Under 19 Premier Division - Part 2

[The MUF]

Preliminary Final
TIME/VENUE
11:20*AM
Sat*11/Sep

Trevor Barker Oval
* OLD SCOTCH *
* vs *
* OLD XAVERIANS *

why would they have the u19 premier game on before the u19 south 2 game?

only reason i could think they would do so is to give the premier game first use of the ground

 

[realestate]

Re: Under 19 Premier Division

i dont think it matters who plays first muff
should be a great game, xaviers hardness vs scotches quickness
who needs to be stopped and why?
sansom ,red head
harangozo ,bull,c mehan
how are the injuries shaping up for each team?

 

[Rooster 24]

Re: Under 19 Premier Division

why would they have the u19 premier game on before the u19 south 2 game?

only reason i could think they would do so is to give the premier game first use of the ground

Probably because the South 2 game is a grand final not a prelim. I suppose it's fair enough that they get top billing.

 

[Wack]

Re: Under 19 Premier Division

Should be an absolutely ripping game between OS and Xavs this Saturday. Scotchies would be hoping for a nice dry day so they can look to use their tall marking forwards in Barnett and Van Den Broek. Xav's would probably like some sting out of the ground to get some advantage from the strong bodies of Nidam and Lees. Either way I'm tipping a ripping game and fancy it may be a close one come the final siren.

 

[meow meow kitty]

that red head thing should be locked in a cage
.
.
meowww

 

[BadBazza]

Reckon OS will beat OX. Despite the horrible conditions affecting both games last week, the 2nd semi was a far superior game. Take nothing away from OX - great win - I'll put my hand up and say weeks ago I thought Beauy would get past them. I was wrong big time! Conditions suited OX better, and Beauy's running wide game was useless. Given a nice dry day the surfer boys might have put in a better showing! Absolutely smashed despite a few big predictions on the forum.

Here's an interesting Q for the OX boys - if the 1's had got over Collegians and had a week off, would Goss have been allowed to play in the 19s this week???

Any changes for the De La side going into the granny? Didn't see any major injuries in the game so hopefully not.

 

[Oh Tayteridge]

Reckon OS will beat OX. Despite the horrible conditions affecting both games last week, the 2nd semi was a far superior game. Take nothing away from OX - great win - I'll put my hand up and say weeks ago I thought Beauy would get past them. I was wrong big time! Conditions suited OX better, and Beauy's running wide game was useless. Given a nice dry day the surfer boys might have put in a better showing! Absolutely smashed despite a few big predictions on the forum.

Here's an interesting Q for the OX boys - if the 1's had got over Collegians and had a week off, would Goss have been allowed to play in the 19s this week???

Any changes for the De La side going into the granny? Didn't see any major injuries in the game so hopefully not.

Agreed on Scotch, will be too strong for Xavs. Their running game and skills will simply prove too much for OX.

 

[Stan7]

Reckon OS will beat OX. Despite the horrible conditions affecting both games last week, the 2nd semi was a far superior game. Take nothing away from OX - great win - I'll put my hand up and say weeks ago I thought Beauy would get past them. I was wrong big time! Conditions suited OX better, and Beauy's running wide game was useless. Given a nice dry day the surfer boys might have put in a better showing! Absolutely smashed despite a few big predictions on the forum.

Here's an interesting Q for the OX boys - if the 1's had got over Collegians and had a week off, would Goss have been allowed to play in the 19s this week???

Any changes for the De La side going into the granny? Didn't see any major injuries in the game so hopefully not.

Correct.

 

[The MUF]

Ahhhhh don't you love to see Scotch choke and go out in straight sets!!!!

 

[meow meow kitty]

Ahhhhh don't you love to see Scotch choke and go out in straight sets!!!!

i would have to agree with you MUF..
garfield here,

it makes my ginger fur erect when i look at all the past posts and see how completely wrong every single person is on the forum, old scotch have choked up something extremely special, xavs coming into the game with nothing to lose and scotch being the nancy little boys they are just could not handle the pressure or intensity of the xav troopas.

meow meowwwwwww
i just purr'd three times lol

luff garfield the phat ginger ninja

 

[The Octopus]

It seems Xavs ownership of Scotch is not just restricted to the seniors. Funny.

 

[The MUF]

It seems Xavs ownership of Scotch is not just restricted to the seniors. Funny.

very.

 

[Stan7]

Great win by the Xavs.

