Potentially it might be quite wet next weekend.
Prediction Round 2: Changes Vs St Kilda + pre-match discussion
- Thread starter MrDanggazz
- Start date
- Tagged users None
- Status
I think people are wrong on these two:
- Banfield essentially did one bad kick on goal, but he was also one of the ones trying his guts out till the very end to get us back in it and actually making some impact; he is going to stay in the team, if just as reward for how hard be tried; and
- Henry had a pretty good first half being critical in multiple good entries (some of our best plays even) into the forward line, started the second half on the bench when all the rot set in and was then brought back on as a forward when the ball was almost solely in Adelaide's half. I think he will get picked next week. Similarly Acres was good in the first half.
Brodie won't be dropped after today. Ludicrous.
So which midfielder are you dropping? Serong? Mundy? Or are you holding Fyfe back another week?
Firstly i don't think Fyfes ready.
Secondly Acres or banners would be dropped before him and Brodie playing a bit more of a fwd/mid role.
wot
There’s no way either Brodie or Actes are getting dropped. What are you people smoking?
Walker MUST play.
Darcy, Fyfe, Colyer and Walker in.
Meek, Banfield, Walters and Young out
Darcy, Fyfe, Colyer and Walker in.
Meek, Banfield, Walters and Young out
Contested ball and tackles, all the talk pre-season was Erasmus, Walker can take the smalls.
We need to get the flankers to rotate midfield.
That includes Erasmus and either Chapman or Young?
Darcy to rotate with Lobb forward, keeps the structure.
Walters maybe closer to retiring than Mundy
We need to get the flankers to rotate midfield.
That includes Erasmus and either Chapman or Young?
Darcy to rotate with Lobb forward, keeps the structure.
Walters maybe closer to retiring than Mundy
I thought Brodie was great
Yeah missed Colyers dash today. Walkers run too. Maybe too top heavy in defence?
Meek awful yes.
Walters must come out. If we are fair dinkum about depth and pressure on spots he must be dropped.
- Aug 17, 2009
- 3,478
- 5,408
- AFL Club
- Fremantle
Treacy>Darcy
Banfield>Colyer
Banfield>Colyer
Is Ryan playing injured still? I feel like we really missed Aishs' ball use and ability to go between contests in the back half. Walker is another inclusion we need. There's a few people worth dropping but I couldn't who and who are exactly.
Just a question. you reckon we're a liitle too top heavy in defence? Besides Clark we have little run.
Pretty sure there's plenty of suggestions for Walters and Henry to be dropped.
Brodie played well but if Fyfe is fit, he'll be better, and we can't afford to lose too much pace by adding Fyfe to the midfield on top of Brodie and Mundy.
Henry out for Colyer
Banfield out for Sturt
Waters out for Eramus
Treacy out for Amiss
If Hamling is fit, then Cox out for Hamling.
Add Fyfe and Darcy if fit, not sure else should go out. Would be good to get on more small defender in the team, and one medium tall out.
That is probably enough
Banfield out for Sturt
Waters out for Eramus
Treacy out for Amiss
If Hamling is fit, then Cox out for Hamling.
Add Fyfe and Darcy if fit, not sure else should go out. Would be good to get on more small defender in the team, and one medium tall out.
That is probably enough
Last edited:
Objective view based on first game performance
OUT:
L. Henry
B. Banfield
IN:
Darcy a must in
OUT:
L. Henry
B. Banfield
IN:
Darcy a must in
Who can we bring in, who could look after the smalls?
Man i am Henry's biggest critic on here but he went ok i thought. Walters must be dropped.
Meek had about 2 bad handballs but apart from that was pretty solid. Only reason he's out is because darcy, not because of his performance
Walker.
- Status
