Anyone dumping Gaj he's the man to get due to his Dpp and price even if he doesn't cut it as a premo mid he will be in every top teams final fwd line so can't go wrong....unless Gaj suddenly recovers of course.
-
AFLW 2024 - Round 9 - Indigenous Round - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
Round 3 trades
- Thread starter stevebbb
- Start date
- Tagged users None
- Status
BillyM
Rookie
- Apr 13, 2015
- 38
- 56
- AFL Club
- Essendon
Great, thanks for that
oh ha ha I strongly considered him but his up and down last year put me off but I'm regretting it a tad now unless he gets a 50 this week.Errrrr, toxic said no to him preseason. He's probably on the choo-choo train now
- Jun 16, 2014
- 2,795
- 3,117
- AFL Club
- North Melbourne
- Other Teams
- Manchester United
I like option 2. Extra trade but you'll come out on top in the end
Option a is a fair trade under the circumstances
You've got a few people voting option B, so let me make the Case for A.
Sloane and Rance are two guys you would comfortably have in your final squad. Two trades, two keepers, GAJ's form/price/fitness is addressed without harm and Goodes can be forgotten about completely.
In the second option, you're spending extra trades to get... how many keepers? Sloane, sure. Though you'll be paying MAX dollar for him. But NVB, as good as he looks for money-making is only a money-maker. He's not a keeper, and you only realise the benefit of a cow like NVB if you spend another trade on him later. And Docherty? As much as he's been Carlton's ONLY shining light and he's looked good, is he definitely a top-tier defender? Is he worth jumping on? If he's a keeper, than so be it, but it's still 3 trades to get two keepers, versus 2 trades to get 2 keepers at lower cost and sooner.
- Apr 10, 2014
- 887
- 1,166
- AFL Club
- Adelaide
- Other Teams
- WWT Eagles / Grêmio / Strikers
Hey lads,
I have GAJ, sheed, cripps, goodes, miller and lambert in my side. Who is the priority to trade out this week (if at all)?
Thinking GAJ is no 1 priority ... prob for Bont.
Also thinking about Goodes to Brodie Smith but might hold off a week due to concussion? In the meantime, should i get nvb in and who for?
Any help would be great - cheers
I have GAJ, sheed, cripps, goodes, miller and lambert in my side. Who is the priority to trade out this week (if at all)?
Thinking GAJ is no 1 priority ... prob for Bont.
Also thinking about Goodes to Brodie Smith but might hold off a week due to concussion? In the meantime, should i get nvb in and who for?
Any help would be great - cheers
PLEASE HELP ME ON THIS ONE, Im sure most of us are faced with the Gaz conundrum...
What would you do with this team? Trying to climb the overall ranks (currently 27,000ish)
Which of the 2 following do I focus on?
1. trade out Gaz to a top Premo Mid/Fwd (I like Shiel, Sloane, JPK, Treloar, Jack, Buddy, Pavlich)
2. bring in cashcows NVB or VDBerg for Cripps (I have all of the cheap Cashcows bar these 2, and I view Shiels, Docherty and McDonald as $50,000 cashcows next week anyways.....)
3. upgrade Goodes to Savage/McDonald/Doc in the backline
4. bring in Goldstein in the ruck
Capital Letters indicate players Im convinced I need to move......
Shaw, Lumumba, Newnes, Saad, Oxley, McIntosh (Brown, GOODES)
ABLETT (?), Fyfe, Wines, Dangerfield, Rich, Beams, Heaney, Ellis-Yolman (Miller, Smith, CRIPPS)
Bellchambers LEUENBERGER (Cox)
Bont, Gray, TexW, Swan, Bennell, Hogan (MClarke, McGrath)
What would you do with this team? Trying to climb the overall ranks (currently 27,000ish)
Which of the 2 following do I focus on?
1. trade out Gaz to a top Premo Mid/Fwd (I like Shiel, Sloane, JPK, Treloar, Jack, Buddy, Pavlich)
2. bring in cashcows NVB or VDBerg for Cripps (I have all of the cheap Cashcows bar these 2, and I view Shiels, Docherty and McDonald as $50,000 cashcows next week anyways.....)
3. upgrade Goodes to Savage/McDonald/Doc in the backline
4. bring in Goldstein in the ruck
Capital Letters indicate players Im convinced I need to move......
