Banter Who will be Better in 2025, Collingwood or Carlton? Part 4

[Fadge]

FYI and discuss:

Total games missed:
Richmond 261
Carlton 192
Collingwood 176
West Coast 167
Fremantle 162
GWS 159
Hawthorn 158
Brisbane 152
St Kilda 145
Essendon 142
North 134
Adelaide 133
Bulldogs 128
Sydney 126
Port 125
Geelong 122
Melbourne 118
GC 95

Only tells half the story, so games missed by best 22 players:
Richmond 171
Carlton 137
Brisbane 114
Adelaide 106
Hawthorn 102
Melbourne 97
Collingwood 93
St Kilda 90
West Coast 90
Bulldogs 86
North 73
Port 70
Essendon 66
Geelong 65
GWS 61
Fremantle 60
Gold Coast 56
Sydney 44

Wrong thread, nuffy?

Or are you so obsessed with trying to punch down on St. Kilda, that they are constantly sub consciously in your pickled brain?

 

[Arr0w]

And Heeney.
And Warner.

The list goes on.

And the statistics were shared to support it.

But you can have Walsh's 0.5 extra hard ball gets a game in exchange for his far inferior ball use and decision making.

As many hard ball gets as Bont and Petracca?

You should change your username to Falsify

 

[Fadge]

As many hard ball gets as Bont and Petracca?

You should change your username to Falsify

Yeah, sorry.

I should have realised a list with the actual statistics was beyond your analytical capability.

 

[Arr0w]

Yeah, sorry.

I should have realised a list with the actual statistics was beyond your analytical capability.

"As many hard ball gets as Bont and Petracca"

No wonder you have no credibility.

 

[Elixuh]

Only tells half the story, so games missed by best 22 players:
Richmond 171
Carlton 137
Brisbane 114
Adelaide 106
Hawthorn 102
Melbourne 97
Collingwood 93
St Kilda 90
West Coast 90
Bulldogs 86
North 73
Port 70
Essendon 66
Geelong 65
GWS 61
Fremantle 60
Gold Coast 56
Sydney 44

That 23 game difference between Carlton and Brisbane must have been the difference between winning a flag and going 0-60 in an elimination final.

 

[Fadge]

"As many hard ball gets as Bont and Petracca"

No wonder you have no credibility.

Tell me, which part of the table that I shared did you struggle to understand?

 

[Fadge]

That 23 game difference between Carlton and Brisbane must have been the difference between winning a flag and going 0-60 in an elimination final.

You also forget that Carlton have 33 players in their best 22 (which apparently includes Jack Silvagni).

 

[Arr0w]

Tell me, which part of the table that I shared did you struggle to understand?

You lie, falsify the truth, then blame others for your errors. Tad narcissistic fadge

 

[Fadge]

You lie, falsify the truth, then blame others for your errors. Tad narcissistic fadge

Your doubling down, calling me a liar, after I have previously shared a table of data to support my comment shows everyone how much of a gaslighter and liar you are yourself.

But please, do keep embarrassing yourself.

 

[King Tut]

And Heeney.
And Warner.

The list goes on.

And the statistics were shared to support it.

But you can have Walsh's 0.5 extra hard ball gets a game in exchange for his far inferior ball use and decision making.

Not to mention the occasional loose ball get from Daicos whilst Walsh is his direct opponent, that results in a match winning goal.

Post the video of it mate in case the Blue boys have forgotten. Watching a clueless Walsh look on with dim witted confusion and ineptitude as Nick seals the game for us never gets old

 

[Arr0w]

Your doubling down, calling me a liar, after I have previously shared a table of data to support my comment shows everyone how much of a gaslighter and liar you are yourself.

But please, do keep embarrassing yourself.

So you can prove, factual statistics that Nicky averaged as many hard ball gets as Bont and Petracca in 2024?

 

[Fadge]

Post the video of it mate in case the Blue boys have forgotten. Watching a clueless Walsh look on with dim witted confusion and ineptitude as Nick seals the game for us never gets old

But, but, but.... it was only a loose ball get!

