Out: darling
In: maric
In: maric
-
Guest - BigFooty Tipping 2025 - Get on! - $500 first prize - Weekly Prizes - Click to Join
PLUS Your club board comp is now up!
Prediction Round 18, 2024: Changes vs Brisbane
- Thread starter KERRPOW
- Start date
- Tagged users None
- Status
Out:
Reid for being arrogant and lacking respect
Ginbey for being in the game only when put in the guts
Hough for kicking into the man on the mark despite shutting down most of the games small forwards all year.
In
Gaff
Sheed on 1 leg
Edwards, another coaches pet
Edit: this is sarcasm based on comments made towards these 3 players in the game day thread.
Last edited:
Out:
Jones, Chesser
In:
Culley, Maric.
Brisbane have a tall forward line so Rotham won't go out.
Jones, Chesser
In:
Culley, Maric.
Brisbane have a tall forward line so Rotham won't go out.
Carbine Chaos
See My Chess
- Apr 1, 2009
- 65,913
- 100,429
- AFL Club
- West Coast
- Other Teams
- Perth FC, Everton, Delhi
Would like to see the back of Witherden, Rotham, Jones and Darling.
Replace with developing players.
Replace with developing players.
- Jun 29, 2013
- 4,140
- 6,837
- AFL Club
- West Coast
Out: Jones, Darling, Rotham
In: Hall/Culley/Burgiel, Maric
In: Hall/Culley/Burgiel, Maric
Oh you missed the part where we aren't in a rebuild
It's a Clayton's rebuild...the rebuild we have when we are t having a rebuild
ToastieBoy18
Team Captain
- Dec 5, 2022
- 307
- 1,397
- AFL Club
- West Coast
Need to stop playing deadwood
Out - JJones, Darling, Rotham/Witherden
In - Maric, Flynn, Johnston
Backs - Gov, TB, Hough, Cole, Hunt, Duggan, Witho/Rotham
Mids - Yeo, Reid, Kelly, Ginbey, Chesser, Maric
Rucks - Flynn, BWilliams
Forwards - Allen, Waterman, JWilliams, Ryan, Brockman, Cripps, Hutchison
Sub - Johnston
Out - JJones, Darling, Rotham/Witherden
In - Maric, Flynn, Johnston
Backs - Gov, TB, Hough, Cole, Hunt, Duggan, Witho/Rotham
Mids - Yeo, Reid, Kelly, Ginbey, Chesser, Maric
Rucks - Flynn, BWilliams
Forwards - Allen, Waterman, JWilliams, Ryan, Brockman, Cripps, Hutchison
Sub - Johnston
Can’t go taller
cacik
Senior List
Thought JD was ok today, seen worse from him
Witherden or rotham to be dropped me thinks.
Surprisingly I thought he was ok as backup ruck, does seem like simmo looking for a way to get him I to the game to get to 300 though.
Both Yeo and Harley look tired.
They've lost a lot of the explosiveness they had at the start of the year. Reid in particular.
First handful of rounds Harley was running on water, bounced off everyone and showed the core strength of a star. Now he looks exhausted, is tackled easily and no longer clean below his feet.
Sack Simpson.
They've lost a lot of the explosiveness they had at the start of the year. Reid in particular.
First handful of rounds Harley was running on water, bounced off everyone and showed the core strength of a star. Now he looks exhausted, is tackled easily and no longer clean below his feet.
Sack Simpson.
Yeah I used to be a big fan of Jones but just too often can't do the basics right and so whole it looks good it's ineffective.
Witherden people talk of as an on field coach but I don't see it and if he is, then he's privacy a better coach than player and can follow that path.
At this point it isn't even who comes in, we have nearly a full list. There are fit bodies.
Last edited:
Getting a lot of verbal and physical pressure from the opposition with little support.
Club is a basket case.
Out witherden rotham darling JJ
Johnson Maric JW hall
Put ginbey Chesser down back
Hall into middle
Maric wing
Culley forward
It might me time to put reid down back Occasionally too
On Pixel 6 Pro using BigFooty.com mobile app
Johnson Maric JW hall
Put ginbey Chesser down back
Hall into middle
Maric wing
Culley forward
It might me time to put reid down back Occasionally too
On Pixel 6 Pro using BigFooty.com mobile app
KBLT
Norm Smith Medallist
Out: Witherden, Rotham, Jones, Brockman
In: Hall, Dewar, Johnston, Maric
Duggan, Barrass, Hough
Maric, McGovern, Hunt
Ginbey, Hall, Kelly
BWilliams, Reid, Yeo
Cripps, Waterman, Ryan
Dewar, Allen, Darling
Johnston, Cole, JWilliams, Hutchinson
Chesser sub
In: Hall, Dewar, Johnston, Maric
Duggan, Barrass, Hough
Maric, McGovern, Hunt
Ginbey, Hall, Kelly
BWilliams, Reid, Yeo
Cripps, Waterman, Ryan
Dewar, Allen, Darling
Johnston, Cole, JWilliams, Hutchinson
Chesser sub
Chesser deserves to make way.
