgins @ 396,000
Houlihan @ 378,000
????
Krakour @ 395,000
Higgins @ 396,000
Houlihan @ 378,000
????
Felixes Felines
Senior List
You need to provide us "experts" with more info. Current fwd line, cash in bank, trades etc.
Not sure ATM but I may go with...
Beams-->Muston
Higgins-->Buddy
Then next week...
Waite-->Ellis
Otten-->Ablett
But I have no idea ATM.
Beams-->Muston
Higgins-->Buddy
Then next week...
Waite-->Ellis
Otten-->Ablett
But I have no idea ATM.
guitar god
Debutant
Not having the greatest year of super coach so far
I've got the following players who I'm considering getting rid of, I've got $340,500 in the bank.
Petterd (back)
Ziebell (mid)
Kerr (mid)
White (ruck)
Kerr is really starting to frustrate me and has lost me 100 grand and isn't getting good scores. Trade to Ablett perhaps? Or downgrade a rookie and get the funds to upgrade Ziebell to Ablett?
That leaves Petterd and white, white's doing average at best so far and it's the same story with petterd, not good scores.
Any advice?
Edit:
Just thought of another idea, trade Kerr to Jimmy Bartel while he's cheap and next week upgrade Ziebell to Ablett and downgrade a cash cow
What do you all think?
I've got the following players who I'm considering getting rid of, I've got $340,500 in the bank.
Petterd (back)
Ziebell (mid)
Kerr (mid)
White (ruck)
Kerr is really starting to frustrate me and has lost me 100 grand and isn't getting good scores. Trade to Ablett perhaps? Or downgrade a rookie and get the funds to upgrade Ziebell to Ablett?
That leaves Petterd and white, white's doing average at best so far and it's the same story with petterd, not good scores.
Any advice?
Edit:
Just thought of another idea, trade Kerr to Jimmy Bartel while he's cheap and next week upgrade Ziebell to Ablett and downgrade a cash cow
What do you all think?
ROFL
Is it a bit early to jump on Muston....
Higgins to Buddy
Waite to Ellis
ROK for me, really looking good atm. He and Kirk were two great pick ups two weeks ago 
Hey guys, I'd love some advice on my team, this being my rookie season. Any advice on trades would be appreciated...
Drummond-Fisher-CCornes-Gilbee-Hill-Grimes-Raines (Houlihan-Bock)
Ablett-Judd-Foley-Hasleby-Rich-Dangerfield (Tuck-Beams)
Cox-McIntosh (Leuenberger-Currie)
Riewoldt-SJohnson-JBrown-Higgins-Ziebell-Dowler-McGlynn (Skipworth-Thorp)
I've got 9 trades left and $51,500
Obviously like most people I'm thinking about Muston, but I don't think my midfield is a worry at the moment. Still though, you guys are the experts so any advice would be appreciated
Drummond-Fisher-CCornes-Gilbee-Hill-Grimes-Raines (Houlihan-Bock)
Ablett-Judd-Foley-Hasleby-Rich-Dangerfield (Tuck-Beams)
Cox-McIntosh (Leuenberger-Currie)
Riewoldt-SJohnson-JBrown-Higgins-Ziebell-Dowler-McGlynn (Skipworth-Thorp)
I've got 9 trades left and $51,500
Obviously like most people I'm thinking about Muston, but I don't think my midfield is a worry at the moment. Still though, you guys are the experts so any advice would be appreciated
Yeah Tuck to Masten would be obvious. You have used 11 trades but you're still playing 4 rookies.
Might be time to choose the rookies that will play out the year because you wont be able to get rid of them anymore.
I would upgrade Dangerfield first.
Might be time to choose the rookies that will play out the year because you wont be able to get rid of them anymore.
I would upgrade Dangerfield first.
- Jul 14, 2005
- 18,723
- 29,565
- AFL Club
- Carlton
- Other Teams
- Chelsea FC
- Banned
- #87
Change of plan.
Coughlan>>>>>>Muston
Higgins>>>>>>>Sewell
Backs: Goddard, Drummond, Fisher, Adcock, Harding, Grimes, Cheney
Mids: Ablett, Judd, Dal Santo, Sewell, Gibbs, Muston
Rucks: Cox, McIntosh
Forwards: Davis, Johnson, Franklin, Krakouer, Giansericusa, McGlynn, Ziebell
Thoughts?
