MRP / Trib. Tribunal Thread - rules and offences discombobulation

[1954]

This sounds a bit oxymoronic...

GWS player Xavier O'Halloran was the only other player to receive a charge from the MRO for Saturday's action, with a $1000 fine able to be accepted with an early plea for engaging in a melee during the second quarter of Saturday's win over Sydney.

A melee with himself? Or were the other players not quite as engaged as O'Halloran??

The relatives on the green side of my family would have suggested that because of his name he was more harshly treated.

The orange men on the other side would have said that for someone who must obviously be a thug the penalty was way too light.

 

[Ford Fairlane]

This is right up there with 'Adelaide Metro apologises for the inconvenience' for infuriatingly useless announcements.

 

[OneGreatClub]

This is right up there with 'Adelaide Metro apologises for the inconvenience' for infuriatingly useless announcements.

I’m still waiting for the apologies to Port

 

[DaTBird187]

Bwahahaha

 

[RossFC]

Port’s Nick Moore has been offered a $125 fine and reprimand with an early guilty plea for engaging in rough conduct with Norwood’s Jacob Kennerley at Alberton Oval on Saturday.

Nick Moore (Port) – Rough Conduct (Dangerous Tackle)
Conduct: Careless
Contact: High
Impact: Low
Base Sanction: 1 match
Early Guilty Plea: $125 fine and reprimand

 

[PowerBaz]

So what are we waiting for with the Rioli charge? Arew they gathering all the evidence?

 

[Alberton Proud]

So what are we waiting for with the Rioli charge? Arew they gathering all the evidence?

I think that's the issue

Other than a supposed concussion, there's really not much that actually shows a 'hit' to the head

 

[malcheski]

So what are we waiting for with the Rioli charge? Arew they gathering all the evidence?

Waiting for the autopsy before deciding between the chair or the gallows.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

[dav3]

So what are we waiting for with the Rioli charge? Arew they gathering all the evidence?

They only announced the charges from Saturdays games a few hours ago, I assume all the Sunday ones will be tomorrow

 

[PrisonBars4life]

They only announced the charges from Saturdays games a few hours ago, I assume all the Sunday ones will be tomorrow

Unlikely - They'd need to allow enough time for a tribunal hearing and appeal. Can't be doing them Wednesday and Thursday on a day's notice.

 

[Sir Watchalot]

They only announced the charges from Saturdays games a few hours ago, I assume all the Sunday ones will be tomorrow

They usually have all the charges laid when the Monday evening footy shows start.

 

[The Hobo]

Port’s Nick Moore has been offered a $125 fine and reprimand with an early guilty plea for engaging in rough conduct with Norwood’s Jacob Kennerley at Alberton Oval on Saturday.

Nick Moore (Port) – Rough Conduct (Dangerous Tackle)
Conduct: Careless
Contact: High
Impact: Low
Base Sanction: 1 match
Early Guilty Plea: $125 fine and reprimand

Another classic example of umpire not blowing the whistle fast enough?

 

[The Hobo]

Conrad with his 3rd umpire contact for the season.. 7 rounds in...

 

[Adz2332]

Rioli straight to the tribunal meaning a minimum of 3

 

[Waspy79]

No surprise Junior sent to tribunal when what he did was no worse than Buddys snipe

 

[JimmyBC]

Port Tax goes boom

 

[ClintEastwood]

Arew they fabricating all the evidence?

FTFY.

 

[Ford Fairlane]

Not even the Reserve Bank has interest rates like ours.

 

[Festerz]

Add to that is that fact that Junior has been racially abused on social media forcing Port to issue a statement.

 

[Ant Bear]

Conrad with his 3rd umpire contact for the season.. 7 rounds in...

Port gun Connor Rozee can accept a $2,500 fine with an early plea for making careless contact with an umpire.

Meanwhile, at Geelong...no fine for Jeremy Cameron steamrollering an umpire.

 

[PowerBaz]

So is impact based on impact or outcome?

This was ‘high’ not severe…

 

[Mr Experience]

• Rioli attempts a block
• Rioli misses but his trailing hand possibly makes contact with Ridley's head, difficult to tell as Ridley doesn't initially react
• Ridley then throws his hands up in the air, perhaps attempting to draw the attention of an umpire to pay a free kick
• Ridley falls and, for some reason, fails to put his hands out to protect himself enough to prevent his head from hitting the turf

 

[The Hobo]

• Rioli attempts a block
• Rioli misses but his trailing hand possibly makes contact with Ridley's head, difficult to tell as Ridley doesn't initially react
• Ridley then throws his hands up in the air, perhaps attempting to draw the attention of an umpire to pay a free kick
• Ridley falls and, for some reason, fails to put his hands out to protect himself enough to prevent his head from hitting the turf

 

[Ported]

The insane thing is, if Rioli's arm had contacted him in the neck or something, I can't see him even recieving a fine. I guess it's port though, so probably.

The AFL's won't stamp out actions over outcomes until their policies are used as evidence in CTE litigation

 

[It Just Is]

The insane thing is, if Rioli's arm had contacted him in the neck or something, I can't see him even recieving a fine. I guess it's port though, so probably.

The AFL's won't stamp out actions over outcomes until their policies are used as evidence in CTE litigation

Except for tackles where on occasion it is action not outcome based. Chooklotto.