- Sep 25, 2005
- 9,720
- 6,297
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
- Other Teams
- Gippy Power
Snoops Annual Mock Draft
You will have to excuse me it's a bit long but I actually really enjoyed this years because it is so open.
Few observations;
• I have tended to pick on needs / best available (if no obvious need then best available).
• Its a very even draft after #30. Deliberately haven’t looked at other mocks so will be keen to see how similar mine is or more likely isn’t.
• Rookie Draft will have plenty of talent as the 30 odd unlucky players have listed could easily be in the National Draft.
• Not a huge amount of ‘x factor’ players which stand out as ‘pick me I could be anything'.
• Calder, Oakleigh are the dominant sources along with the WAFL and VFL.
• Pool out of SA is as good as any year I can remember. Arguably have 5 of the top 12-14
• I am worried about Prestia - think he may go as high as #8, and Lycett. Mate of mine who is a Demon fan convinced me they will go tall fwd......I think Lycett then a tall fwd......he won.
Enjoy!
NATIONAL DRAFT
GOLD COAST NT ZONE SELECTIONS:
1. Steven May
2. Liam Patrick
3. Zephi Skinner
GOLD COAST QLD ZONE SELECTIONS1. Joel Wilkinson
2. Tom Hickey
3. Zac Smith
4. Rory Thompson
5. Rex Liddy
# Note: If Hickey does not get preselected by the Suns then he will go top 40. Outside of Day and Lycett he is the best ruck in the draft. Late season results were awesome and tested wonderfully. Nice hands, beaut hand balling skill, nice enough kick and very mobile.
Selection # 1 (GOLD COAST)
David Swallow – Gold Coast VFL / 186cm / 83kg
Selection # 2 (GOLD COAST)
Sam Day – Sturt /196cm / 90kg
Selection # 3 (GOLD COAST)
Harley Bennell – Peel / 184cm / 70kg
Selection # 4 (WEST COAST)
Jared Polec – Woodville / 188cm / 77kg
Profile : I didn’t initially rate this bloke that highly but as the year has gone on I have just become increasingly impressed with this kid. Was All Australian after a super Champs where his balance (great ability to stay on his feet in a contest) and penetrating left foot really stood out. Nice size and a bit like a few others in that he seems to have a bit more time than most. Adept at winning his own footy and spreading from the contest pretty quickly into space with his pace. Definitely someone you want the ball to be in the hands of when entering the fwd 50 as he excels at hitting targets. Finished off the year playing some really good senior SANFL footy.
Why Eagles: Suspect most if not all others (purposefully haven’t read any of the others yet) have Gaff here and he is the favourite. Eagles have inside mids and Polec is the best outside mid in the Draft who delivers them skill and pace. Polec is underrated on BF and and offers all that the Eagles need and is ready to go.
Similar to: Scott Pendlebury / Clinton Young
Roughie: Andrew Gaff odds on for this selection but I like Polec more. A real left fielder might be Scott Lycett insomuch as they see him working well with Nat and feeding an already impressive bunch of young mids.....and they can take a good mid later as you could argue there is not that much that seperates the mids in the top 30.
Draft Range: 4-7.
Selection # 5 (BRISBANE LIONS)
Dyson Heppell – Gippsland/ 187cm / 79kg
Profile : What Rolls Royce was to car manufacturing this kid is to a HBF. He is all class and has an enormous amount of upside in him. Dominated TAC this year and had a fantastic championship (MVP and AA selection) to boot. Played mostly off a HBF during the year but has been pushed up to the midfield more recently. Has really nice hands as evidenced by Lloydy’s test at DC, carriers the ball through traffic well and has good pace. Usually finishes with his left foot which has got missile like precision on it. Will compete well overhead and whilst he looks a HB’er to start a wing or midfield role isn’t out of the question in a few years time. For those looking for a comparison I would suggest he is a left foot version of Heath Shaw. Just has that ability to read the play that split second quicker and then really hurt on the offensive.......arrrgghhhh please land at Lexus!
Why Lions: Really debated Gaff or Heppell and I landed on Heppell because I think they have Rich who plays that Gaff role. Heppell gives them a bit more class and midfield rotation. Watch out for Lynch.
Similar to: Bryce Gibbs
Roughie: Tom Lynch is in the frame of the Lions recruiters for sure. If Polec was passed at #4 they should hit him
Draft Range: 4-8
Selection # 6 (RICHMOND)
Andrew Gaff – Oakleigh / 183cm / 78kg
Profile : Wonderful player who played champs the last 2 years and performed exceptionally well as he did at the DC where his results were amongst the best in many categories. Racks up the possessions and tend to use it very well (champs efficiency was a whopping 79%) particularly off HB where he likes to set the play up. Also very adept at centre clearances and reminds of Power & Dal Santo in how he can hurt without a heap of touches. Super in traffic, great first step and happy knack of finding himself in space which allows him to use his left foot with good precision. Also good at the little things – chases / tackles etc so cant fault him on that and has obvious leadership qualities as well. If there is a knock on Gaff it is that there is a view he doesn’t hurt offensively. In saying that he shown in a number of games he is capable so maybe it’s just the role he plays and what he is asked to do.
