List Mgmt. Trade & Free Agency - Fred 11

What Picks Will Richmond Get For Baker Bolton & Rioli


  • Total voters
    199
  • Poll closed .

Remove this Banner Ad

Log in to remove this ad.

We aren’t going to win the flag next year mate
Will Forte Reaction GIF by The Lonely Island
 
Would we compromise and take
10 -18 and 30
That's a capitulation, not a compromise.

They will compromise and give us 10, 11 and 18.

Well, I think we’ve officially found the poster with the worst mail on this forum.
Congratulations.
It's a Melbourne Cup field.

Although don't think Hicksy posts here does he?

They will trade 10 and 11 for Bolton once Baker is off the table.
They will trade 10 and 11 and 18 for Bolton once we've added 6, 16 and 23 to our kitty and tell them we're happy to keep him.
 
Do you have any more faith left to lose? You’d have to be empty by now!


Exactly. The club has pissed away a dynasty and gone from Premiership Cups to empty KFC buckets.

Club has targeted exactly zero young talent, or even competent back-up. If Kosi last year was underwhelming, what the f do you call ZERO the next season? Seem unable to get even close to the value of the players leaving & have now traded away the only strength they had - which was, they had enough picks to just "stick fat" & go to the draft and force their players to stay if the new clubs want to play "chicken"

By trading away 4 picks for 1, it now means we actually don't have enough decent picks to fill the "outs" on our roster - lol. So why the f are clubs like GC, Freo & WCE going to flinch, when they know we have already traded out all the 2nd-3rd rounders in expectation that we will end up getting a swag of picks for Rioli, Baker & Bolton - and gave away, for ****ing nothing, the pick we got for Graham? All we did is create more urgency on our side to get the deals "done". At the moment we will be taking 2-3 picks in the 60s+ IF we can't get deals done for Bolton. We literally took the pants off in the deal, gave them to GC, Freo & WC - then bent over to empty their dishwasher. Why would you do that? We now need to make those deals to go to the draft with a decent hand.

There is no "art of the deal" here - more like "fart of the deal".

Why the f did we just trade 4 picks for 1 when we needed those picks to fill out the roster? You do this trade AFTER you secure the highest reward possible for your outgoing players ffs & when you actually don't need them anymore. As it stands, without those picks, our draft hand is far far worse
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Baker -

Going to need other clubs to get involved , Solid chance we lose him for nothing in the PSD

apparently put forward Baker+F1 & F2 for Pick 3 and got knocked back

Freo need to better their contract offer before being considered





Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com
So the other day we knocked back a deal for 3 from West coast but now we've offered possibly 2025 pick 1 & 19 & Baker for 3.
Zero chance he goes into the PSD.

Not sure your intel is good. Doesn't make sense
 
They’re talking about walking Bailey Smith into the ND rather than the PSD. Same thing the Pies ended up doing with Luke Ball back in the day
 
I'm losing more faith in the club as each day goes on tbh. Feel like we will just settle for 10+18 for Bolton - which is a shit trade for us. He is worth alot more than that - guy has "Norm Smith" potential written all over him.

And the trade with the Lions - the longer that sits with me the worse it gets/feels.

We essentially upgraded 32 to 20 for Jack Graham, 43 + 45. I don't really see how that equates to good value for us, considering the Lions needed the points. Its like a worse version of the Jack Higgins trade. The club just seems to "not get it" still

It’s bewildering to me that you think the club “doesn’t get it” yet you, an internet forum poster does and you’re somehow more in tune with how best to manage our draft hand.

Graham left as a free agent (so the compensation isn’t accurate value) the pick we got for him is virtually useless. To bundle them up and attain pick 20 was a great move imo as pick 20 could still be a really solid player in this draft, not to mention with the other picks coming our way, we couldn’t have used all those later picks anyway
 
Exactly. The club has pissed away a dynasty and gone from Premiership Cups to empty KFC buckets.

Club has targeted exactly zero young talent, or even competent back-up. If Kosi last year was underwhelming, what the f do you call ZERO the next season? Seem unable to get even close to the value of the players leaving & have now traded away the only strength they had - which was, they had enough picks to just "stick fat" & go to the draft and force their players to stay if the new clubs want to play "chicken"

By trading away 4 picks for 1, it now means we actually don't have enough decent picks to fill the "outs" on our roster - lol. So why the f are clubs like GC, Freo & WCE going to flinch, when they know we have already traded out all the 2nd-3rd rounders in expectation that we will end up getting a swag of picks for Rioli, Baker & Bolton - and gave away, for ****ing nothing, the pick we got for Graham? All we did is create more urgency on our side to get the deals "done". At the moment we will be taking 2-3 picks in the 60s+ IF we can't get deals done for Bolton. We literally took the pants off in the deal, gave them to GC, Freo & WC - then bent over to empty their dishwasher. Why would you do that? We now need to make those deals to go to the draft with a decent hand.

There is no "art of the deal" here - more like "fart of the deal".

Why the f did we just trade 4 picks for 1 when we needed those picks to fill out the roster? You do this trade AFTER you secure the highest reward possible for your outgoing players ffs & when you actually don't need them anymore. As it stands, without those picks, our draft hand is far far worse
Solid melt here. I'd say about a 9/10.
Would have been a 10 if there were more hysterics. Room to improve RJK.
 
Why the f did we just trade 4 picks for 1 when we needed those picks to fill out the roster? You do this trade AFTER you secure the highest reward possible for your outgoing players ffs
Because if we didn’t someone else would have. The reality is Brisbane would have gone to the next team that can offer them points for their Academy bids.

Forget the worth of points. We can only take a certain amount of players in this draft and rookie draft and come pick 20 or whatever it becomes post bids there’s going to be a slider.

Having the last pick of the first round and first of the second are very strong picks. We either get potential ‘sliders’ or get way overs on draft night
 

Remove this Banner Ad

List Mgmt. Trade & Free Agency - Fred 11

Back
Top