Round 19 trades

[Krujan]

If I pull the trigger on Swallow tonight, these are my preferred trade options


Option 1) L Henderson @ B6/F7 I can DP with Staker F7 (as well as moving Vlas to mid bench - DP with Goddard & Gibbs) Ellis becomes B7

Option 2) Cyril @ M9/F6 I can DP with SJ & Rocky in the forwards. (probably move SJ to mids and bench TMithcell) Cyril could play @ F6 or bench cover in the mids. (maybe M8)

Option 3) Barlow/Fyfe/Jack/Jab/Cotch/ROK (or anyone under 570k) and bench one of TMitchell, Murphy, Stanton

Option 4) Hold Swallow this week, I will win all your league games anyway.
(GAJ, Pendles, Swan, Jelwood, JPK, Murphy, Stanton, TMitchell to get the job done) who knows who else will get injured/suspended this week...

Thoughts?

 

[leng jai]

I've shelved the Cyril idea but I still think he's an excellent addition for DPP and loophole shenanigans.

 

[Sir Skid]

sad times Mr Skid, sad sad times

Need a DON'T like button

 

[Krujan]

Is it still worth coming here without any puppies around?

I have puppies.

 

[karaoke]

If I pull the trigger on Swallow tonight, these are my preferred trade options


Option 1) L Henderson @ B6/F7 I can DP with Staker F7 (as well as moving Vlas to mid bench - DP with Goddard & Gibbs) Ellis becomes B7

Option 2) Cyril @ M9/F6 I can DP with SJ & Rocky in the forwards. (probably move SJ to mids and bench TMithcell) Cyril could play @ F6 or bench cover in the mids. (maybe M8)

Option 3) Barlow/Fyfe/Jack/Jab/Cotch/ROK (or anyone under 570k) and bench one of TMitchell, Murphy, Stanton

Option 4) Hold Swallow this week, I will win all your league games anyway.
(GAJ, Pendles, Swan, Jelwood, JPK, Murphy, Stanton, TMitchell to get the job done) who knows who else will get injured/suspended this week...

Thoughts?

Option 4, hold fire (for now),

I think we've all seen the value in the premium DPP players this year,

So, perhaps, Cyril(?) - lets have that discussion in 4-5 days time,

 

[Sir Skid]

I have puppies.

I see that Gingy, very nice too.

 

[scatman john]

due to being o/s twice this season and only briefly having a look at SC when traveling my team is a shambles.

one trade left, too many good fwds/rucks, not the right dpp players and only $30k~.

am in four leagues and in with a shot in all - my mates are somehow bigger spuds at this than myself.

goddard, malceski, taylor, gibbs, ibbotson, staker (wright, clisby)

ablett, pendles, selwood, kennedy, bartel, lewis, heppell, mitchell (k martin, hunter)

mcevoy, nn (cox(just there due to potentially being out), naismith(wtf?!))

martin, kennedy, cloke, s johnson, ryder, harvey (rowe, kennedy)

thinking i might just sit on it and wait for an injury.

any bright ideas or stick with the plan?

 

[Krujan]

I see that Gingy, very nice too.

Likewise, Sir.

 

[Sir Skid]

Likewise, Sir.

Thanks Gingy.
3 may be seen as a little Star Warsish whilst 2 is considered the natural order of puppies!

 

[Krujan]

Thanks Gingy.
3 may be seen as a little Star Warsish whilst 2 is considered the natural order of puppies!

I've actually got 4 (one is out of frame)

 

[Sir Skid]

I've actually got 4 (one is out of frame)

View attachment 25402

Ah! 2 pairs. Natural order is restored

 

[Spider Eater]

I brought in McBean so I can DP him with Rowe in the rucks. Is this a good move or a bad move?

Forward bench - Staker, Macaffer
Ruck bench - Nicholls, Rowe

I think it makes sense only if you have 2 DPP premo F/R's (one forward, ie... Cox, and one in the ruck ie... Roughead)... then you can have them swapping both ways if need be.
Or if you have one premo DPP and are planning to get another with a remaining trade.

I don't think having Rowe swap around for back up offers much, not confident he'll hold his spot in the side either... also looking like dropping 20-30k in the next 2 weeks so as for Rowe this is the week to trade him for cash if it was in your plans to do so otherwise keep him for his DP link.