Why Richmond: Yes he is very smilar to Cotchin but who cares. Super talent and will ensure a quality midfield for Richmond in 2-3 years time. Between Martin, Cotchin and Gaff Richmond’s ability to win ball from stoppages is going to be awesome. They only issue is that maybe an outside mid would be better or a ruckmen to ensure they get fed the ball as much as they deserve.
Similar to: Luke Power / Nick Dal Santo
Roughie: Highly likely Polec is here so he may be the one. Daniel Gorringe or Tom Lynch
Draft Range: 4 – 10
Selection # 7 (GOLD COAST SUNS)
Sean Atley – Murray Bushies / 187cm / 82kg
Profile : Very highly rated junior for some time now and will be in the top ten. Has super endurance and had a very good year at the Bushies. Hard running HBF type who often plays in the midfield rotation as well. Very clean hands and more than adept at winning his own footy and departing the contest at pace. Good by hand and foot but it is his penetrating kick which I think is his big standout feature. No knocks on this kid.....none at all!
Why Richmond: I just think he is McKenna’s style of player. Can play in and out and carry the footy when required.
Similar to: Heath Shaw / Damian Hardwick
Roughie: Should hit Tom Lynch as they can afford the punt on this kid whereas others may be cannot.
Draft Range: 5 - 12
Selection # 8 (ESSENDON)
Josh Caddy – Northern Knights/ 186cm / 81kg
Profile : Just love this bloke. Saw a bit of him this year and every time just impressed me with the way he goes about his footy – tough, fearless and effective! Doesnt present immediately as a great athlete but his testing results were bloody awesome.....particularly his pace, agility and endurance results. Has a terrific sense of reading a contest and winning and clearing the ball. Can also be thrown around the ground a bit and think he will probably start more as a HBF who will push up into the midfield group. Terrific height for a midfielder and in addition to his clearance work his skills are very good, he can take a contested mark and is a goal kicking mid which always provides that bit extra attraction. This kid will go high. Performances and his testingbhave been terrific.
Why Essendon: Screaming out for some quality mids and frankly would be happy if any of the above fell through. Been rumours they love Caddy and he is a great fit. Nice fit with Melksham in years to come!
Similar to: Michael Voss
Roughie: Have good mail Prestia could go here. Lynch could be the one.
Draft Range: Great season, Great Champs, Great DC....cannot see him lasting long
Selection # 9 (GOLD COAST SUNS)
Daniel Gorringe – Norwood / 199cm / 86kg
Profile : I think most people know enought about Gorringe. Super talent, terrific year and was very impressive through the champs. Definately someone that will go top 10 and could go as high as 5 for mine. Been a part of the AIS squad so a lot of development has gone into him and you can tell that he does a lot of things you want out of your ruckmen. Got a nice leap and will give him mids in years to come first use of the footy. Your modern day ruck needs to be a link player and there is no doubt Gorringe could be that as he has good good hands for a big fella and nice hand and foot skills. Can go fwd as well and take a grab so offers a few different choices. Not sure how long before he is AFL ready but shouldn’t take long for him to grab his chance.
Why Gold Coast: Best available
Similar to: Dean Cox
Draft Range: 5-15
Selection # 10 (GOLD COAST SUNS)
Tom Lynch – Dandenong Stingrays / 196cm / 86kg
Profile : Tall forward prospect who doesn’t get here on results but rather on potential. Didn’t play with the Stingrays last year and was coaxed down to play by Hallahan earlier this year. Played 3 games pre Champs and was selected for the Country Side. It was the first time I had seen him play and I was really taken in with how he moves and the potential he offers. Terrificly athletic (albeit some of his test results were mixed) and comes from a basketball background. The upside in the kid is enormous because he shows that he can do most of the things you would want in a tall fwd given the way the game is played today. He moves very well for a kid his size allowing him to play a few different roles and hence will be hard to match up, he will chase and tackle and seemingly has a terrific motor - his beep was almost midfield like. Skills are good and has a capacity to rack up a number of touches (i think Hyde said he could play in the middle if they needed him to). Had a terrific game against QLD in the champs where he took some really strong marks and kicked a few goals in the second half. Notwithstanding people might say it was just QLD, from memory he kicked them on Crawford which was no mean feat as he had a really good champs and took a few very good scalps. Has come back from champs and been pretty consistent albeit yet to really dominate a game although reportedly had a terrific game in Wk 1 finals vs Oakleigh on Gordon and Otten. Notwithstanding, there is a bit of x factor in this kid and he is well worth a first rounder.
Why Gold Coast: Suns will take best available but he also suits as a potetial KPF
Similar to: Jarrad Waite / Scott Lucas
Draft Range: 7 - 15
Selection # 11 (GOLD COAST SUNS)
Patrick McCarthy – Glenelg / 194cm / 84kg
Profile : Was in the mix to go north as a Suns player but didn’t make the cut i don’t think (he may have knocked them back – cant remember). Played more HB at the champs where he was AA but will develop into a terrific CHB for mine. Outstanding athlete who moves really smoothly and can run off his man at will to pick a possession and hurt offensively. Also has a good leap on him and is exactly the sort of a player who in a few years could go with a Riewoldt or a Franklin who so many clubs struggle to get a match up for.
