What's he worth if he dont wanna go to West Coast or Norf in PSD?
On SM-A426B using BigFooty.com mobile app
Preview Round 20 v Melbourne MCG Sunday July 30th 3.20pm
- Thread starter _RT_
- Start date
- Tagged users None
- Status
On SM-A426B using BigFooty.com mobile app
- Jun 29, 2018
- 13,892
- 55,271
- AFL Club
- Richmond
Whatever the offer is I would match it
Kid has potential to be top shelf
Pissed off to see Ralphsmith instead of Cumbo
That class may be the difference. What class does Ralphsmith give us.
That class may be the difference. What class does Ralphsmith give us.
it would make no sense if he wasnt
It's a joke
domin8
Club Legend
potential is a dirty word. Just as likely to be back a Maroochydore in 5 years
- Apr 30, 2016
- 2,483
- 8,372
- AFL Club
- Richmond
Gotta feel for Cumberland and Coulthard. Racking my brains since the flags can only think of Dan Rioli and Caddie getting dropped for form reasons out of the core team. Nothing surer than Soldo, Banks, Mansell, Miller and even unfortunately Ross will be the next dropped regardless of how well they play.
Had so many passengers amongst the premiership players majority of the year and how nobody from our dog
forward line was dropped for Cumbo is an absolute disgrace. Til 3/4 time could barely think of 5 players who earnt their cheque and half were defenders.
Here's hoping our mids can kick majority of our goals against one of the best midfields in the comp again cos got little faith in our fwds. Wonder if can back May to get BOG and Jack to get donuts since all the no namers have been ragdolling him majority of season.
Had so many passengers amongst the premiership players majority of the year and how nobody from our dog
forward line was dropped for Cumbo is an absolute disgrace. Til 3/4 time could barely think of 5 players who earnt their cheque and half were defenders.Here's hoping our mids can kick majority of our goals against one of the best midfields in the comp again cos got little faith in our fwds. Wonder if can back May to get BOG and Jack to get donuts since all the no namers have been ragdolling him majority of season.
Last edited:
sante
Emu
We’ll be lucky to have 15 scoring shots
15.0 to 0.0
- Aug 25, 2007
- 3,134
- 10,111
- AFL Club
- Richmond
- Other Teams
- Richmond VFL
Ralphsmith isn’t playing instead of Cumberland, neither of them are playing at this stage.
Ralphsmith only got named a late emergency because Short was a late withdrawal.
- Jun 29, 2018
- 13,892
- 55,271
- AFL Club
- Richmond
Wtf? Why is it a dirty word?
We don’t know the future but his potential and upside for our club is ****en high if things align
he would be non-existent out on that AFL field
sante
Emu
Just like Stack?
How many years did Stack get?
How many games in a row did Stack get ibefore injury got him dropped? The club was even considering playing him in a GF coming back from injury. If he had played as well as Marlion in the VFL GF, he would have likekly got in over him. Dimma gave Stack SO MANY opportunities.
Cumbo's ride is nothing like Stack. Stack got kissed on the D for the first 2 years of his career. Cumbo was refused games behind Aarts, Parker & a Castagna that was playing so badly, OUR OWN SUPPORTERS, bullied him so badly he quit at 25. Then after all those guys got moved on, he still couldn't get a game.
There has always been a a certain level of double-standards tbh
Last thing we want at Richmond mate is players that show potential
Seriously, why do we even bother with some of these Nincompoops
The no Cumberland decision is a poor one. We desperately need goal kickers. If we lose, then that is on the club and Mini.
I mean FFS, Cumberland kicked 6 in the reserves last week and kicked 3 against the Demons in the seniors only a few months ago. It's the only time he has played against the Demons in his career, so he effectively averages 3 goals a game against them.
If he can't get a game off the back of that then we might as well give him away like we did Butler & just regret it later. I'm a bit disappointed that Mini hasn;t been able to get Cumberland on board enough yet that he can kick 6 goals in the reserves and still not get a game, i assume, because he is "not buying in enough".
I mean FFS, Cumberland kicked 6 in the reserves last week and kicked 3 against the Demons in the seniors only a few months ago. It's the only time he has played against the Demons in his career, so he effectively averages 3 goals a game against them.
If he can't get a game off the back of that then we might as well give him away like we did Butler & just regret it later. I'm a bit disappointed that Mini hasn;t been able to get Cumberland on board enough yet that he can kick 6 goals in the reserves and still not get a game, i assume, because he is "not buying in enough".
Looking forward to Miller making Adam Tomlinson look like Alex Rance while collecting 6 disposals, 2 marks and an arsey goal himself.
Harrison Bergeron tell me the stats of his last few AFL games .. ill wait
We always bring cumberland in cold off a vfl bye and then people complain why he not performing. Total mismanagement
domin8
Club Legend
How many players with “potential” don’t utilise it and fall by the wayside? Look how many top draft picks don’t go on to amount to anything on the football field. Potential is a dirty word it’s what you do with it.
Who cares Mate. He is contracted for another year and we hold the cards at this stage.
He’s not that good anyway at this point in his career. If he’s desperate to leave, let some club overpay, while we take it and run. I like him a lot as a player but the way he’s spoken of on here is just crazy. He’s not Dusty, or even Stringer for God sake. Just a player that showed great promise towards the end of last season, but when given the chance this season at AFL level, has done two thirds of F all.
Cumberland could have been selected over Mansell. Cumberland plays differently to Mansell. More of a marking goal kicking type. Could have added this to the Jack, Miller, Pickett mix, which needs something.
I'm glad we're winning. Who knows maybe we get smacked by Melbourne maybe we have a close win.
Well he certainly has an upside, a big one if he comes good, 6 goals last week, 4 the week before, suggests he is starting to find some of last years form.
But that would mean dropping Mansell, can't have that he's a scrapper just like McQualter was.
No changes? Geez did our coaches rock up 3/4 time? I just hope we don’t see Lever and May taking 15-20 interceptions between them
- Status
