List Mgmt. Trade targets 2022

[Buget]

I only follow for entertainment purposes. But I’ll take this.

 

[blackholeguns]

Scary proposition in terms of foot skills, with the possibility of adding Dunks and a departing Amon. Amon was fire and Dunkley hacks more than Freddie Kruger on a Friday night.

 

[Shaxx Attaxx]

I only follow for entertainment purposes. But I’ll take this.

View attachment 1511204

Well if “he can exclusively that” then I believe him.

 

[SureBuddy]

Scary proposition in terms of foot skills, with the possibility of adding Dunks and a departing Amon. Amon was fire and Dunkley hacks more than Freddie Kruger on a Friday night.

Yea that’s just not true lol

 

[blackholeguns]

Yea that’s just not true lol

Which part?

 

[blackholeguns]

Which part?

Maybe a little rough on Dunkley lol but even on the doggies board he’s rated as average foot skills. Can’t be any worse than wines I suppose

 

[SureBuddy]

Which part?

Dunkley is not a hack kick lol. He’s not the best in the comp, but it’s not a problem at all with his game.

 

[PatientMental]

Maybe a little rough on Dunkley lol but even on the doggies board he’s rated as average foot skills. Can’t be any worse than wines I suppose

Dunkley is not a hack kick lol. He’s not the best in the comp, but it’s not a problem at all with his game.

2022 stats

Dunkleys kicking efficiency was 58.5%

Ollies kicking efficiency was 54.5%

They both stink.

 

[Schulzenfest]

Inside midfielder has poor kicking efficiency, more at 11. In other news, small forward has poor hitout to advantage stats.

 

[TazD]

In other news, small forward has poor hitout to advantage stats.

Bodes poorly for the upcoming Rioli for ruck experiment

 

[SureBuddy]

2022 stats

Dunkleys kicking efficiency was 58.5%

Ollies kicking efficiency was 54.5%

They both stink.

Yea nah, that’s not it at all lol.
It’s just the position they play.

Oliver is 52%, Petracca is 56%, Neale is 56%, Parker 58%, Andy Brayshaw 59%, Laird 57%.

All dogshit players of course. Let’s not recruit any of them either.

I swear most of you complaining about Dunkley don’t watch any games other than Port ones and literally have zero clue. Dunkley is a flipping gun, stop saying otherwise.

 

[1954]

Jonas couldn’t hit the side of a barn

Bit harsh on TJ, if the barn was on the boundary line he would be a chance to hit it, maybe not on the side but at least somewhere on the roof.

 

[morell]

Which part?

Pretty much all of your posts have been off the mark in really weird ways.

 

[blackholeguns]

Yea nah, that’s not it at all lol.
It’s just the position they play.

Oliver is 52%, Petracca is 56%, Neale is 56%, Parker 58%, Andy Brayshaw 59%, Laird 57%.

All dogshit players of course. Let’s not recruit any of them either.

I swear most of you complaining about Dunkley don’t watch any games other than Port ones and literally have zero clue. Dunkley is a *ing gun, stop saying otherwise.

Efficiency is all cool man, but there are too many other elements to consider after accurately breaking down those stats ie length of kick (can they bang ‘em from outside 50 off two steps or on the run for instance), do they lace out from middle of the ground to leading forwards regularly etc . Prime example from that list would be trac.. similar efficiencies but vastly different kick qualities.

 

[Grave Danger]

I only follow for entertainment purposes. But I’ll take this.

View attachment 1511204

Poor Scoops - Twitter too rough for him was it, so found his home on Facebook?

 

[blackholeguns]

Efficiency is all cool man, but there are too many other elements to consider after accurately breaking down those stats ie length of kick (can they bang ‘em from outside 50 off two steps or on the run for instance), do they lace out from middle of the ground to leading forwards regularly etc . Prime example from that list would be trac.. similar efficiencies but vastly different kick qualities.

It’s a blunt instrument! You’re saying that because they all have similar efficiencies they’re legs are similar which is wrong.

 

[Powerade 08]

It’s a blunt instrument! You’re saying that because they all have similar efficiencies they’re legs are similar which is wrong.

The poster ur arguing with only looks at supercoach scores. thinks Matt Crouch can play.

 

[blackholeguns]

The poster ur arguing with only looks at supercoach scores. thinks Matt Crouch can play.

I can appreciate that some of my perspectives may be left of centre at times but relying on stats as a means to justify the quality of a player is sloppy.

 

[Bevoman]

The handling of Xavier was nothing short of an abomination this season.

If he wasn't picking up injuries in the SANFL while guys like Motlop and Mead got games ahead of him, he was a travelling emergency while attempting to come back from injury, unable to get any type of continuity in his football at all.

The suggestions in this thread of guys to play wing ahead of him range from unlikely to laughable. Farrell was playing off half back late in the season, Bonner is frankly terrible, and I won't even comment on names like Rioli and Finlayson that have been mentioned.

Round one we had six injuries, it was a disaster for us; Xavier hurt his collar bone but lost the trust of the coaches when de declared himself fit to play in Round Two.

Myth? Not sure. I know where that truth comes from though and you just have to watch him defending 1v1 or making a blunder with his kicking when there are too many options in front of him. He's not in my top 25 at the club

Bonner can't defend, he is a lovely kick but can't get his own ball
We should not play Bonner and Farell in the same side.

 

[Winganeen]

Bonner can't defend, he is a lovely kick but can't get his own ball
We should not play Bonner and Farell in the same side

Same side is ok, not at the same end if the ground I think.

 

[Tibbs]

Yea nah, that’s not it at all lol.
It’s just the position they play.

Oliver is 52%, Petracca is 56%, Neale is 56%, Parker 58%, Andy Brayshaw 59%, Laird 57%.

All dogshit players of course. Let’s not recruit any of them either.

I swear most of you complaining about Dunkley don’t watch any games other than Port ones and literally have zero clue. Dunkley is a *ing gun, stop saying otherwise.

The most accurate post on this thread to date.

 

[blackholeguns]

The most accurate post on this thread to date.

For simpletons

 

[Mitch PAFC]

Every time I watch Langon of Melbourne I think that's what Duursma can become.

On SM-G975F using BigFooty.com mobile app

And better. Don't look at this year as he was never on top of his injuries. He is tall, hard running, strong marking and goal kicking wingman and with a good pre-season can be elite.

 

[240volt]

I don’t get all this negative talk about Dunkley being a hack kick and not even close to the dogs best midfielder.

So I had a look at the TAB to see who was favourite to top there Brownlow count.
Surprise Surprise Sergeant Carter!

 

[Mitch PAFC]

2022 stats

Dunkleys kicking efficiency was 58.5%

Ollies kicking efficiency was 54.5%

They both stink.

If Brownlow medalists like Ollie stink, I would be very happy to have more stinkers like that at Alberton.