Xavs Vs De La

MATCH UPS? THOUGHTS? ODDS? De La would be obvious favourites but Xavs with nothing to lose.....???

 

[the ox1]

Great win by the Xavs.

Xavs Vs De La

MATCH UPS? THOUGHTS? ODDS? De La would be obvious favourites but Xavs with nothing to lose.....???

nothing to lose.......except a grandfinal

 

[Stan7]

sorry i meant as in de la have been the dominant team all season, undefeated, its theirs to choke. xavs, finished fourth, come home with a wet sail, have had a good year etc

 

[the ox1]

sorry i meant as in de la have been the dominant team all season, undefeated, its theirs to choke. xavs, finished fourth, come home with a wet sail, have had a good year etc

I understand what you mean but i think the old "nothing to lose" quote is just an excuse in the case that a team losses can say well we lost to the best team, but if the best team losses then they have choked. Grand Finals are simple, best team on the day wins. Last year Xavs won an epic semi , both teams went into the grandfinal with minimal changes and de la won...better team on the day. Two years ago, St.Bedes thrashed De La by 70 points in the semi, grandfinal day De La had the game toasted as the underdogs then Bedes ended up wining by under a kick i think, Better team on the day will win, The team that steps up, because when your out on the field, you forget that you have come from fourth and that was a good effort or that you havnt lost yet, these thoughts dont cross your mind.

 

[meow meow kitty]

I understand what you mean but i think the old "nothing to lose" quote is just an excuse in the case that a team losses can say well we lost to the best team, but if the best team losses then they have choked. Grand Finals are simple, best team on the day wins. Last year Xavs won an epic semi , both teams went into the grandfinal with minimal changes and de la won...better team on the day. Two years ago, St.Bedes thrashed De La by 70 points in the semi, grandfinal day De La had the game toasted as the underdogs then Bedes ended up wining by under a kick i think, Better team on the day will win, The team that steps up, because when your out on the field, you forget that you have come from fourth and that was a good effort or that you havnt lost yet, these thoughts dont cross your mind.

well said ox1

meowwwwww
purrrrrrrrrrrrr
meowwwwww

 

[The MUF]

Beaumaris and Old Xaverians major melee, Under-19 Premier on September 4.
Both clubs accepted prescribed penalty. Beaumaris $200, Old Xaverians $300.

I think the fines system needs to be fixed.... how Beaumaris who started the melee get off better then OX

Thoughts?

 

[Rooster 24]

Beaumaris and Old Xaverians major melee, Under-19 Premier on September 4.
Both clubs accepted prescribed penalty. Beaumaris $200, Old Xaverians $300.

I think the fines system needs to be fixed.... how Beaumaris who started the melee get off better then OX

Thoughts?

The amount depends on your 'prior convictions’. If a team has recent fines for melees then the amount is increased. It seems the degree of culpability is not generally a consideration. No mercy shown from the VAFA when it comes to revenue raising!

 

[rightfoot_sloth]

All the votes from Under Nineteens Premier Section !

