Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
AFLW 2024 - Round 8 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
Balta is a star if he’s allowed to just play in his rightful position down back. He was ranked 1 for intercept marks in 2023, he’s a gun. Circumstances stuffed his 2024 campaign. Taranto and Hopper I agree are probably B Graders but both have had A grade seasons previously where they have been in AA discussions. Sadly hopper may never get his body right for the rigours of AFL footy.they are not guns, good players but not guns, Hopper may not even be regarded as a good player yet, still needs more consistency and get over his setbacks
Because they were rebuilding while we were winning our drought-breaking flag?but not just first rounders , they have ability to and put it on show
FOS is a better player than Walsh probably and Walsh would know and Wright with Hawthorn connection proabbly knows something about Tauru as well.
There might be a miss here and there but CFC has far more X factor and pedigree than RFC on their list
our window is looking pretty far away now.It’s ok Mr Magic we can trade Bolton back when we are in our window
1 for intercept marks in a year does not make you a star.Balta is a star if he’s allowed to just play in his rightful position down back. He was ranked 1 for intercept marks in 2023, he’s a gun. Circumstances stuffed his 2024 campaign. Taranto and Hopper I agree are probably B Graders but both have had A grade seasons previously where they have been in AA discussions. Sadly hopper may never get his body right for the rigours of AFL footy.
I know you're having an episode but trading is not acceptance of mediocrity. That was back in the Frawley days when we traded in spuds like Houlihan.that is the problem, acceptance of mediocrity at RFC
OK, this campaigner's cooked. When the **** did I mention Luke Hodge?as if pick 25 is worth anything much, lol
We need pick 25 to get Luke Hodge, yeah, nah
Another invited to my poker night. Pick up voorhees on your way.there's no need to trade him. But he has wanted out all year, allegedly. 10 & 18 do me, or pay his full salary if that helps.
$hai's on a $million. Bolton will put em over surely.
we wanted 2 very players, that cost us 2 1st rounders. Bolton has wanted to go home, mid contract. Freo are the only club chasing. They have 10, 11 & 18 are 2 1st rounders.Will we get 10 and 11 for Bolton or 10 and 18 is now the question??? We have up 12 and 19 for Tarranto and Bolton is a more valuable asset so I think 10 and 11 is fair. What do other people think?
Of course they do (cfc, have a better list). We are ships passing in the night. 2 differing ends of the cycle.but not just first rounders , they have ability to and put it on show
FOS is a better player than Walsh probably and Walsh would know and Wright with Hawthorn connection proabbly knows something about Tauru as well.
There might be a miss here and there but CFC has far more X factor and pedigree than RFC on their list
your too softwe wanted 2 very players, that cost us 2 1st rounders. Bolton has wanted to go home, mid contract. Freo are the only club chasing. They have 10, 11 & 18 are 2 1st rounders.
10 & 18 is not as good as 10&11 but better than forcing Bolton to stay.
Minor detailBecause they were rebuilding while we were winning our drought-breaking flag?
lol, when is their destination versus ours?? I give us 15 years and them 8.Of course they do (cfc, have a better list). We are ships passing in the night. 2 differing ends of the cycle.
AgreeAfter all these picks have come in
I genuinely do not see the need to trade Shai unless we get huge overs
We have 1, 6, 14, 20, 23 and 24
If we do not get 10,11, keep him
Thats the worst trade in trade history.Jees surely this involves 3 to the blews
Carl - 3
Tiges - 14
WC 12 & Owies
I do not rate Owies, nor 12, and 14, although 12 and 14 individually are better than OwiesThats the worst trade in trade history.
Can't get my head around it.
This is some wild revisionist history in Carlton's favour. They've been attempting to build this list since they picked Murphy with Pick 1 in 2005, they've had plenty of misses.lol, when is their destination versus ours?? I give us 15 years and them 8.
Tell me in 2016 did we get pick 3??? and in a draft rated to
Kane Cornes mentioned West Coast trading out previous pick and missed out on Sheezel. How did that go?
It was bold. Cornes likes bold.I know I'm a bit behind on this one given how quick this thread moves, but jeez I reckon Carlton have paid a huge price to get Pick 3 and they'd want to get the player they have their eye on, and have a good year next year, or it could backfire massively. I always think that Kane Cornes is a ****ing idiot, but to say they are one of the winners of the trade period based on what they gave up is insane.
They essentially overpaid by a Future 2nd and Owies based on draft points value alone.
true but I assume new guy Wright is helping them and they do not have SOS anymoreThis is some wild revisionist history in Carlton's favour. They've been attempting to build this list since they picked Murphy with Pick 1 in 2005, they've had plenty of misses.
Good, I thought it must've been just me seeing all that gibberish.
Will be even better when we take the player they traded up for eh eh ehIt was bold. Cornes likes bold.
Everyone saying Blues have killed it. They've given up 2 x 1sts and a 2nd for pick 3. It's a big price to pay.
The only really remarkable part of the deal is Eagles contribution.