Why Gold Coast: I probably have him a bit higher than others but I look at where guys like Frawley / Reid etc went and think he has that capability as well. Also the Suns haven’t got a heap of young key defenders so it’s a logical choice.
Similar to: James Frawley / Jarrad Waite
Draft Range: 10 – 20
Selection # 12 (MELBOURNE)
Jack Darling – West Perth /190cm / 86kg
Profile : Kid is an exceptional talent and has dominated junior footy ranks for a long time...but he has some issues and it will come down to a club believing they can manage him. Many will remember he was a dominant bottom age player at last year’s champs where he was named AA and even then was regarded as a top 5 pick this year. Big question is whether a KPF or not. For me probably more in the Aaron Hamill mould as he isn’t quite tall enough to play key position (did grown last year though so may still finish at a 193cm tall in the Chris Dawes mould. Either way he is going to cause some serious headaches for the. Great contested mark who is very agile (spent time in midfield at champs), nice skills, gives you 2nd and 3rd efforts, skills are good and leads by example on the field......in short the kid is a super talent but I suspect his interviews will be fairly critical to where he lands as he has had some issues. I will bet he will become very John Brown like as the years go on.
Why Melbourne: Probably the hardest pick so far because I really rate Scott Lycett and Dees could use him. They missed on Nat but this guy (in my view only)is probably better. However, I just think Melbourne needs a strong and physically imposing presence in that fwd line to work with Watts (and hopefully Fitzpatrick) in years to come. Cook, Mitchell and Barden were also considerations and they would probably be there at the next selection if Melbourne wanted to go Lycett now, tall fwd at next pick and then get some mids – probably a very sensible approach as they have some good mids in Tapscott, Gysberts, Strauss and Blease to come into that side.
Similar to: Aaron Hamill / John Brown/ Chris Dawes
Draft Range: 4-15.
Roughie: Geez I wanted to pick Scott Lycett here.
Selection # 13 (GOLD COAST)
Billie Smedts – Geelong Falcons / 188cm / 78kg
Profile : Amazingly someone who hasn’t been talked about that much but a kid I have pretty high on the list. Is one of those players who is the ideal height for a mid and who pretty much ticks every box. Mostly plays HB but can go into the middle and fwd as well. Very athletic and I think was the best or at least one of the best in the agility stakes. Also has good pace, clean hands, able to take a contested mark, kicks nicely off both sides and just presents as someone who could play all over the park. Some of his footy at the champs was really impressive (particularly some of his defensive pressure and attack on the footy) and he was definitely one who caught my eye with some of his ball use off HBF.
Why Gold Coast: Was going to go Lycett as he is next best but they have a heap of talls and need someone like Billie a bit more.
Similar to: Heath Shaw.
Draft Range: 10-20
Selection # 14 (ADELAIDE)
Brodie Smith – Woodville / 189cm / 80kg
Profile : Another one of those mids who is likely to go pretty early because he has that wonderful height, running capacity and skill level you are looking for in your midfielders. Played in the mids at Champs but has been playing defence in the SANFL. Was close to best player at champs but missed game vs NT. Powerful kick which is pretty highly rated these days and in a game where is trending back to kicking skills it gives him great currency. Also able to repeatedly win his own ball and generate clearances to his side’s advantage. Only knock is his pace but he makes up for it in endurance.
Why Crows: Crows have indicated they would prefer a gun onballer and Smith is exactly that
Similar to: Jack Trengove
Draft Range: 10-20
Roughie: Would they pass up Scott Lycett though?
Selection # 15 (GEELONG)
Kieran Harper – Eastern Ranges / 187cm /80 kg
Profile : Other than Bennell nobody in this draft has more x factor. He is a huge talent. Many will have only seen his game on BF where he kicked 3 or 4 pretty impressive goals and to be fair that was his best game all year. He is a bit like Dale Thomas or more recently someone like Sam Blease (who I was also a big fan of) insomuch as he comes in with good potential but extremely patchy form which can be put down to a couple of injuries which have curtailed his fitness base. He is a super size (6ft) and has a great leap (4th at the DC) so going to be hard for the opposition in a 1:1. Also blessed with terrific pace (his first few steps are like lightning) and really clean hands. Makes that quick transition from hand to foot which so many clever fwds have as a signature. Also has a really good ability to read the play and make smart decisions. Executes well both sides and if can get consistent and injury free will be a really exciting prospect either up fwd or in the middle. The knock on him is consistency and his injuries. Also needs to develop his body a bit but and staybaway from the injuries.
Why Geelong: Require an injection of pace and class. Have a terrific list and can probably take a punt on this kid who has a lot of potential but formline is up and down. Probably not the next best player but again just think this is a bloke who the Cats could fall in love with.
Similar to: Dale Thomas
Draft Range: 12 - 25
Roughie: could very easily take either Watson or McCarthy if still available as want big backs. Dion Prestia a strong chance, Billie Smedts would be a chance and Jayden Pitt could be as well.
