Round 18 trades

[Geelong_Bisons_#36]

Lids to Montagna.
Only 1 trade left now +50K.

 

[cdcanman]

Just a warning to all those considering bringing Naismith in. Yes he has had a great couple of games but as the proud owner of Toby Nankervis who never scored under 70SC and got dropped after his 3rd game this same thing could happen to Naismith. I recall Horse saying he was going to rotate through the rookie ruckman while Tippett was out. Then again you never know... Horse may drop Sinclair and Nankervis and Naismith may both play??

Naismith has been FAR more influential than what Nankervis was. SC scores may not differ greatly, but in terms of real world football influence, Naismith has been far superior.
Sinclair hasn't been great, you are quite right, but he has been doing enough to hold his spot.

 

[Smitch]

Hey guys! New around here so not sure if this posted right so let me know.
Not sure what to do this week, sitting second in my league and 15,741 overall in my first year of SuperCoach. Any ideas welcome!
Scored 2,408 last round.

 

[The Lemon]

Hey guys! New around here so not sure if this posted right so let me know.
Not sure what to do this week, sitting second in my league and 15,741 overall in my first year of SuperCoach. Any ideas welcome!
Scored 2,408 last round.
View attachment 267203 View attachment 267204

Hold trades, or upgrade Kerridge.

 

[GoDees234]

come to the wrong place for expert advice!

but otherwise, Brand to William
Deledio to Zerrett is what i would do

Cheers mate.

That trade leaves me with 132 K to go Kerridge\Petrecca to Dahlhaus with plenty of change when he returns from injury.

 

[Smitch]

Hold trades, or upgrade Kerridge.

Was thinking about upgrading kerridge, who would you go up to? Monty? Or look elsewhere?

 

[TheBeardAmigos]

Hey guys! New around here so not sure if this posted right so let me know.
Not sure what to do this week, sitting second in my league and 15,741 overall in my first year of SuperCoach. Any ideas welcome!
Scored 2,408 last round.
View attachment 267203 View attachment 267204

bench cover is very thin........

i would look at upgrade Kerridge to someone better than roll on with your final 2 trades until finals!

 

[cdcanman]

Hey guys! New around here so not sure if this posted right so let me know.
Not sure what to do this week, sitting second in my league and 15,741 overall in my first year of SuperCoach. Any ideas welcome!
Scored 2,408 last round.
View attachment 267203 View attachment 267204

Throw your spare change at Kerridge is the obvious option.
Unless you want to hold fire until Dahlhaus or Lids get back from injury which would be an ok move too.

 

[The Lemon]

Was thinking about upgrading kerridge, who would you go up to? Monty? Or look elsewhere?

Sucking to FWD and then get Boyd.

Not sure on Montagna.

 

[DraftPunk]

Shiel avg 101 to Hannebery avg 112 worth a trade or too sideways?

 

[Goats]

get this guy

#fearthebeard

My balls have a more fearsome beard than Napleon Westoff.

 

[DT_35]

Barlow > Z.Merrett
R.Davis > Neale/Sloane

Leaves me with full premo team, 3 trades + no cash. Tippa at F7, Collins D7, Jansen/Phillips/Trengrove M9

 

[MightyMark]

Shiel avg 101 to Hannebery avg 112 worth a trade or too sideways?

Hanners would want to step up.

Look at the last 3 and 5 round average, paints a different picture. Hanners still slightly ahead but not by much.

Shiel also went 30+ touches and 94 against a Robinson tag, which is better than most have done this season.

Hanners is a better player and should come good, but I would wait till he bottoms out in a couple weeks, and only if you have the trades to spare.

 

[karaoke]

Hey guys! New around here so not sure if this posted right so let me know.
Not sure what to do this week, sitting second in my league and 15,741 overall in my first year of SuperCoach. Any ideas welcome!
Scored 2,408 last round.
View attachment 267203 View attachment 267204

Collins > Montagna (via DPP Joyce > Def, Kerridge > Mids)

 

[Smitch]

Collins > Montagna (via DPP Joyce > Def, Kerridge > Mids)

I like I like!

 

[RobZombie]

For all of you with trades left..
GAGFC
you know what the C stands for

6 left, planning to save 4 for finals, which means a one-up-one-down this week or next. One game clear on top of my cashie.

 

[jellyfish]

Whats Naismiths job security like in comparisons to Markov?
One gives me ruck and foward cover but thinking markov will play every game for the rest of the season and naismith may not play all the games when tippet is back?
Would people go Naismith over Markov?
Help would be appreciated

 

[go you pups]

Whats Naismiths job security like in comparisons to Markov?
One gives me ruck and foward cover but thinking markov will play every game for the rest of the season and naismith may not play all the games when tippet is back?
Would people go Naismith over Markov?
Help would be appreciated

Tippett not expected to be back until R22 or something (apparently he was put on LTI until then), I think Naismith is very relevant now

 

[jellyfish]

Deledio cleared of serious injury inline to face hawks
http://www.afl.com.au/news/2016-07-18/deledio-cleared-of-serious-calf-injury-in-line-to-play-hawks

 

[Kadog]

Deledio cleared of serious injury inline to face hawks
http://www.afl.com.au/news/2016-07-18/deledio-cleared-of-serious-calf-injury-in-line-to-play-hawks

Inb4 late out

 

[Sydney Kicker]

Deledio cleared of serious injury inline to face hawks
http://www.afl.com.au/news/2016-07-18/deledio-cleared-of-serious-calf-injury-in-line-to-play-hawks

Interesting. Would they dare risk him. Also looks like a candidate for the classic 1 week injury that ends up "test" on the injury list for a month.

Nervous times for Lids owners

 

[Gavin Excell]

Y

Interesting. Would they dare risk him. Also looks like a candidate for the classic 1 week injury that ends up "test" on the injury list for a month.

Nervous times for Lids owners

In some respects having a definite out for 4 weeks would be better. Real chance will miss next week. Tough call

 

[Listclogger]

Seeking the thoughts of the SC experts.

Current team after replacing GAJ this week:




Considering replacing Kerridge with Joey and moving Hall to M9/F7.

Am I wasting a trade??

 

[TheBeardAmigos]

Seeking the thoughts of the SC experts.

Current team after replacing GAJ this week:

View attachment 267276
View attachment 267277

Considering replacing Kerridge with Joey and moving Hall to M9/F7.

Am I wasting a trade??

i personally wouldnt go with Joey. is too up and down. probably better off keeping Kerridge

 

[leng jai]

i personally wouldnt go with Joey. is too up and down. probably better off keeping Kerridge

Montagna is a huge upgrade over Kerridge especially with St Kilda's draw. Kerridge is just as inconsistent, except the difference is he ranges from 50-95 compared to Montagna's 75-120.