Opinion Who wins the Premiership? (Updated poll - Updated for Prelims))

[Scotland]

What did Chapman do?

Got suspended in the 2013 semi vs Port where he kicked 4. Geelong lost the prelim to Hawthorn the next week by 5 points.

 

[Jhye Clark 13]

You mean the first batch of games we played at the beginning of the restart where we were out of form playing on wet/ dewy grounds. Wet is our kryptonite.

be interesting to see how we go in the next hub played all at night.

Any cane toads able to tell us if the nights are wet at that time of year?

So excuses?

You’re so full of sh*t. You’ve got a couple of nuffie Cats mates in your corner but the overwhelming majority are staying away. You don’t happen to be that clown that got 2008 tattooed on his arm?

More rubbish. I simply said West Coast won't beat Geelong, Richmond, Brisbane or Port at the AO or the GABBA if finals were played there. The MCG is irrelant, what happened to Collingwood in the past is irrelevant as well as anything else you've conjured in response. You've gone off on a tangent.

Where the hell will you be when you choke in a final again?

You hope.

 

[demondavey]

Feel like this is the best the Cats have played. Reckon they’ll go really close to it.

 

[demondavey]

So excuses?

More rubbish.


You hope.

Why set yourself up to get ridiculed?

 

[Jhye Clark 13]

Why set yourself up to get ridiculed?

You might care what people think on an internet forum but not me.

 

[Port Adel Proud]

Easy answer to question posed by OP: Geelong as is usual.

 

[demondavey]

So excuses?

More rubbish. I simply said West Coast won't beat Geelong, Richmond, Brisbane or Port at the AO or the GABBA if finals were played there. The MCG is irrelant, what happened to Collingwood in the past is irrelevant as well as anything else you've conjured in response. You've gone off on a tangent.


You hope.

But you don’t know that mate. You can’t say with conviction that they won’t. That’s why you’re sounding like a nuffie. You’re coming out with statements of conviction saying it won’t happen when it may. It’s a bit different from saying the sun will rise tomorrow, bloody bank on it.

 

[Jhye Clark 13]

But you don’t know that mate. You can’t say with conviction that they won’t. That’s why you’re sounding like a nuffie. You’re coming out with statements of conviction saying it won’t happen when it may. It’s a bit different from saying the sun will rise tomorrow, bloody bank on it.

It's my opinion. I said the same thing last year ... West Coast won't beat Geelong in a final at the MCG. That too had people in a spin. In fact there were pages upon pages of responses just like this.

Good luck with your prayers. Now bye.

 

[kranky al]

So excuses?

More rubbish. I simply said West Coast won't beat Geelong, Richmond, Brisbane or Port at the AO or the GABBA if finals were played there. The MCG is irrelant, what happened to Collingwood in the past is irrelevant as well as anything else you've conjured in response. You've gone off on a tangent.


You hope.

You might wanna have a look at west coasts record on adelaide oval.....

 

[Duskfire]

This happens most seasons. There are periods where Geelong look like a million bucks. Unfortunately, it all falls apart come finals team. I do think though that they have a very good chance this year due to the crazy nature of it. Avoiding MCG weirdly enough might be a benefit.

 

[demondavey]

It's my opinion. I said the same thing last year ... West Coast won't beat Geelong in a final at the MCG. That too had people in a spin. In fact there were pages upon pages of responses just like this.

Good luck with your prayers. Now bye.

So your opinion is founded on something you’re ‘sure of’ yet you have no possible way of attaching conviction to it?

I forgot how many raving lunatics frequented this place.

 

[Jhye Clark 13]

You might wanna have a look at west coasts record on adelaide oval.....

I've got no interest in the looking back further than this year in regards to West Coast results. This is the present. If you're hanging your hat on previous wins against Adelaide or Port then good luck to you.

 

[The Final Word]

Feel like this is the best the Cats have played. Reckon they’ll go really close to it.

I know it's better to win late in the season but we were 11-1 and knocked off the Tigers, who were undermanned, by 11 goals at the MCG last year. That was pretty decent form.

 

[Duskfire]

At this moment. Not in any particular order. I would think between Brisbane, Richmond, Geelong, WCE.

Then depending on where the GF is played. Home ground advantage would have a bearing, because of how much time being away from home. Brisbane seem to be looking good.

BUT> nothing would surprise who actually wins. Been a weird year so far, based on this Port, Saints> maybe?

I am becoming less confident about Brisbane. They just aren’t playing very well at the moment. I think their forward line is their Achilles heel; except for Cameron they aren’t good at fighting dirty and scrapping, so if they come up against a defensive team they struggle to score.

I don’t know, maybe I am wrong. If Geelong can’t win it I would like to see them doing so. It is just hard to see them beating the likes of Richmond in a cut throat final.

 

[Coolangatta]

Geelong/Richmond grand final at the GABBA would be pretty epic. I'm not convinced about West Coast there, but maybe that's because the last two times they've been thumped there by Brisbane it's been early in the season. I guess we'll see how they fair there against the Saints and Bombers.

 

[The Final Word]

You mean the first batch of games we played at the beginning of the restart where we were out of form playing on wet/ dewy grounds. Wet is our kryptonite.

be interesting to see how we go in the next hub played all at night.

Any cane toads able to tell us if the nights are wet at that time of year?

Wetter in Oct and Nov than any of Apr - Sep

 

[kranky al]

Wetter in Oct and Nov than any of Apr - Sep

Reckon we are fkxd then

Nice of the afl to give us wall to wall night games

 

[Footy_Fan2007]

Im still expecting the Tigers to hit their straps when players come back. They cannot be underestimated.
Richmond had a slump last year then went bang.
We were looking good last year and look what happened.

 

[bzparkes]

I've got no interest in the looking back further than this year in regards to West Coast results. This is the present. If you're hanging your hat on previous wins against Adelaide or Port then good luck to you.

You have no interest in facts and reality?

Whatever floats your boat I guess.

 

[WillHayward]

Geelong look invincible every year.

Until about round 18.

 

[Jhye Clark 13]

You have no interest in facts and reality?

Whatever floats your boat I guess.

I do. The facts are you were bottom 4 until you went back home.

 

[Jimmy Yamazaki]

A full Strength Tigers are still the team to beat.

 

[WillHayward]

A full Strength Tigers are still the team to beat.

Annoying but probably true.

 

[bzparkes]

I do. The facts are you were bottom 4 until you went back home.

Cool.

Didn't you guys get pumped by a woeful Collingwood?

Very inconsistent form there.

Lost to Giants - they are rubbish.

Lost to Carlton - Lol.

Struggled against Melbourne when they were shit.

Beat a Freo that can't score and and have good form the last 3 rounds.

Rollercoaster season for the Cats and nothing to indicate so far that they are a genuine threat, especially considering their finals record since 2011.

 

[kranky al]

I've got no interest in the looking back further than this year in regards to West Coast results. This is the present. If you're hanging your hat on previous wins against Adelaide or Port then good luck to you.

“I also have no interest in looking at anythjng bar things that support my assertions.”

do you support trump too?

- a dickhead trump supporter