Selection # 16 (PORT ADELAIDE)
Jayden Pitt – Oakleigh / 187cm / 70kg
Profile : I hate these blokes........results to date good but potential massive. Where do you place them? Personally I think you have to place Pitt pretty high. Pitt wasn’t really on the radar at the start of the year but his champs were terrific. One of those kids a bit like Pendlebury who just seems to read the play so well and have more time than anyone else around him. Very light and his aerobic capacity allows him the ability to find space and select the right options with his beautiful skills. Also has the ability to push fwd and kick goals, so is going to be someone that attracts a heap of interest. All class! What is the knock? Body seems to get a few injuries so could slide a bit further!
Why Port: I thought about an inside mid here but preferred to take a quality ball user and then go for an inside mid later. I also think between Rodan, Salopek, Boak and Banner they have players who can win the footy in the middle. Getting some more quality outside players to help Pearce, Pittard etc made more sense to me.
Similar to: Scott Pendlebury
Draft Range: 10 - 30
Roughie: Dion Prestia....ala Rodan!
Selection # 17 (NORTH MELBOURNE)
Lucas Cook – North Ballarat /194cm / 82kg
Profile : AIS graduate who has been on the radar all year but it was the performance vs Metro in the Champs which will have scouts salivating. Kicked 5 goals and showed that he can be a potential match turner and has a bit of x factor. Also shown an ability to play behind the ball as well so offers some versatility for prospective clubs. Seems to read the play pretty well and leads to good spots, importantly he loves to play in front and lead at the ball which I always like in fwds. Gives an effort when the ball hits the ground and is pretty good for a bloke his height when the ball is on the ground. Finishes it all off by executing pretty well (one of the best performed at DC kicking test) and ultimately that is what he is going to be paid to do so a pretty good package for clubs to work with. Body will need some filling out and you would be well advised to leave him to it for a couple of years and judge then.
Why North Melbourne: I think the prevailing view amongst North fans is a quality key fwd albeit Hansen starting to show some form and Petrie as well potentially gives them a bit of height and ammo up front. Cook is a great fit because he can play fwd and back and so gives North a heap of flexibility as their young list evolves.
Similar to: Jack Watts
Draft Range: 10-20
Roughie: Kieran Harper
Selection # 18 (CARLTON)
Matthew Watson – Calder / 193cm / 91kg
Profile : Terrific player who isn’t dissimilar to Hurley but probably doesn’t have the pace and acceleration Hurley does. Plays as a KPB and reads the game really well. Has a weapon in that left boot and setting play up from the back half. Was waiting to see his results because I thought he might slide as his pace and closing speed sometimes don’t look great but his results were better than expected.
Why Carlton: These blokes definitely need a key back and the beauty of Watson is that he can potentially go in sooner than later. Real skill is reading the play and setting the counter attack up. Hawks will be hoping he falls I suspect!
Similar to: Taller Shane Morwood for those that remember him.....bit of class, effortless and nice kick but just not quick.
Draft Range: 15 - 40
Roughie: Wonder if they would take Darling if still here if he was available.
Selection # 19 (HAWTHORN)
Jed Lamb – Gippsland Power / 181cm / 78kg
Profile : Will appeal to many draft watchers and I suspect recruiters because offers that precious uncoachable commodity.....x factor! Had a super year and presented himself really well at the Champs where his best was on display. Played mostly forward and has that ability like Stevie J to do the mercurial things. Can also go into the middle and hurt as he showed for Gippy later in the year. Terrific core strength and is difficult to beat 1:1. He is a one touch player and a super kick(circa 90% efficiency in the Buckley kicking test) ... particularly lethal in front of goals (I haven’t checked but I think he finished with 40 odd goals this year and 45-50 last year). Other than that he has really good hands, shows a good lashing of dash and tends to make really good decisions in how sets up play, where he leads to etc.
Why Hawks: Cut Peterson, Stokes and Hooper, couldn’t get Hill done but alas Lamb is better and should go straight in given the quality around him.
Similar to:
Draft Range: 15 - 30
Roughie: Would suspect they are keen on Watson but if he ain't there then Pitt would be a chance here and has probably slipped more than he should. Dion Prestia would be another around this range. Also if Harper fell (and he could well do) would be a near lock.
Selection # 20 (FREMANTLE)
Reece Conca – Perth /184cm / 76kg
Profile : Really like this kid but a bit unsure where he lands principally because he doesn’t have a heap of standout features. Notwithstanding, you have a kid that has had a super Colts year and has played some really good state league footy (5 games incl a BOG vs Claremont). Backed that all up with a series of good performances at the Champs where he averaged 18-20 touches at a whopping 80% efficiency and hence I think will go higher than most think. Would describe him just as a very smart footy player who can play anywhere over the park. Good overhead, skills better than what you probably think but it’s how he finds space, the second efforts, chasing and tackling which mark him as a determined young footballer who will definitely go pretty well with his AFL career. The knock I think is these blokes often go a bit later because there is no obvious x factor but plenty of his type have proven recruiters wrong over last few years .FWIW – this kid is no dill either as he is doing a double degree (phys and commerce)!
Why Fremantle: Was thinking of Mitchell but just thought an inside mid of quality is a real need and I suspect they are keen on one of the three WA talls later anyway.