Coughlan>>>>>>Muston
Higgins>>>>>>>Sewell
Backs: Goddard, Drummond, Fisher, Adcock, Harding, Grimes, Cheney
Mids: Ablett, Judd, Dal Santo, Sewell, Gibbs, Muston
Rucks: Cox, McIntosh
Forwards: Davis, Johnson, Franklin, Krakouer, Giansericusa, McGlynn, Ziebell
Thoughts?
Yeah, I know but I'd like to see Ellis play a game first (which is hopefully this week) and he should go down a little bit in price aswell. Depends if Cheney/Broughton get a game, if they don't (and Ellis does) I will do as you suggested above.
strong team
id give muston one more week though, you don't want another cheney, and it gives coughlan a chance to go up even more in value.
I can't choose between these three forwards to go in my forward line.
Forward Line: Goodwin, S.Johnson, Deledio, Fevola, Higgins, McGlynn, Skipworth
*this is easily my weakest part...
I want to trade out fevola for Franklin/Giansiracusa/O'Keefe
Consider price, potential scores, consistency and whether or not he is a keeper when choosing. I'm probably going to pick up Aaron Davey the round after.
Thoughts?
- Jul 14, 2005
- 18,723
- 29,565
- AFL Club
- Carlton
- Other Teams
- Chelsea FC
- Banned
- #90
Thanks mate
Fev is playing injured so he wont be picking up massive scores, so you'd either upgrade now or wait until he's fully recovered.
Get on Franklin early though, his stocks are rising.
Current Ranking: 196th
Money in the bank: $580,000
Trades left: 12
What I'm thinking of doing this week is:
Nahas > O'Keefe and Rich > Sewell
then next week:
Beams > Muston and Otten > Ablett
Though this would only leave me with roughly $684,500 for ablett though so not quite enough! So if Higgins is out then I'll trade him instead of Nahas, and if he isn't I'll bring in Cyril instead of ROK!
This will leave me with 8 trades left and my team will look like this...
BACKS: Goddard, Drummond, Fisher, Cornes, Gilbee, Grimes, Cheney (Broughton, Petrenko)
MIDFIELD: Ablett, Sewell, Davis, Judd, Selwood, Gibbs (Muston, Anthony)
RUCKS: Cox, McIntosh (Spencer, Jacobs)
FORWARDS: Riewoldt, Pavlich, Deledio, Franklin, Sidebottom and either Higgins, Cyril or ROK, Nahas! (Brown, Walker)
Then team will be finished until Hodge comes back in and finds some form! Then Cheney will turn into Hodge hopefully and then right before finals i'll upgrade one more forward! Leaving me with 4 or 5 trades for injuries!
Just interested in peoples opinions on those trades and if you have any advice that could help me! Any feedback is good feedback, all helpful!
Money in the bank: $580,000
Trades left: 12
What I'm thinking of doing this week is:
Nahas > O'Keefe and Rich > Sewell
then next week:
Beams > Muston and Otten > Ablett
Though this would only leave me with roughly $684,500 for ablett though so not quite enough! So if Higgins is out then I'll trade him instead of Nahas, and if he isn't I'll bring in Cyril instead of ROK!
This will leave me with 8 trades left and my team will look like this...
BACKS: Goddard, Drummond, Fisher, Cornes, Gilbee, Grimes, Cheney (Broughton, Petrenko)
MIDFIELD: Ablett, Sewell, Davis, Judd, Selwood, Gibbs (Muston, Anthony)
RUCKS: Cox, McIntosh (Spencer, Jacobs)
FORWARDS: Riewoldt, Pavlich, Deledio, Franklin, Sidebottom and either Higgins, Cyril or ROK, Nahas! (Brown, Walker)
Then team will be finished until Hodge comes back in and finds some form! Then Cheney will turn into Hodge hopefully and then right before finals i'll upgrade one more forward! Leaving me with 4 or 5 trades for injuries!
Just interested in peoples opinions on those trades and if you have any advice that could help me! Any feedback is good feedback, all helpful!
Is Gia a good swap for higgins i dont want to do a double trade and have little money left
Great side mate, trades sound find.
I've got $901,300 for a back and a forward to replace Waite & Higgins.
Backs I like are either Newman ($485k) or Gilbert ($461k). Problem is then the best forwards I could afford would be Porps ($414k) or Cyril ($433k). Ideally, I'd like to wait a week to do the forwards (and play M Brown), so i could downgrade & grab a genuine premium, but I NEED a win this week, and will already be carrying 2 x zeros vs my opponent who has none. Haven't seen enough of Porps to make a judgment, his early scores were woeful but has knocked up 122 & 110 the past fortnight.