Name Surname Club Total
Maxwell van den Broek OLD SCOTCH 25
Edward Clinch DE LA SALLE 24
Hugh Nicholson DE LA SALLE 23
Jared Evans BEAUMARIS 20
Max Davis OLD SCOTCH 13
Charles Shaw UNI BLUES 12
Thomas McKinley OLD SCOTCH 12
Mark RAMANATHAN BEAUMARIS 10
Tristan Parker OLD XAVERIANS 9
Ben Nethersole DE LA SALLE 9
Jack Keegan UNI BLACKS 9
Timothy WIGNEY ST BEDES / MENTONE TIGERS 8
Adam JONES ST BEDES / MENTONE TIGERS 8
Daniel Harangozo OLD XAVERIANS 8
Thomas Hudson OLD CAMBERWELL 8
James Sansom OLD SCOTCH 8
Nick Dickinson BEAUMARIS 7
Alex Lattuada OLD CAMBERWELL 7
Angus Nice UNI BLUES 7
Ted de Fegely OLD MELBURNIANS 7
Stuart Sharp OLD CAMBERWELL 6
Jared Edwards UNI BLUES 6
Llewyn Butler UNI BLUES 6
Callum BYRNES ST BEDES / MENTONE TIGERS 6
Will Moffitt OLD XAVERIANS 6
Adrian Papamiltiades DE LA SALLE 6
Nicholas de STEIGER OLD MELBURNIANS 6
Lachlan Bennett OLD MELBURNIANS 6
Benjamin Humphrey DE LA SALLE 6
Jason Edwards OLD CAMBERWELL 6
William Minehan BEAUMARIS 5
Louis Tiernan OLD XAVERIANS 5
John McIntyre MARCELLIN 5
Joel Di Natale BEAUMARIS 5
Anthony Manakis MARCELLIN 5
Thomas McMahon DE LA SALLE 5
Michael Fort-Williams DE LA SALLE 5
Jack Gandy BEAUMARIS 5
Matthew Seed OLD SCOTCH 5
James Sharp OLD CAMBERWELL 4
Lachlan O'Connell DE LA SALLE 4
Will Mattingley BEAUMARIS 4
Nicholas Biddlecombe OLD XAVERIANS 4
Brendan Goss OLD XAVERIANS 4
Stephen Harris OLD CAMBERWELL 4
Thomas Brennan UNI BLACKS 4
Thomas McClusky OLD XAVERIANS 4
Hicham NIDAM OLD XAVERIANS 4
Ben Plant OLD XAVERIANS 4
Oliver Webber BEAUMARIS 4
Sam Quennell OLD MELBURNIANS 4
Samuel Killworth OLD CAMBERWELL 3
Declan Mitchell OLD CAMBERWELL 3
Jaryd Robertson ST BEDES / MENTONE TIGERS 3
Jack Hume UNI BLACKS 3
Timothy Lincoln MARCELLIN 3
Nicholas Voyage OLD MELBURNIANS 3
Aiden Orr-Farrell DE LA SALLE 3
Jack Amad OLD XAVERIANS 3
Jordan Pollard DE LA SALLE 3
Adrian Coburn MARCELLIN 3
Patrick Ambrose OLD XAVERIANS 3
Scott Braithwaite BEAUMARIS 3
Shaun GLENNEN ST BEDES / MENTONE TIGERS 3
Jack O'Halloran DE LA SALLE 3
Henry Hanlon UNI BLUES 3
Maurice Clayton OLD SCOTCH 3
Tom Ruggles UNI BLUES 3
Peter Aitken UNI BLACKS 3
William Hatfield OLD MELBURNIANS 3
Jack McDonald UNI BLACKS 3
Tom Hywood OLD MELBURNIANS 3
Nicholas Holt UNI BLACKS 3
Matthew Jane OLD SCOTCH 3
Dale FOLEY ST BEDES / MENTONE TIGERS 3
Jack O'sullivan OLD XAVERIANS 3
Hayden Darbyshire BEAUMARIS 3
Samuel Muttdon OLD SCOTCH 2
Nicholas Ross OLD CAMBERWELL 2
Alex Williamson OLD SCOTCH 2
Nicholas SEEBER ST BEDES / MENTONE TIGERS 2
Edward Marks OLD SCOTCH 2
Alexander Edmondson BEAUMARIS 2
James Bull BEAUMARIS 2
Nicholas Campese OLD XAVERIANS 2
Lachlan Gooley OLD MELBURNIANS 2
Patrick CORTAZZO ST BEDES / MENTONE TIGERS 2
Mark Todd DE LA SALLE 2
John Anstee OLD SCOTCH 2
Luke Bisset OLD XAVERIANS 2
Shaun Bryce UNI BLUES 2
Mitchell Potts UNI BLACKS 2
Jack Maxwell UNI BLUES 2
Harrison Lee MARCELLIN 2
Daniel MILLWOOD ST BEDES / MENTONE TIGERS 2
Daniel McMahon MARCELLIN 2
Nicholas Lattuada OLD CAMBERWELL 2
Thomas Hackett OLD SCOTCH 2
Ray Lengyel BEAUMARIS 2
Nick Madders OLD MELBURNIANS 2
Xavier Harkins DE LA SALLE 1
Dale Martin ST BEDES / MENTONE TIGERS 1
Tyson Rayner BEAUMARIS 1
Edward Furey OLD SCOTCH 1
Dan Isaac MARCELLIN 1
Robert Kemp MARCELLIN 1
Gregory Roberts BEAUMARIS 1
Jonathan Thomas UNI BLACKS 1
Grady Woods UNI BLUES 1
Robert Costanzo MARCELLIN 1
Alex McKenzie MARCELLIN 1
Scott Needham OLD CAMBERWELL 1
Anthony O'Shea DE LA SALLE 1
Nick BOTHAM MARCELLIN 1
Chris Bell OLD CAMBERWELL 1
Lewis Stutterd ST BEDES / MENTONE TIGERS 1
Henry Dick OLD SCOTCH 1
Corey Somerville UNI BLUES 1
Simon Bennett OLD CAMBERWELL 1
Anthony Chiodo MARCELLIN 1
Alastair Dugdale UNI BLUES 1
Michael De LUCA DE LA SALLE 1
Lachie Borthwick OLD MELBURNIANS 1
Ivan Sim UNI BLACKS 1
Joshua Kennedy OLD CAMBERWELL 1
Ari Loucas MARCELLIN 1
Luke Barda DE LA SALLE 1
Maxim Allen UNI BLUES 1
Jonathan Pintal OLD XAVERIANS 1