Similar to: I see a bit of Jim Kelly
Draft Range: 12 - 30
Roughie: Luke Mitchell
You will have to excuse me it's a bit long but I actually really enjoyed this years because it is so open.
Few observations;
• I have tended to pick on needs / best available (if no obvious need then best available).
• Its a very even draft after #30. Deliberately haven’t looked at other mocks so will be keen to see how similar mine is or more likely isn’t.
• Rookie Draft will have plenty of talent as the 30 odd unlucky players have listed could easily be in the National Draft.
• Not a huge amount of ‘x factor’ players which stand out as ‘pick me I could be anything'.
• Calder, Oakleigh are the dominant sources along with the WAFL and VFL.
• Pool out of SA is as good as any year I can remember. Arguably have 5 of the top 12-14
• I am worried about Prestia - think he may go as high as #8, and Lycett. Mate of mine who is a Demon fan convinced me they will go tall fwd......I think Lycett then a tall fwd......he won.
Enjoy!
NATIONAL DRAFT
GOLD COAST NT ZONE SELECTIONS:
1. Steven May
2. Liam Patrick
3. Zephi Skinner
GOLD COAST QLD ZONE SELECTIONS1. Joel Wilkinson
2. Tom Hickey
3. Zac Smith
4. Rory Thompson
5. Rex Liddy
# Note: If Hickey does not get preselected by the Suns then he will go top 40. Outside of Day and Lycett he is the best ruck in the draft. Late season results were awesome and tested wonderfully. Nice hands, beaut hand balling skill, nice enough kick and very mobile.
Selection # 1 (GOLD COAST)
David Swallow – Gold Coast VFL / 186cm / 83kg
Selection # 2 (GOLD COAST)
Sam Day – Sturt /196cm / 90kg
Selection # 3 (GOLD COAST)
Harley Bennell – Peel / 184cm / 70kg
Selection # 4 (WEST COAST)
Jared Polec – Woodville / 188cm / 77kg
Profile : I didn’t initially rate this bloke that highly but as the year has gone on I have just become increasingly impressed with this kid. Was All Australian after a super Champs where his balance (great ability to stay on his feet in a contest) and penetrating left foot really stood out. Nice size and a bit like a few others in that he seems to have a bit more time than most. Adept at winning his own footy and spreading from the contest pretty quickly into space with his pace. Definitely someone you want the ball to be in the hands of when entering the fwd 50 as he excels at hitting targets. Finished off the year playing some really good senior SANFL footy.
Why Eagles: Suspect most if not all others (purposefully haven’t read any of the others yet) have Gaff here and he is the favourite. Eagles have inside mids and Polec is the best outside mid in the Draft who delivers them skill and pace. Polec is underrated on BF and and offers all that the Eagles need and is ready to go.
Similar to: Scott Pendlebury / Clinton Young
Roughie: Andrew Gaff odds on for this selection but I like Polec more. A real left fielder might be Scott Lycett insomuch as they see him working well with Nat and feeding an already impressive bunch of young mids.....and they can take a good mid later as you could argue there is not that much that seperates the mids in the top 30.
Draft Range: 4-7.
Selection # 5 (BRISBANE LIONS)
Dyson Heppell – Gippsland/ 187cm / 79kg
Profile : What Rolls Royce was to car manufacturing this kid is to a HBF. He is all class and has an enormous amount of upside in him. Dominated TAC this year and had a fantastic championship (MVP and AA selection) to boot. Played mostly off a HBF during the year but has been pushed up to the midfield more recently. Has really nice hands as evidenced by Lloydy’s test at DC, carriers the ball through traffic well and has good pace. Usually finishes with his left foot which has got missile like precision on it. Will compete well overhead and whilst he looks a HB’er to start a wing or midfield role isn’t out of the question in a few years time. For those looking for a comparison I would suggest he is a left foot version of Heath Shaw. Just has that ability to read the play that split second quicker and then really hurt on the offensive.......arrrgghhhh please land at Lexus!
Why Lions: Really debated Gaff or Heppell and I landed on Heppell because I think they have Rich who plays that Gaff role. Heppell gives them a bit more class and midfield rotation. Watch out for Lynch.
Similar to: Bryce Gibbs
Roughie: Tom Lynch is in the frame of the Lions recruiters for sure. If Polec was passed at #4 they should hit him
Draft Range: 4-8
Selection # 6 (RICHMOND)
Andrew Gaff – Oakleigh / 183cm / 78kg
Profile : Wonderful player who played champs the last 2 years and performed exceptionally well as he did at the DC where his results were amongst the best in many categories. Racks up the possessions and tend to use it very well (champs efficiency was a whopping 79%) particularly off HB where he likes to set the play up. Also very adept at centre clearances and reminds of Power & Dal Santo in how he can hurt without a heap of touches. Super in traffic, great first step and happy knack of finding himself in space which allows him to use his left foot with good precision. Also good at the little things – chases / tackles etc so cant fault him on that and has obvious leadership qualities as well. If there is a knock on Gaff it is that there is a view he doesn’t hurt offensively. In saying that he shown in a number of games he is capable so maybe it’s just the role he plays and what he is asked to do.
