List Mgmt. Welcome Jack Petruccelle (Pick 38, 2017 National Draft)

Remove this Banner Ad

Matera was a natural and unique footy player.
Have we seen anyone quite like Matera since, with that burst speed, swervability and goal sense?
I seriously doubt Petch can be 'trained' to be like Matera?
But he does have some attributes that could be developed into a handy and consistent role, as long as he doesn't list-clog or prevent another more natural footy player a shot.

He was performing quite well-or heading in the right direction before Covid, with still the occasional brain farts.
Like some other players he had an interrupted season - let's hope they really take him aside and drill him with forward/wing smarts and shots on the run/tackling etc.
Even Jaydyn Stephenson went downhill in 2020..
It was a tough year to judge anyone too harshly, there's been a bit of collateral damage or fallout throughout most clubs? (coaches included)
 

Log in to remove this ad.

Optemizer said:
Others on here have said it and i agree, The best position i think for Petch is on the wing. Use his pace to provide an option out of defence. Fingers crossed with enough development he can be like Peter Matera.
Click to expand...
Nothing worse than a winger with poor ball use though.........
 
Optemizer said:
Others on here have said it and i agree, The best position i think for Petch is on the wing. Use his pace to provide an option out of defence. Fingers crossed with enough development he can be like Peter Matera.
Click to expand...

Haha, you can’t use Peter Matera in any conversation with Petch.
Petch would not be a star on the wing in A grade amateurs. He can’t find the ball in the WAFL. Matera is in the top 5 players the club has ever seen.
I just don’t get what the club and people see that Petch has to offer? No footy brain, poorly skilled, no awareness, no toughness. He is a quick runner and that’s it. Like any player if you give them enough chances once in a blue moon he may have a day out with 15 disposals and 3-4 goals. He has had enough games to find out what it’s all about.
I don’t blame him though, not his fault the club is willing to keep paying him.
 
Astro7 said:
Haha, NO...there was Judd and there was Matera aka Roo!
Similar but two different sports cars inmho...
Unless Judd could launch raking goals on the run from the wing?
Click to expand...

With no offence intended to Matera but Judd creating goals and scoring opportunities from stoppages was something to behold.
Burst speed and swervability is exactly how I would describe Judd as an Eagle.
If you have a look at the video below you will see many examples of this. Early on in this video there is two goals against Port Adelaide that exemplify this, or the two goals in succession against Fremantle, or the goal against Melbourne at the six and a half minute mark, or the goal against the Bulldogs at about the 7 minute mark, or the goal against Port Adelaide straight after that, or the goal against Port Adelaide at the 8 and a half minute mark, or the goal against Carlton at the 10 and a half minute mark, or the goal against Collingwood at the 12 minute mark, or the goal against Richmond at the 12 minute 45 second mark, or the goal against the Bulldogs at the 14 minute mark. Fair to say he was exceptional at long range goals on the burst.
In fact his modus operandi was bursting from a stoppage/congestion from the centre to pin point goals. This is about as valuable a contribution as you can get from a inside/outside midfielder.
I'm just not sure what you have to criticism him about, even in comparison to Matera (who I regard as the best Eagles player to this point in history).
 
eaglespremiers said:
With no offence intended to Matera but Judd creating goals and scoring opportunities from stoppages was something to behold.
Burst speed and swervability is exactly how I would describe Judd as an Eagle.
If you have a look at the video below you will see many examples of this. Early on in this video there is two goals against Port Adelaide that exemplify this, or the two goals in succession against Fremantle, or the goal against Melbourne at the six and a half minute mark, or the goal against the Bulldogs at about the 7 minute mark, or the goal against Port Adelaide straight after that, or the goal against Port Adelaide at the 8 and a half minute mark, or the goal against Carlton at the 10 and a half minute mark, or the goal against Collingwood at the 12 minute mark, or the goal against Richmond at the 12 minute 45 second mark, or the goal against the Bulldogs at the 14 minute mark. Fair to say he was exceptional at long range goals on the burst.
In fact his modus operandi was bursting from a stoppage/congestion from the centre to pin point goals. This is about as valuable a contribution as you can get from a inside/outside midfielder.
I'm just not sure what you have to criticism him about, even in comparison to Matera (who I regard as the best Eagles player to this point in history).
Click to expand...