 

[The MUF]

All the votes from Under Nineteens Premier Section !

Name Surname Club Total
Maxwell van den Broek OLD SCOTCH 25
Edward Clinch DE LA SALLE 24
Hugh Nicholson DE LA SALLE 23
Jared Evans BEAUMARIS 20
Max Davis OLD SCOTCH 13
Charles Shaw UNI BLUES 12
Thomas McKinley OLD SCOTCH 12
Mark RAMANATHAN BEAUMARIS 10
Tristan Parker OLD XAVERIANS 9
Ben Nethersole DE LA SALLE 9
Jack Keegan UNI BLACKS 9
Timothy WIGNEY ST BEDES / MENTONE TIGERS 8
Adam JONES ST BEDES / MENTONE TIGERS 8
Daniel Harangozo OLD XAVERIANS 8
Thomas Hudson OLD CAMBERWELL 8
James Sansom OLD SCOTCH 8
Nick Dickinson BEAUMARIS 7
Alex Lattuada OLD CAMBERWELL 7
Angus Nice UNI BLUES 7
Ted de Fegely OLD MELBURNIANS 7
Stuart Sharp OLD CAMBERWELL 6
Jared Edwards UNI BLUES 6
Llewyn Butler UNI BLUES 6
Callum BYRNES ST BEDES / MENTONE TIGERS 6
Will Moffitt OLD XAVERIANS 6
Adrian Papamiltiades DE LA SALLE 6
Nicholas de STEIGER OLD MELBURNIANS 6
Lachlan Bennett OLD MELBURNIANS 6
Benjamin Humphrey DE LA SALLE 6
Jason Edwards OLD CAMBERWELL 6
William Minehan BEAUMARIS 5
Louis Tiernan OLD XAVERIANS 5
John McIntyre MARCELLIN 5
Joel Di Natale BEAUMARIS 5
Anthony Manakis MARCELLIN 5
Thomas McMahon DE LA SALLE 5
Michael Fort-Williams DE LA SALLE 5
Jack Gandy BEAUMARIS 5
Matthew Seed OLD SCOTCH 5
James Sharp OLD CAMBERWELL 4
Lachlan O'Connell DE LA SALLE 4
Will Mattingley BEAUMARIS 4
Nicholas Biddlecombe OLD XAVERIANS 4
Brendan Goss OLD XAVERIANS 4
Stephen Harris OLD CAMBERWELL 4
Thomas Brennan UNI BLACKS 4
Thomas McClusky OLD XAVERIANS 4
Hicham NIDAM OLD XAVERIANS 4
Ben Plant OLD XAVERIANS 4
Oliver Webber BEAUMARIS 4
Sam Quennell OLD MELBURNIANS 4
Samuel Killworth OLD CAMBERWELL 3
Declan Mitchell OLD CAMBERWELL 3
Jaryd Robertson ST BEDES / MENTONE TIGERS 3
Jack Hume UNI BLACKS 3
Timothy Lincoln MARCELLIN 3
Nicholas Voyage OLD MELBURNIANS 3
Aiden Orr-Farrell DE LA SALLE 3
Jack Amad OLD XAVERIANS 3
Jordan Pollard DE LA SALLE 3
Adrian Coburn MARCELLIN 3
Patrick Ambrose OLD XAVERIANS 3
Scott Braithwaite BEAUMARIS 3
Shaun GLENNEN ST BEDES / MENTONE TIGERS 3
Jack O'Halloran DE LA SALLE 3
Henry Hanlon UNI BLUES 3
Maurice Clayton OLD SCOTCH 3
Tom Ruggles UNI BLUES 3
Peter Aitken UNI BLACKS 3
William Hatfield OLD MELBURNIANS 3
Jack McDonald UNI BLACKS 3
Tom Hywood OLD MELBURNIANS 3
Nicholas Holt UNI BLACKS 3
Matthew Jane OLD SCOTCH 3
Dale FOLEY ST BEDES / MENTONE TIGERS 3
Jack O'sullivan OLD XAVERIANS 3
Hayden Darbyshire BEAUMARIS 3
Samuel Muttdon OLD SCOTCH 2
Nicholas Ross OLD CAMBERWELL 2
Alex Williamson OLD SCOTCH 2
Nicholas SEEBER ST BEDES / MENTONE TIGERS 2
Edward Marks OLD SCOTCH 2
Alexander Edmondson BEAUMARIS 2
James Bull BEAUMARIS 2
Nicholas Campese OLD XAVERIANS 2
Lachlan Gooley OLD MELBURNIANS 2
Patrick CORTAZZO ST BEDES / MENTONE TIGERS 2
Mark Todd DE LA SALLE 2
John Anstee OLD SCOTCH 2
Luke Bisset OLD XAVERIANS 2
Shaun Bryce UNI BLUES 2
Mitchell Potts UNI BLACKS 2
Jack Maxwell UNI BLUES 2
Harrison Lee MARCELLIN 2
Daniel MILLWOOD ST BEDES / MENTONE TIGERS 2
Daniel McMahon MARCELLIN 2
Nicholas Lattuada OLD CAMBERWELL 2
Thomas Hackett OLD SCOTCH 2
Ray Lengyel BEAUMARIS 2
Nick Madders OLD MELBURNIANS 2
Xavier Harkins DE LA SALLE 1
Dale Martin ST BEDES / MENTONE TIGERS 1
Tyson Rayner BEAUMARIS 1
Edward Furey OLD SCOTCH 1
Dan Isaac MARCELLIN 1
Robert Kemp MARCELLIN 1
Gregory Roberts BEAUMARIS 1
Jonathan Thomas UNI BLACKS 1
Grady Woods UNI BLUES 1
Robert Costanzo MARCELLIN 1
Alex McKenzie MARCELLIN 1
Scott Needham OLD CAMBERWELL 1
Anthony O'Shea DE LA SALLE 1
Nick BOTHAM MARCELLIN 1
Chris Bell OLD CAMBERWELL 1
Lewis Stutterd ST BEDES / MENTONE TIGERS 1
Henry Dick OLD SCOTCH 1
Corey Somerville UNI BLUES 1
Simon Bennett OLD CAMBERWELL 1
Anthony Chiodo MARCELLIN 1
Alastair Dugdale UNI BLUES 1
Michael De LUCA DE LA SALLE 1
Lachie Borthwick OLD MELBURNIANS 1
Ivan Sim UNI BLACKS 1
Joshua Kennedy OLD CAMBERWELL 1
Ari Loucas MARCELLIN 1
Luke Barda DE LA SALLE 1
Maxim Allen UNI BLUES 1
Jonathan Pintal OLD XAVERIANS 1