Why Richmond: Yes he is very smilar to Cotchin but who cares. Super talent and will ensure a quality midfield for Richmond in 2-3 years time. Between Martin, Cotchin and Gaff Richmond’s ability to win ball from stoppages is going to be awesome. They only issue is that maybe an outside mid would be better or a ruckmen to ensure they get fed the ball as much as they deserve.
Similar to: Luke Power / Nick Dal Santo
Roughie: Highly likely Polec is here so he may be the one. Daniel Gorringe or Tom Lynch
Draft Range: 4 – 10
Selection # 7 (GOLD COAST SUNS)
Sean Atley – Murray Bushies / 187cm / 82kg
Profile : Very highly rated junior for some time now and will be in the top ten. Has super endurance and had a very good year at the Bushies. Hard running HBF type who often plays in the midfield rotation as well. Very clean hands and more than adept at winning his own footy and departing the contest at pace. Good by hand and foot but it is his penetrating kick which I think is his big standout feature. No knocks on this kid.....none at all!
Why Richmond: I just think he is McKenna’s style of player. Can play in and out and carry the footy when required.
Similar to: Heath Shaw / Damian Hardwick
Roughie: Should hit Tom Lynch as they can afford the punt on this kid whereas others may be cannot.
Draft Range: 5 - 12
Selection # 8 (ESSENDON)
Josh Caddy – Northern Knights/ 186cm / 81kg
Profile : Just love this bloke. Saw a bit of him this year and every time just impressed me with the way he goes about his footy – tough, fearless and effective! Doesnt present immediately as a great athlete but his testing results were bloody awesome.....particularly his pace, agility and endurance results. Has a terrific sense of reading a contest and winning and clearing the ball. Can also be thrown around the ground a bit and think he will probably start more as a HBF who will push up into the midfield group. Terrific height for a midfielder and in addition to his clearance work his skills are very good, he can take a contested mark and is a goal kicking mid which always provides that bit extra attraction. This kid will go high. Performances and his testingbhave been terrific.
Why Essendon: Screaming out for some quality mids and frankly would be happy if any of the above fell through. Been rumours they love Caddy and he is a great fit. Nice fit with Melksham in years to come!
Similar to: Michael Voss
Roughie: Have good mail Prestia could go here. Lynch could be the one.
Draft Range: Great season, Great Champs, Great DC....cannot see him lasting long
Selection # 9 (GOLD COAST SUNS)
Daniel Gorringe – Norwood / 199cm / 86kg
Profile : I think most people know enought about Gorringe. Super talent, terrific year and was very impressive through the champs. Definately someone that will go top 10 and could go as high as 5 for mine. Been a part of the AIS squad so a lot of development has gone into him and you can tell that he does a lot of things you want out of your ruckmen. Got a nice leap and will give him mids in years to come first use of the footy. Your modern day ruck needs to be a link player and there is no doubt Gorringe could be that as he has good good hands for a big fella and nice hand and foot skills. Can go fwd as well and take a grab so offers a few different choices. Not sure how long before he is AFL ready but shouldn’t take long for him to grab his chance.
Why Gold Coast: Best available
Similar to: Dean Cox
Draft Range: 5-15
Selection # 10 (GOLD COAST SUNS)
Tom Lynch – Dandenong Stingrays / 196cm / 86kg
Profile : Tall forward prospect who doesn’t get here on results but rather on potential. Didn’t play with the Stingrays last year and was coaxed down to play by Hallahan earlier this year. Played 3 games pre Champs and was selected for the Country Side. It was the first time I had seen him play and I was really taken in with how he moves and the potential he offers. Terrificly athletic (albeit some of his test results were mixed) and comes from a basketball background. The upside in the kid is enormous because he shows that he can do most of the things you would want in a tall fwd given the way the game is played today. He moves very well for a kid his size allowing him to play a few different roles and hence will be hard to match up, he will chase and tackle and seemingly has a terrific motor - his beep was almost midfield like. Skills are good and has a capacity to rack up a number of touches (i think Hyde said he could play in the middle if they needed him to). Had a terrific game against QLD in the champs where he took some really strong marks and kicked a few goals in the second half. Notwithstanding people might say it was just QLD, from memory he kicked them on Crawford which was no mean feat as he had a really good champs and took a few very good scalps. Has come back from champs and been pretty consistent albeit yet to really dominate a game although reportedly had a terrific game in Wk 1 finals vs Oakleigh on Gordon and Otten. Notwithstanding, there is a bit of x factor in this kid and he is well worth a first rounder.
Why Gold Coast: Suns will take best available but he also suits as a potetial KPF
Similar to: Jarrad Waite / Scott Lucas
Draft Range: 7 - 15
Selection # 11 (GOLD COAST SUNS)
Patrick McCarthy – Glenelg / 194cm / 84kg
Profile : Was in the mix to go north as a Suns player but didn’t make the cut i don’t think (he may have knocked them back – cant remember). Played more HB at the champs where he was AA but will develop into a terrific CHB for mine. Outstanding athlete who moves really smoothly and can run off his man at will to pick a possession and hurt offensively. Also has a good leap on him and is exactly the sort of a player who in a few years could go with a Riewoldt or a Franklin who so many clubs struggle to get a match up for.