Some options are: (*average in brackets)
1) Gilbert (101) /Newman (98) & Porps (85)
2) Gilbert/Newman & Cyril (88)
3) M Johnson (89) & Buddy (91)
4) Adcock (83) & Buddy/ROK
Not real happy with any of those. Really want Newman or Gilbert as back, but this only leaves me $416k or $439k for my forward, obviously not enough for Buddy at $469k.
Thoughts???
Backs I like are either Newman ($485k) or Gilbert ($461k). Problem is then the best forwards I could afford would be Porps ($414k) or Cyril ($433k). Ideally, I'd like to wait a week to do the forwards (and play M Brown), so i could downgrade & grab a genuine premium, but I NEED a win this week, and will already be carrying 2 x zeros vs my opponent who has none. Haven't seen enough of Porps to make a judgment, his early scores were woeful but has knocked up 122 & 110 the past fortnight.
Some options are: (*average in brackets)
1) Gilbert (101) /Newman (98) & Porps (85)
2) Gilbert/Newman & Cyril (88)
3) M Johnson (89) & Buddy (91)
4) Adcock (83) & Buddy/ROK
Not real happy with any of those. Really want Newman or Gilbert as back, but this only leaves me $416k or $439k for my forward, obviously not enough for Buddy at $469k.
Thoughts???
- Mar 28, 2008
- 3,144
- 445
- AFL Club
- Geelong
Team up in the air ATM. Gilbee, Higgins, Chappy stuffed my plans l had for this week.
$323,200 in bank, 12 trades
Thinking :
Petrenko > McMahon ( Looks a consistent scorer with 1 score under 89 for the year, ave 96.
Higgins > Porps
This would leave:
B: Cornes, Newman, P Burg, Gilbee, Hurn, McMahon, Grimes (Hurley, Rance)
M: Judd, Selwood, Corey, Mitchell, Rich, Sidebottom (Beams, Robinson)
R: Cox, McIntosh
F: Pavlich, Buddy, ROK, Chappy, Fev, Porps, Ziebell (Walker, Brown)
Chapman out this week > Brown cover
Maybe looking at a 0 for Gilbee unless Rance comes up.
leaves 10 trades, $50k
$323,200 in bank, 12 trades
Thinking :
Petrenko > McMahon ( Looks a consistent scorer with 1 score under 89 for the year, ave 96.
Higgins > Porps
This would leave:
B: Cornes, Newman, P Burg, Gilbee, Hurn, McMahon, Grimes (Hurley, Rance)
M: Judd, Selwood, Corey, Mitchell, Rich, Sidebottom (Beams, Robinson)
R: Cox, McIntosh
F: Pavlich, Buddy, ROK, Chappy, Fev, Porps, Ziebell (Walker, Brown)
Chapman out this week > Brown cover
Maybe looking at a 0 for Gilbee unless Rance comes up.
leaves 10 trades, $50k
chapman2grandstand
Senior List
Backs: Goddard, Drummond, Fisher, Cornes, Gilbert, Grimes, Cheney (Rance, Broughton)
Mids: Ablett,Judd, Bartel, Gibbs, Rich, Coughlan (T. Tuck, Sidebottom)
Rucks: Cox, Kreuzer (Jacobs, Spencer)
F: Pavlich, Deledio, Franklin, O'Keefe, Higgins, Fevola, Ziebell (Walker, Warren)
I'm considering:
Tuck -> Muston
Higgins -> Riewoldt
Peoples thoughts? Any other suggestions. Only 14k in the kitty.
Mids: Ablett,Judd, Bartel, Gibbs, Rich, Coughlan (T. Tuck, Sidebottom)
Rucks: Cox, Kreuzer (Jacobs, Spencer)
F: Pavlich, Deledio, Franklin, O'Keefe, Higgins, Fevola, Ziebell (Walker, Warren)
I'm considering:
Tuck -> Muston
Higgins -> Riewoldt
Peoples thoughts? Any other suggestions. Only 14k in the kitty.
i wouldnt trade muston in til next week, dont judge a rookie on 1 game lol.
still dont know my trades for the week, depends on the teams and who gets named. heres hoping broughton, gilbee and cheney get named. and heres hoping that t tuck doesnt get named!
still dont know my trades for the week, depends on the teams and who gets named. heres hoping broughton, gilbee and cheney get named. and heres hoping that t tuck doesnt get named!
chapman2grandstand
Senior List
Amount of game's isn't the issue for Muston, it's the injuries.
He will be a very good player if he doesn't go down again.
The only cheap alternative is L. Anthony, and he's got injury problems of his own!
- Status