 

[Fadge]

So you can prove, factual statistics that Nicky averaged as many hard ball gets as Bont and Petracca in 2024?

I have you dill, when I made the statement!

 

[Arr0w]

I have you dill, when I made the statement!

I'll take that as a no

Get help fudge

 

[King Tut]

But, but, but.... it was only a loose ball get!

Very loose. Walshthegoat wasn’t in the same postcode. Probably looking for a hard ball scrubbing kick or handball whereas our Nick saw the opportunity for a match sealing goal.

#levels

 

[WalshistheGOAT]

Are the Pies nuffies still pretending Nicky isn't the biggest pea hearted ball of fairy floss the games seen in years?

He's got champion data on the brink of rewriting the definition of 'contested possession' after gathering so many of them despite never actually cracking into a contest all season long

 

[Fadge]

I'll take that as a no

Get help fudge

In yet another example of your lack of comprehension and therefore misrepresentation of a post, I actually stated:
1. Daicos averaged more contested possessions than Bontempelli (amongst others), and
2. Daicos had similar hard ball gets as Petracca (amongst others).

Refer to post #5415.

 

[Arr0w]

In yet another example of your lack of comprehension and therefore misrepresentation of a post, I actually stated:
1. Daicos averaged more contested possessions than Bontempelli (amongst others), and
2. Daicos had similar hard ball gets as Petracca (amongst others).

Refer to post #5415.

"And then we're told that they're not 'hard ball gets', and then we highlight that he averages as many hard ball gets as the likes of Petracca, Heeney, Warner and Bontempelli.

And then they crawl back into their holes."

 

[Fadge]

How obsessed do these plebs continue to be with Daicos?

He's going to put them in an asylum after they have to watch him dominate the competition for the next decade!

 

[Corn Cobbers]

In yet another example of your lack of comprehension and therefore misrepresentation of a post, I actually stated:
1. Daicos averaged more contested possessions than Bontempelli (amongst others), and
2. Daicos had similar hard ball gets as Petracca (amongst others).

Refer to post #5415.

Crikey Fadge just as you said it

Someone needs help but not you

Another day, another own

On SM-A225F using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[WalshistheGOAT]

How obsessed do these plebs continue to be with Daicos?

He's going to put them in an asylum after they have to watch him dominate the competition for the next decade!

My dude u literally make a circle jerk thread on main board to celebrate his greatness with other Pies nuffs

You Kent's also spent a whole off season crying on social media about Charlie getting free kicks after he whooped Daisy's ass a few too many times.

But yes... We're the obsessed ones

 

[Arr0w]

Crikey Fadge just as you said it

Someone needs help but not you

Another day, another own

On SM-A225F using BigFooty.com mobile app

Oh my

 

[Corn Cobbers]

Oh my

Yes oh my, unless you can actually produce a post to back your accusation

Might be time for bed, put the bottle away

On SM-A225F using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[Go the Guts]

Only tells half the story, so games missed by best 22 players:
Richmond 171
Carlton 137
Brisbane 114
Adelaide 106
Hawthorn 102
Melbourne 97
Collingwood 93
St Kilda 90
West Coast 90
Bulldogs 86
North 73
Port 70
Essendon 66
Geelong 65
GWS 61
Fremantle 60
Gold Coast 56
Sydney 44

This is a crucial stat if teams such as Adelaide underperformed as badly as they did last year.
Amazing that Carlton and Brisbane did as well as they did with that many best 22 games missed.

 

[Arr0w]

My dude u literally make a circle jerk thread on main board to celebrate his greatness with other Pies nuffs

You Kent's also spent a whole off season crying on social media about Charlie getting free kicks after he whooped Daisy's ass a few too many times.

But yes... We're the obsessed ones

That thread is a bit of fun, despite the delusions, but to falsify facts, repeatedly, while trying demean the comprehension of others, that's another level of bizarre