Why Gold Coast: I probably have him a bit higher than others but I look at where guys like Frawley / Reid etc went and think he has that capability as well. Also the Suns haven’t got a heap of young key defenders so it’s a logical choice.
Similar to: James Frawley / Jarrad Waite
Draft Range: 10 – 20
Selection # 12 (MELBOURNE)
Jack Darling – West Perth /190cm / 86kg
Profile : Kid is an exceptional talent and has dominated junior footy ranks for a long time...but he has some issues and it will come down to a club believing they can manage him. Many will remember he was a dominant bottom age player at last year’s champs where he was named AA and even then was regarded as a top 5 pick this year. Big question is whether a KPF or not. For me probably more in the Aaron Hamill mould as he isn’t quite tall enough to play key position (did grown last year though so may still finish at a 193cm tall in the Chris Dawes mould. Either way he is going to cause some serious headaches for the. Great contested mark who is very agile (spent time in midfield at champs), nice skills, gives you 2nd and 3rd efforts, skills are good and leads by example on the field......in short the kid is a super talent but I suspect his interviews will be fairly critical to where he lands as he has had some issues. I will bet he will become very John Brown like as the years go on.
Why Melbourne: Probably the hardest pick so far because I really rate Scott Lycett and Dees could use him. They missed on Nat but this guy (in my view only)is probably better. However, I just think Melbourne needs a strong and physically imposing presence in that fwd line to work with Watts (and hopefully Fitzpatrick) in years to come. Cook, Mitchell and Barden were also considerations and they would probably be there at the next selection if Melbourne wanted to go Lycett now, tall fwd at next pick and then get some mids – probably a very sensible approach as they have some good mids in Tapscott, Gysberts, Strauss and Blease to come into that side.
Similar to: Aaron Hamill / John Brown/ Chris Dawes
Draft Range: 4-15.
Roughie: Geez I wanted to pick Scott Lycett here.
Selection # 13 (GOLD COAST)
Billie Smedts – Geelong Falcons / 188cm / 78kg
Profile : Amazingly someone who hasn’t been talked about that much but a kid I have pretty high on the list. Is one of those players who is the ideal height for a mid and who pretty much ticks every box. Mostly plays HB but can go into the middle and fwd as well. Very athletic and I think was the best or at least one of the best in the agility stakes. Also has good pace, clean hands, able to take a contested mark, kicks nicely off both sides and just presents as someone who could play all over the park. Some of his footy at the champs was really impressive (particularly some of his defensive pressure and attack on the footy) and he was definitely one who caught my eye with some of his ball use off HBF.
Why Gold Coast: Was going to go Lycett as he is next best but they have a heap of talls and need someone like Billie a bit more.
Similar to: Heath Shaw.
Draft Range: 10-20
Selection # 14 (ADELAIDE)
Brodie Smith – Woodville / 189cm / 80kg
Profile : Another one of those mids who is likely to go pretty early because he has that wonderful height, running capacity and skill level you are looking for in your midfielders. Played in the mids at Champs but has been playing defence in the SANFL. Was close to best player at champs but missed game vs NT. Powerful kick which is pretty highly rated these days and in a game where is trending back to kicking skills it gives him great currency. Also able to repeatedly win his own ball and generate clearances to his side’s advantage. Only knock is his pace but he makes up for it in endurance.
Why Crows: Crows have indicated they would prefer a gun onballer and Smith is exactly that
Similar to: Jack Trengove
Draft Range: 10-20
Roughie: Would they pass up Scott Lycett though?
Selection # 15 (GEELONG)
Kieran Harper – Eastern Ranges / 187cm /80 kg
Profile : Other than Bennell nobody in this draft has more x factor. He is a huge talent. Many will have only seen his game on BF where he kicked 3 or 4 pretty impressive goals and to be fair that was his best game all year. He is a bit like Dale Thomas or more recently someone like Sam Blease (who I was also a big fan of) insomuch as he comes in with good potential but extremely patchy form which can be put down to a couple of injuries which have curtailed his fitness base. He is a super size (6ft) and has a great leap (4th at the DC) so going to be hard for the opposition in a 1:1. Also blessed with terrific pace (his first few steps are like lightning) and really clean hands. Makes that quick transition from hand to foot which so many clever fwds have as a signature. Also has a really good ability to read the play and make smart decisions. Executes well both sides and if can get consistent and injury free will be a really exciting prospect either up fwd or in the middle. The knock on him is consistency and his injuries. Also needs to develop his body a bit but and staybaway from the injuries.
Why Geelong: Require an injection of pace and class. Have a terrific list and can probably take a punt on this kid who has a lot of potential but formline is up and down. Probably not the next best player but again just think this is a bloke who the Cats could fall in love with.
Similar to: Dale Thomas
Draft Range: 12 - 25
Roughie: could very easily take either Watson or McCarthy if still available as want big backs. Dion Prestia a strong chance, Billie Smedts would be a chance and Jayden Pitt could be as well.