Blame it on Simpson for being a dickhead with his wings week after week, but Chesser gifted games on that wing whilst another young player could come in and do the exact same thing isn't good for selection integrity, and it certainly doesn't appear to be doing anything positive with his development.
Hell, move Chesser somewhere else if you want, just get him off that wing FFS.
OUT: Rotham, Witherden, Jones, Chesser
IN: Hedwards. Hall, Trew/Dewar, Johnston
What have we got to lose exactly? The game? That'll happen regardless.
Blame it on Simpson for being a dickhead with his wings week after week, but Chesser gifted games on that wing whilst another young player could come in and do the exact same thing isn't good for selection integrity, and it certainly doesn't appear to be doing anything positive with his development.
Hell, move Chesser somewhere else if you want, just get him off that wing FFS.
OUT: Rotham, Witherden, Jones, Chesser
IN: Hedwards. Hall, Trew/Dewar, Johnston
What have we got to lose exactly? The game? That'll happen regardless.
- Jun 29, 2013
- 4,140
- 6,837
- AFL Club
- West Coast
Not sure chess out is the answer tbh, he's been far from terrible in spite of being gimped on the wing. Getting more games into kids like him should be the priority.
Agree with the need to get other kids in (e.g hall, Hewitt soon) - coaches need to think about how to get them involved and playing to their strengths better
- Jul 27, 2023
- 5,716
- 16,843
- AFL Club
- West Coast
Cole Barrass Hough
Burgiel Gov Maric
Johnston Kelly Ginbey
Dewar Waterman Hutchinson
Ryan Allen AReid
Flynn Reid Yeo
JWilliams Hall Chesser Culley
Hunt
Burgiel Gov Maric
Johnston Kelly Ginbey
Dewar Waterman Hutchinson
Ryan Allen AReid
Flynn Reid Yeo
JWilliams Hall Chesser Culley
Hunt
- Jul 28, 2018
- 1,481
- 5,065
- AFL Club
- West Coast
Out: Chesser, Darling, Brockman, Rotham, Jones, Witherden
In: Don’t care, whoever
We aren’t making selections with winning games of footy in mind anyway, heads need to roll with the absolute rubbish we’ve been dishing out. Want everyone to proper turn on Simpson too, enough is now enough. Up the heat on the head coach as supporters of this once great club. Rabble.
All the players I’ve called to be dropped suck as of right now, and it’d be hard to argue otherwise
In: Don’t care, whoever
We aren’t making selections with winning games of footy in mind anyway, heads need to roll with the absolute rubbish we’ve been dishing out. Want everyone to proper turn on Simpson too, enough is now enough. Up the heat on the head coach as supporters of this once great club. Rabble.
All the players I’ve called to be dropped suck as of right now, and it’d be hard to argue otherwise
- Jan 13, 2013
- 24,043
- 48,513
- AFL Club
- West Coast
Dunno about Chesser, hard to tell if the role is his problem or not, but Brockman has been fairly disappointing imo. Not sure what the go is but he does one or two tricky plays a week that do or don't come off and then is largely un-sighted.
Maybe part of the flying V?
cacik
Senior List
It was suprising but your right, his second efforts i thought were good enough, And decent fwd ruck craft. I agree on the 300 sentiment, can see why simmo will get him there... he has never dropped him and never will though
Maric for Chesser
Johnston for Jones
Flynn for Bailey, or not, I don't care, just don't play both.
JWilliams for Darling
Dewar for Witherden
Hedwards for Rotham
Ryan to HBF.
Chesser to sub, or give that to Dewar/Johnston and Chesser can play WAFL.
If Chesser plays WAFL then Trew/Culley to sub.
Johnston for Jones
Flynn for Bailey, or not, I don't care, just don't play both.
JWilliams for Darling
Dewar for Witherden
Hedwards for Rotham
Ryan to HBF.
Chesser to sub, or give that to Dewar/Johnston and Chesser can play WAFL.
If Chesser plays WAFL then Trew/Culley to sub.
- Status
Similar threads
