Round 3 trades

[FlapFlap]

What do you see both players averaging from this point in the season? Obviously doing that trade, would mean you have missed Halls Rd 1 and 2 scores, so it's more important that the player you choose averages more from rd 3 onwards. I'm not very confident on Barlow personally and think it's a solid trade, although Barlow could go back to playing mid this week, and end up being a good Pod.

That's a tough question. Barlow has history of averaging good numbers, and Freo are bound to snap out of this bad run of form. It's just a matter of when.

Meanwhile this could be the cheapest Hall will be for the rest of the season. Doubts over whether he'll keep scoring this well when GC get their full midfield back, but who knows when that could happen.

What value would you put on a trade? Is an extra 80k worth it?

 

[toxic]

So as it currently stands

Rocky - fat
Rich - pisspoor
Pendles - busted ribs/sternum/spine/pelvis/general soreness
Gresham - opposite of leather poisoning
McGovern - shoulder
The Chad - torn hammy off the bone
Lids - Quad/hip flexor
Harlett - busybangingsomeone

Who else can we add to the rumour mill for this week?

 

[KardiniaPark]

What are you doing this week toxic ? A friend wants to know

 

[Feerits Elf]

I hear Barlow died.

 

[Didstar]

That's a tough question. Barlow has history of averaging good numbers, and Freo are bound to snap out of this bad run of form. It's just a matter of when.

Meanwhile this could be the cheapest Hall will be for the rest of the season. Doubts over whether he'll keep scoring this well when GC get their full midfield back, but who knows when that could happen.

What value would you put on a trade? Is an extra 80k worth it?

I'd value a trade at more than 80k, however I think there is more to as it's a sideways trade of a premo. Sideways trading keepers isn't ideal, so when doing so I personally look for players that I am very confident will be a top player in their position. (i,e going rockliff to Danger). In order for this trade to be worth it, you need to be confident in Hall being a keeper, which comes down to your individual gut feel. If you're confident in hall, then go for it, and that 80k will be useful at a later time.

 

[FlapFlap]

I'd value a trade at more than 80k, however I think there is more to as it's a sideways trade of a premo. Sideways trading keepers isn't ideal, so when doing so I personally look for players that I am very confident will be a top player in their position. (i,e going rockliff to Danger). In order for this trade to be worth it, you need to be confident in Hall being a keeper, which comes down to your individual gut feel. If you're confident in hall, then go for it, and that 80k will be useful at a later time.

Thanks mate. Will have to think about it

 

[rocker_oz33]

I hear Barlow died.

So we get a grievance trade.

 

[Super Hans]

Krujan TheOz what's the go with Cripps? Thinking of getting him in for Barlow via DPP. Hasn't played great but still has two tons? Jut short of getting Parker.

 

[Krujan]

Krujan TheOz what's the go with Cripps? Thinking of getting him in for Barlow via DPP. Hasn't played great but still has two tons? Jut short of getting Parker.

I'm probably not the right person to be asking that question.

 

[PoopingHindi]

So as it currently stands

Rocky - fat
Rich - pisspoor
Pendles - busted ribs/sternum/spine/pelvis/general soreness
Gresham - opposite of leather poisoning
McGovern - shoulder
The Chad - torn hammy off the bone
Lids - Quad/hip flexor
Harlett - busybangingsomeone

Who else can we add to the rumour mill for this week?

Oliver - slow/fat/ginger
Dunkley - rested

 

[blackshadow]

Meanwhile my man Lonergan loses the man bun and does squat.

It can only mean good things for him.

I toyed with setting up a man bun only SC team but couldn't stomach researching the vile things.

 

[Pedro]

1.
Barlow -> Papley
Rockliff -> Mitchell

OR

2.
Barlow -> Papley
Gresham -> Ben Ken

Hold Rocky

OR

3.
Barlow ->Papley
Gresham -> Parker

Hold Rocky

I considered downgrading Rocky and Barlow for BK and Papley. At the moment I've gone for your option 2. Think I might hold onto Rockliff. Barlow just looks like a big mistake. Happy to correct that and get in the 2 rookies I missed.

 

[joeyp]

So have carried out the following

Rocky --> Paker (sideways I know but ill stick with Parker all year)
Barlow --> JJ via DPP

Banking 100k also...

Happy with my rookies...may have to lose Gresh when Petracca comes into the mix

Thoughts???

 

[Here2tellyouwhy]

So as it currently stands

Rocky - fat
Rich - pisspoor
Pendles - busted ribs/sternum/spine/pelvis/general soreness
Gresham - opposite of leather poisoning
McGovern - shoulder
The Chad - torn hammy off the bone
Lids - Quad/hip flexor
Harlett - busybangingsomeone

Who else can we add to the rumour mill for this week?

Barlow swallowed a bag of potatoes for a dare and it blocked the oxygen to his head and he forgot how to footballs.

 

[Here2tellyouwhy]

I'm probably not the right person to be asking that question.

View attachment 232689

You can tell its only round 3 because there's still some tissues left and the couch isn't white.

 

[Jcpdragonx]

So as it currently stands

Rocky - fat
Rich - pisspoor
Pendles - busted ribs/sternum/spine/pelvis/general soreness
Gresham - opposite of leather poisoning
McGovern - shoulder
The Chad - torn hammy off the bone
Lids - Quad/hip flexor
Harlett - busybangingsomeone

Who else can we add to the rumour mill for this week?

Just on Rich, I think his owners should hold him. He had a full pre season unlike last season and played exceptionally in round 1. He cant hold a tag but looking at his draw, I don't think he will be tagged anytime soon. I'm still confident he can average 90, he will play plenty in the guts.

 

[rocker_oz33]

You can tell its only round 3 because there's still some tissues left and the couch isn't white.

Later in the year he won't be able to type.........because of sticky fingers.

 

[toxic]

Just on Rich, I think his owners should hold him. He had a full pre season unlike last season and played exceptionally in round 1. He cant hold a tag but looking at his draw, I don't think he will be tagged anytime soon. I'm still confident he can average 90, he will play plenty in the guts.

Gone.

If he plays i mite reconsider

 

[stevebbb]

Just on Rich, I think his owners should hold him. He had a full pre season unlike last season and played exceptionally in round 1. He cant hold a tag but looking at his draw, I don't think he will be tagged anytime soon. I'm still confident he can average 90, he will play plenty in the guts.

Are people trading Rich out?? Crazy if so

Agree

edit: nevermind, toxic is haha

 

[Hear Me Crow]

....aaaaaaand Wingard is out this week

 

[Ingy]

Yeah I don't want to get rid of Crouch, but need cash generation. I'm still hoping in the back of my mind that Barlow could turn things around and then become a good POD.

Hold BCrouch

 

[Here2tellyouwhy]

Later in the year he won't be able to type.........because of sticky fingers.

Yeah but he could use his....oh wait, nevermind.

 

[Ingy]

....aaaaaaand Wingard is out this week

Yup. Bums

 

[stevebbb]

Might have to keep Barlow this week so I don't have to play Milera or McCarthy at F6

Sigh fml!

 

[Thuggee_Cult]

Hold BCrouch

+1

I have him too, he wont lose value and the pure mid rookies all pretty much suck. He is slowly getting better.