No sweat, can't believe you devoted so much time and detail to this lighthearted pitch?
I haven't criticised Judd, I just prefer Matera over Judd, personal opinion-am not going to devote pages on analysing it. You like Judd, great! Enjoy!
 
eaglespremiers said:
With no offence intended to Matera but Judd creating goals and scoring opportunities from stoppages was something to behold.
Burst speed and swervability is exactly how I would describe Judd as an Eagle.
If you have a look at the video below you will see many examples of this. Early on in this video there is two goals against Port Adelaide that exemplify this, or the two goals in succession against Fremantle, or the goal against Melbourne at the six and a half minute mark, or the goal against the Bulldogs at about the 7 minute mark, or the goal against Port Adelaide straight after that, or the goal against Port Adelaide at the 8 and a half minute mark, or the goal against Carlton at the 10 and a half minute mark, or the goal against Collingwood at the 12 minute mark, or the goal against Richmond at the 12 minute 45 second mark, or the goal against the Bulldogs at the 14 minute mark. Fair to say he was exceptional at long range goals on the burst.
In fact his modus operandi was bursting from a stoppage/congestion from the centre to pin point goals. This is about as valuable a contribution as you can get from a inside/outside midfielder.
I'm just not sure what you have to criticism him about, even in comparison to Matera (who I regard as the best Eagles player to this point in history).
Click to expand...


Matera in the modern game would be devastating, could kick 50 + on either foot with deadly accuracy and at top pace. Terrific over head and no better player with the ball below his knees.

Would be a top 5 player in the comp without question.
 
Matera92 said:
Matera in the modern game would be devastating, could kick 50 + on either foot with deadly accuracy and at top pace. Terrific over head and no better player with the ball below his knees.

Would be a top 5 player in the comp without question.
Click to expand...
I'm not diminishing Matera's abilities at all. Just the previous posters suppositions about Judd.

Sent from my SM-G965F using Tapatalk
 
Matera92 said:
Matera in the modern game would be devastating, could kick 50 + on either foot with deadly accuracy and at top pace. Terrific over head and no better player with the ball below his knees.

Would be a top 5 player in the comp without question.
Click to expand...

And while he didnt have blistering top speed his first few steps were as fast as anyone.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Both Judd and Matera were footballers first and Athletes second. Petch is the other way around. He doesn't have the the skills or the brain those two had. Some of those Judd goals were unbelievable and would still be freakish today.
 
Massive preseason and move to the wing please or high half forward role please. We’re dying for midfield speed and in 2019 he looked so close to ripping a few games apart running on to the loose ball and burning opponents off. Decent overhead and 5 goals in a match in your second year. Comes down to how fit he wants to get. Hope he’s started training already
 
Astro7 said:
Matera was a natural and unique footy player.
Have we seen anyone quite like Matera since, with that burst speed, swervability and goal sense?
I seriously doubt Petch can be 'trained' to be like Matera?
But he does have some attributes that could be developed into a handy and consistent role, as long as he doesn't list-clog or prevent another more natural footy player a shot.

He was performing quite well-or heading in the right direction before Covid, with still the occasional brain farts.
Like some other players he had an interrupted season - let's hope they really take him aside and drill him with forward/wing smarts and shots on the run/tackling etc.
Even Jaydyn Stephenson went downhill in 2020..
It was a tough year to judge anyone too harshly, there's been a bit of collateral damage or fallout throughout most clubs? (coaches included)
Click to expand...
Peter Materas are born not made. Would be a top 1-2 draft pick these days.
Thats not Petch but he can play a role. Ridiculous to compare
 