Selection # 16 (PORT ADELAIDE)
Jayden Pitt – Oakleigh / 187cm / 70kg
Profile : I hate these blokes........results to date good but potential massive. Where do you place them? Personally I think you have to place Pitt pretty high. Pitt wasn’t really on the radar at the start of the year but his champs were terrific. One of those kids a bit like Pendlebury who just seems to read the play so well and have more time than anyone else around him. Very light and his aerobic capacity allows him the ability to find space and select the right options with his beautiful skills. Also has the ability to push fwd and kick goals, so is going to be someone that attracts a heap of interest. All class! What is the knock? Body seems to get a few injuries so could slide a bit further!
Why Port: I thought about an inside mid here but preferred to take a quality ball user and then go for an inside mid later. I also think between Rodan, Salopek, Boak and Banner they have players who can win the footy in the middle. Getting some more quality outside players to help Pearce, Pittard etc made more sense to me.
Similar to: Scott Pendlebury
Draft Range: 10 - 30
Roughie: Dion Prestia....ala Rodan!
Selection # 17 (NORTH MELBOURNE)
Lucas Cook – North Ballarat /194cm / 82kg
Profile : AIS graduate who has been on the radar all year but it was the performance vs Metro in the Champs which will have scouts salivating. Kicked 5 goals and showed that he can be a potential match turner and has a bit of x factor. Also shown an ability to play behind the ball as well so offers some versatility for prospective clubs. Seems to read the play pretty well and leads to good spots, importantly he loves to play in front and lead at the ball which I always like in fwds. Gives an effort when the ball hits the ground and is pretty good for a bloke his height when the ball is on the ground. Finishes it all off by executing pretty well (one of the best performed at DC kicking test) and ultimately that is what he is going to be paid to do so a pretty good package for clubs to work with. Body will need some filling out and you would be well advised to leave him to it for a couple of years and judge then.
Why North Melbourne: I think the prevailing view amongst North fans is a quality key fwd albeit Hansen starting to show some form and Petrie as well potentially gives them a bit of height and ammo up front. Cook is a great fit because he can play fwd and back and so gives North a heap of flexibility as their young list evolves.
Similar to: Jack Watts
Draft Range: 10-20
Roughie: Kieran Harper
Selection # 18 (CARLTON)
Matthew Watson – Calder / 193cm / 91kg
Profile : Terrific player who isn’t dissimilar to Hurley but probably doesn’t have the pace and acceleration Hurley does. Plays as a KPB and reads the game really well. Has a weapon in that left boot and setting play up from the back half. Was waiting to see his results because I thought he might slide as his pace and closing speed sometimes don’t look great but his results were better than expected.
Why Carlton: These blokes definitely need a key back and the beauty of Watson is that he can potentially go in sooner than later. Real skill is reading the play and setting the counter attack up. Hawks will be hoping he falls I suspect!
Similar to: Taller Shane Morwood for those that remember him.....bit of class, effortless and nice kick but just not quick.
Draft Range: 15 - 40
Roughie: Wonder if they would take Darling if still here if he was available.
Selection # 19 (HAWTHORN)
Jed Lamb – Gippsland Power / 181cm / 78kg
Profile : Will appeal to many draft watchers and I suspect recruiters because offers that precious uncoachable commodity.....x factor! Had a super year and presented himself really well at the Champs where his best was on display. Played mostly forward and has that ability like Stevie J to do the mercurial things. Can also go into the middle and hurt as he showed for Gippy later in the year. Terrific core strength and is difficult to beat 1:1. He is a one touch player and a super kick(circa 90% efficiency in the Buckley kicking test) ... particularly lethal in front of goals (I haven’t checked but I think he finished with 40 odd goals this year and 45-50 last year). Other than that he has really good hands, shows a good lashing of dash and tends to make really good decisions in how sets up play, where he leads to etc.
Why Hawks: Cut Peterson, Stokes and Hooper, couldn’t get Hill done but alas Lamb is better and should go straight in given the quality around him.
Similar to:
Draft Range: 15 - 30
Roughie: Would suspect they are keen on Watson but if he ain't there then Pitt would be a chance here and has probably slipped more than he should. Dion Prestia would be another around this range. Also if Harper fell (and he could well do) would be a near lock.
Selection # 20 (FREMANTLE)
Reece Conca – Perth /184cm / 76kg
Profile : Really like this kid but a bit unsure where he lands principally because he doesn’t have a heap of standout features. Notwithstanding, you have a kid that has had a super Colts year and has played some really good state league footy (5 games incl a BOG vs Claremont). Backed that all up with a series of good performances at the Champs where he averaged 18-20 touches at a whopping 80% efficiency and hence I think will go higher than most think. Would describe him just as a very smart footy player who can play anywhere over the park. Good overhead, skills better than what you probably think but it’s how he finds space, the second efforts, chasing and tackling which mark him as a determined young footballer who will definitely go pretty well with his AFL career. The knock I think is these blokes often go a bit later because there is no obvious x factor but plenty of his type have proven recruiters wrong over last few years .FWIW – this kid is no dill either as he is doing a double degree (phys and commerce)!
Why Fremantle: Was thinking of Mitchell but just thought an inside mid of quality is a real need and I suspect they are keen on one of the three WA talls later anyway.
Similar to: I see a bit of Jim Kelly
Draft Range: 12 - 30
Roughie: Luke Mitchell