Slow day at work/uni?

Also amazed that the top 2 goal kickers in the league only polled a combined 5 votes!!!

 

[The MUF]

Slow day at work/uni?

Also amazed that the top 2 goal kickers in the league only polled a combined 5 votes!!!

And that B.Goss didnt poll for kicking 10!!!

 

[Rooster 24]

And that B.Goss didnt poll for kicking 10!!!

This is why club B & F’s are a far better indication of a players worth.
DLS B & F was tie for 1st between Tom and Ben Humphrey (2 brothers - has that ever happened before?) Tom was probably the most consistent member of the team across the year but did not poll one vote in the league B & F. Allan from UB kicked a few bags but gets just 1 vote for the year and Goss gets 0 for a 10 goal game. Please ..……

Max VDB and Ed Clinch are top line players and deserve recognition but unless you play in the midfield you can forget about winning a comp B & F.

 

[boomer_29]

Beaumaris and Old Xaverians major melee, Under-19 Premier on September 4.
Both clubs accepted prescribed penalty. Beaumaris $200, Old Xaverians $300.

I think the fines system needs to be fixed.... how Beaumaris who started the melee get off better then OX

Thoughts?

There is no way beaumaris started the fight, that is a fact.

 

[The MUF]

There is no way beaumaris started the fight, that is a fact.

getting bent over and given a new one and wanting to win something on the day??