eaglespremiers said:
With no offence intended to Matera but Judd creating goals and scoring opportunities from stoppages was something to behold.
Burst speed and swervability is exactly how I would describe Judd as an Eagle.
If you have a look at the video below you will see many examples of this. Early on in this video there is two goals against Port Adelaide that exemplify this, or the two goals in succession against Fremantle, or the goal against Melbourne at the six and a half minute mark, or the goal against the Bulldogs at about the 7 minute mark, or the goal against Port Adelaide straight after that, or the goal against Port Adelaide at the 8 and a half minute mark, or the goal against Carlton at the 10 and a half minute mark, or the goal against Collingwood at the 12 minute mark, or the goal against Richmond at the 12 minute 45 second mark, or the goal against the Bulldogs at the 14 minute mark. Fair to say he was exceptional at long range goals on the burst.
In fact his modus operandi was bursting from a stoppage/congestion from the centre to pin point goals. This is about as valuable a contribution as you can get from a inside/outside midfielder.
I'm just not sure what you have to criticism him about, even in comparison to Matera (who I regard as the best Eagles player to this point in history).
Click to expand...


15 minutes of Judd highlights with coffee to start my day is a great way to begin
 
eaglespremiers said:
I'm not diminishing Matera's abilities at all. Just the previous posters suppositions about Judd.

Sent from my SM-G965F using Tapatalk
Click to expand...
Must be the off-season?
My post was referring to a previous poster's fanciful comparison with Petch becoming a Matera?
I made no mention of Judd, you brought him into the debate and proceeded to swing the topic to Judd? Suppositions - really? I prefer Matera because I watched those GF's as they occurred back in the day and because Matera was a legend long before Judd arrived. In fact when a 23 yr old Matera tore Geelong apart, Judd was 9 yrs old. Yes, many idolise Judd, but Matera's GF performance/s were outstanding and the fact is Matera came first. Surely this debate has been done to death many times.
Each to their own Mr. Swervability!
 
Last edited:
Astro7 said:
Must be the off-season?
My post was referring to a previous poster's fanciful comparison Petch with becoming a Matera?
I made no mention of Judd, you brought him into the debate and proceeded to swing the topic to Judd? Suppositions - really? I prefer Matera because I watched those GF's as they occurred back in the day and because Matera was a legend long before Judd arrived. In fact when a 23 yr old Matera tore Geelong apart, Judd was 9 yrs old. Yes, many idolise Judd, but Matera's GF performance/s were outstanding and the fact is Matera came first. Surely this debate has been done to death many times.
Each to their own Mr. Swervability!
Click to expand...

I think i'm at fault for bringing Judd into this.
Compared Judd's goal kicking to Matera's but neither is even in the same dimension with Petruccelle for ability
 

Remove this Banner Ad

List Mgmt. Welcome Jack Petruccelle (Pick 38, 2017 National Draft)

Similar threads

eaglespremiers
List Mgmt. Welcome Hamish Davis (Pick 65, 2024 National Draft)
2 3 4
Replies
90
Views
8K
Bacchus
Bacchus
Bleedblueandgold
List Mgmt. Welcome Lucca Grego (Pick 48, 2024 National Draft)
5 6 7 8 9
Replies
208
Views
18K
MeltMan
MeltMan
Bleedblueandgold
List Mgmt. Welcome Tom Gross (Pick 46, 2024 National Draft)
2 3 4
Replies
83
Views
9K
Happy Mastenator
Happy Mastenator
eaglespremiers
List Mgmt. Welcome Jobe Shanahan (Pick 30, 2024 National Draft)
2 3 4 5
Replies
106
Views
10K
eaglespremiers
eaglespremiers
Bleedblueandgold
List Mgmt. Welcome Bo Allan (Pick 16, 2024 National Draft)
5 6 7 8 9
Replies
208
Views
18K
Jukes
Jukes
eaglespremiers
List Mgmt. Welcome Clay Hall (Pick 38, 2023 National Draft)
5 6 7 8 9
Replies
223
Views
24K
bzparkes
bzparkes
A
List Mgmt. Welcome Harry Edwards (Pick 18, 2018 Rookie Draft)
Replies
6
Views
868
THE A5
THE A5

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top