Shaw, Lumumba, Newnes, Saad, Oxley, McIntosh (Brown, GOODES)
ABLETT (?), Fyfe, Wines, Dangerfield, Rich, Beams, Heaney, Ellis-Yolman (Miller, Smith, CRIPPS)
Bellchambers LEUENBERGER (Cox)
Bont, Gray, TexW, Swan, Bennell, Hogan (MClarke, McGrath)
- Apr 10, 2014
- 887
- 1,166
- AFL Club
- Adelaide
- Other Teams
- WWT Eagles / Grêmio / Strikers
GAJ to JPK, Sloane or Treloar
Maybe Miller to NVB? It might be worth holding Cripps a little longer?
Remember people are only a cashcow if you have a trade left later to up/downgrade them. If you're bringing any of those three in it really should be because you're happy with them in your final team (and you probably could be, with those three).
Im keen to trade out Gaz for any other premo mid, but my mids are deep already, and all other positions (esp Backs and Rucks) I feel are deficient. No point getting in NVB or VDBerg if I have to sit them or CEY on the bench......
SimplySublime
Debutant
I'm gonna throw my support behind this suggestion too.
Ok need some help:
Option A
Ablett > Bont
Goodes > Docherty
Leaves me with roughly 200k to Upgrade Jack Steven to Premium between 550-600k.
Or
Option B
Ablett > NVB
Goodes > Docherty.
Will be short a premo mid for a week but then gives me roughly 400k to upgrade jack steven to anyone, plus another 150-200k in the bank for other upgrades.
Obviously not happy with Jack Steven, but he wont make or lose much this week hence why I can wait.
Option A
Ablett > Bont
Goodes > Docherty
Leaves me with roughly 200k to Upgrade Jack Steven to Premium between 550-600k.
Or
Option B
Ablett > NVB
Goodes > Docherty.
Will be short a premo mid for a week but then gives me roughly 400k to upgrade jack steven to anyone, plus another 150-200k in the bank for other upgrades.
Obviously not happy with Jack Steven, but he wont make or lose much this week hence why I can wait.
I'm in a similar predicament so I'm no help.lol
rocker_oz33
TheBrownDog
A.
Bont looks to be a keeper could be one of the top forwards at years end.
Keep a eye on steven there's selwood,beams even rocky in the coming weeks will all be cheap watch griffen and wines form also.
- Jan 17, 2013
- 858
- 538
- AFL Club
- Gold Coast
- Other Teams
- Patriots/Colts
My vote would be on Risch. He's practically got to carry the midfield this year (no Ablett or O'Meara) and his first 2 games have been excellent. Probably your best bet out of those four.
You cant not have Bont.... He is a keeper, NVB isn't. Also, theyre prices will rise fairly equally I imagine.
Therefore, Id trade Gaz to Bont, and then you have $300,000 to get whomever you desire.
- Apr 25, 2010
- 4,748
- 11,136
- AFL Club
- Hawthorn
- Other Teams
- Arsenal
No idea why, but I'm bullish on Coniglio at the moment. He'll get next to no attention with Shiel, Ward, Griffen and Treloar around him, and he can score big.
---
JPK + NVB OR Dangerfield + Rich?
Big Fozza
Premiership Player
JPK will be 10 5 mids season end and NVB should make more cash than rich
- Sep 29, 2010
- 1,678
- 1,914
- AFL Club
- Richmond
- Other Teams
- Aston Villa
Pretty tight, I'd probably go Danger + Rich. In saying that though you wouldn't think Rich would be a keeper so you'd probably be trading him down the line anyway, is that a bit of a waste?
Trading Gaz: was initially thinking Pendlebury, and then Sloane, and now thinking Shiel for the $$$ it will give me... Thoughts?
gutsroy
Brownlow Medallist
Had been prepared to sit with Cripps, but there seems to be a bit of word going around that rested for back soreness = dropped. Looking at three options:
(1) Cripps --> NVB
(2) N Brown --> McIntosh
(3) Freeman --> Heeney
Right to say (1) and (2) would be the priorities out of that lot?
Thanks in advance for any suggestions.
(1) Cripps --> NVB
(2) N Brown --> McIntosh
(3) Freeman --> Heeney
Right to say (1) and (2) would be the priorities out of that lot?
Thanks in advance for any suggestions.
2 & 3 are the priorities IMO. Cripps should get back into the team, so I'd hold until he is definitely out. Heeney will be a better cow than NVB I think & Cripps more chance of a game than Freeman it seems
- May 6, 2009
- 10,619
- 25,569
- AFL Club
- St Kilda
gutsroy
Brownlow Medallist
Yeah, that's what I locked in yesterday. On Freeman, think he wouldn't come into the frame for selection for another 3-odd weeks, but could be wrong.
- Status