 

[karaoke]

due to being o/s twice this season and only briefly having a look at SC when traveling my team is a shambles.

one trade left, too many good fwds/rucks, not the right dpp players and only $30k~.

am in four leagues and in with a shot in all - my mates are somehow bigger spuds at this than myself.

goddard, malceski, taylor, gibbs, ibbotson, staker (wright, clisby)

ablett, pendles, selwood, kennedy, bartel, lewis, heppell, mitchell (k martin, hunter)

mcevoy, nn (cox(just there due to potentially being out), naismith(wtf?!))

martin, kennedy, cloke, s johnson, ryder, harvey (rowe, kennedy)

thinking i might just sit on it and wait for an injury.

any bright ideas or stick with the plan?

 

[JDC!]

I think it makes sense only if you have 2 DPP premo F/R's (one forward, ie... Cox, and one in the ruck ie... Roughead)... then you can have them swapping both ways if need be.
Or if you have one premo DPP and are planning to get another with a remaining trade.

I don't think having Rowe swap around for back up offers much, not confident he'll hold his spot in the side either... also looking like dropping 20-30k in the next 2 weeks so as for Rowe this is the week to trade him for cash if it was in your plans to do so otherwise keep him for his DP link.

Cheers for the response. My ruckmen are Cox and Roughead so I'm thinking of sticking with the Macaffer for McBean trade.

 

[rocker_oz33]

Puppies > no puppies but why?

 

[toxic]

Puppies > no puppies but why?

Not sure. Someone sooked it up a treat, its bigfootys version of friday the 13th

 

[Gene Simmons]

Any siggestions will be much appreciated..

I would like to get Griffen in the midfield, I can do a straight swap for J.Kennedy or Mundy but I feel like that is just a sideways trade.

My other thought was to downgrade Nicholls on the bench and use the extra $ to upgrade Crouch to Griffen?

Or any other suggestions? Cheers

 

[Sir Skid]

Not sure. Someone sooked it up a treat, its bigfootys version of friday the 13th

The phantom puppy haters!
Maybe the faceless men have a new campaign!

 

[rocker_oz33]

Any siggestions will be much appreciated..

I would like to get Griffen in the midfield, I can do a straight swap for J.Kennedy or Mundy but I feel like that is just a sideways trade.

My other thought was to downgrade Nicholls on the bench and use the extra $ to upgrade Crouch to Griffen?

Or any other suggestions? Cheers

View attachment 25476

Do you really need to trade? do you want to?

 

[gh172]

I have NicNat as my second ruck with Nicholls on the bench and no money in the bank. Do I trade NicNat for Ryder or downgrade NicNat to Grundy pocketing over 300k with the hope Nicholls plays next week? I currently have 4 trades remaining.

Sent from my GT-I9505 using Tapatalk 2

 

[karaoke]

Any siggestions will be much appreciated..

I would like to get Griffen in the midfield, I can do a straight swap for J.Kennedy or Mundy but I feel like that is just a sideways trade.

My other thought was to downgrade Nicholls on the bench and use the extra $ to upgrade Crouch to Griffen?

Or any other suggestions? Cheers

View attachment 25476

Crouch > MMurph

Save last 3 trades,

IMO & FWIW

 

[flea29]

Last minute dilemma
Current D6 is Staker with Vlastuin Emerg
Should I trade Vlas for Burgoyne & play him or leave as is?
Must win game

 

[gh172]

I have NicNat as my second ruck with Nicholls on the bench and no money in the bank. Do I trade NicNat for Ryder or downgrade NicNat to Grundy pocketing over 300k with the hope Nicholls plays next week? I currently have 4 trades remaining.

Sent from my GT-I9505 using Tapatalk 2

Would really appreciate some feedback on this one. Its really doing my head in. I've posted 3 times without any luck.

 

[karaoke]

Last minute dilemma
Current D6 is Staker with Vlastuin Emerg
Should I trade Vlas for Burgoyne & play him or leave as is?
Must win game

Vlas (325k) - 72 (3 game ave), 56 (5 game ave), 76 ('13 ave),
Burg (375k) - 75, 73, 83

Are you really gaining much?

Save the trade, Burg's can spud it (5x scores this year of 70 or less) with the best of them,

 

[karaoke]

Would really appreciate some feedback on this one. Its really doing my head in. I've posted 3 times without any luck.

Hard to say w'out seeing whole team, but looks like you might need cash (ie Grundy) for final 3 trades?

Do you need to win this week?