Round 6 Trades

[Faz 2000]

Wait, why are we trading Bennell? Cos he's just smashed out a 146 and is averaging 100...

He'll only be out 1 week, surely. Not worth the trade whilst you've got anchors like Goodes, Newnes, Lamb, I'd think? Even Salem *might* hit his BE this week (though I axed him for Pendles).

 

[buttox]

Thanks Toxic , ideally I wish to hold Hogan abit longer but I think Salem has pretty much hit his ceiling..

I've just reversed my 1st trade (Bennel > Pendles), I have $373,700 in the bank

Here are the options i'm faced with:

Option 1
Bennell > Hannebery
Salem > Danger or JPK (via Gray)

Originally, I had Bennell > Pendles but this wouldn't allow me to move on Salem

Option 2
Bennell > Pendlebury
CEY > Danger or JPK

Option 3
Bennell > Pendles
Salem > Buddy

What you think?

View attachment 131950

id actually hold bennell. i know its not what you want to hear. but i reckon hes a gun.

 

[Krujan]

Thanks Toxic , ideally I wish to hold Hogan abit longer but I think Salem has pretty much hit his ceiling..

I've just reversed my 1st trade (Bennel > Pendles), I have $373,700 in the bank

Here are the options i'm faced with:

Option 1
Bennell > Hannebery
Salem > Danger or JPK (via Gray)

Originally, I had Bennell > Pendles but this wouldn't allow me to move on Salem

Option 2
Bennell > Pendlebury
CEY > Danger or JPK

Option 3
Bennell > Pendles
Salem > Buddy

What you think?

View attachment 131950

I'd rather hang on to Bennell for the season than Andrew Swallow.

 

[Faz 2000]

id actually hold bennell. i know its not what you want to hear. but i reckon hes a gun.

He was underwhelming for a high 80s average in losses, but he's also someone who can go BIG in wins as demonstrated... like 5 days ago.

 

[buttox]

Thanks Toxic , ideally I wish to hold Hogan abit longer but I think Salem has pretty much hit his ceiling..

I've just reversed my 1st trade (Bennel > Pendles), I have $373,700 in the bank

Here are the options i'm faced with:

Option 1
Bennell > Hannebery
Salem > Danger or JPK (via Gray)

Originally, I had Bennell > Pendles but this wouldn't allow me to move on Salem

Option 2
Bennell > Pendlebury
CEY > Danger or JPK

Option 3
Bennell > Pendles
Salem > Buddy

What you think?

View attachment 131950

cey to pendles. one trade.

 

[Cool Cat]

right now form isnt really the issue
there perma players. all 4 of those should average more than shiel for the rest of the year imo.

Hmmm, food for thought. Starting to lean towards Sloane now. Do you have an opinion re Sloane v jpk v beams?Sloane or jpk in particular. Cheers for the input btw, very helpful.

 

[rog1995]

Is Geary to Yeo just trading one problem to another or is the Yeo in the guts move going to continue to produce decent scores?

Yes, I would wait a week or 2 and trade for B. Smith for less than 100k. I have Geary as well and will be doing the same trade.

 

[Jcpdragonx]

Going newnes>picken. yung mitchell coming in if he starts on the ground. 8/10 tells me this is a car crash waiting to happen, but i need to fix this 60k ranking...

 

[toxic]

Thanks Toxic , ideally I wish to hold Hogan abit longer but I think Salem has pretty much hit his ceiling..

I've just reversed my 1st trade (Bennel > Pendles), I have $373,700 in the bank

Here are the options i'm faced with:

Option 1
Bennell > Hannebery
Salem > Danger or JPK (via Gray)

Originally, I had Bennell > Pendles but this wouldn't allow me to move on Salem

Option 2
Bennell > Pendlebury
CEY > Danger or JPK

Option 3
Bennell > Pendles
Salem > Buddy

What you think?

View attachment 131950

SO in terms of cows about to be culled and rookies coming along

is it Salem then Hogan then....???

I dont like the option of getting rid of Bennell tbh

 

[Faz 2000]

Hmmm, food for thought. Starting to lean towards Sloane now. Do you have an opinion re Sloane v jpk v beams?Sloane or jpk in particular. Cheers for the input btw, very helpful.

JPK's track record is pretty hard to argue with.

 

[rog1995]

I can trade any Midfield Pre by Moving Gray to forward line for Salem, I already have Pendles, Selwood, Fyfe, Griffen, J Steven, was thinking about Watson Boak or JPK??

 

[buttox]

Hmmm, food for thought. Starting to lean towards Sloane now. Do you have an opinion re Sloane v jpk v beams?Sloane or jpk in particular. Cheers for the input btw, very helpful.

sloane has a high be and seems like 5% injured. wait a week or 2 on him.
jpk has played some strong teams, they have lost a higher ratio of games than they will for the rest of the year. would expect this is about his bottom price.

 

[Asho81]

LOCKED IN

CEY --> Glenn
Goodes --> McDonald (may change to Pittard or Picken before 7pm, but McDonald is in hot hot form)

 

[buttox]

Going newnes>picken. yung mitchell coming in if he starts on the ground. 8/10 tells me this is a car crash waiting to happen, but i need to fix this 60k ranking...

insane in the membraine

 

[toxic]

LOCKED IN ??????

CEY --> Glenn
Goodes --> McDonald (may change to Pittard or Picken before 7pm, but McDonald is in hot hot form)

WTF happenned to locked in?

 

[Burzum]

LOCKED IN

CEY --> Glenn
Goodes --> McDonald (may change to Pittard or Picken before 7pm, but McDonald is in hot hot form)

Why would you bring in Glenn after only one game?

 

[Asho81]

Why would you bring in Glenn after only one game?

Why not.....

 

[buttox]

Why would you bring in Glenn after only one game?

because
how else can he use 2 trades this week?

 

[Asho81]

WTF happenned to locked in?

I changed my mind whilst writing the post

 

[Gene Simmons]

cey to pendles. one trade.

SO in terms of cows about to be culled and rookies coming along

is it Salem then Hogan then....???

I dont like the option of getting rid of Bennell tbh

I can go Salem > Pendles or Hannebery (via Gray)

Or CEY > Pendles or Hannebery

??

 

[Asho81]

I changed my mind whilst writing the post

Ill probably crash to 50,000+ this week and give up and you wont hear from me after this round anyways. lol

 

[Danog]

Still can't decide between Newnes > TMac or TBC > Blicavs

 

[Burzum]

Why not.....

Because he's not going to go up in price and you've got no idea of the continued form he will have. What if his first game was a fluke and he averages 30 from here on?

 

[buttox]

Ill probably crash to 50,000+ this week and give up and you wont hear from me after this round anyways. lol

thats the whole point bro.
you will have bad weeks. you will need the trades later on.
you really dont need to trade. same as i said on monday.

 

[toxic]

Why would you bring in Glenn after only one game?

to facilitate another trade based on break evens / league matches / loophole opportunities / upgrades / 2 trades already planned for next week

multiple reasons possible

to simply dismiss the concept based on the "he's only played 1 week" is naive and shortsighted imho