Search results for query: *

Castagna is a headless chook but is insanely damaging in that set up. Not sure how he would go in another team. I don't think he has the necessary skill to make it here but we definitely lack acceleration and speed across the board. Good luck finding expendale players for reasonable currency...

Yeah certainly lost some minutes to him. When he returned from injury had a cracking game then did his hammy. Think the rotation is still there for him but got shifted at the time because of his flexibility..

Not sure what was up with him this season. Started well and then something changed dramatically. Very very good SF when fit even with the Duckwood academy graduation certificate. Can't see the dogs letting him walk though, they need more classy small forwards not less. Not sure what they will...

Absolute elite talent, wanted him for years but he looks well and truly cooked and aside from the injuries the obvious worry is culturally. The guy has had some serious issues so you have to ask yourself... Would he be a positive influence on the group? Especially the kids etc. I trust the...

Not sure if their will ever be a team that skilful again due to equilisation. GWS have the list but they turned Into battlers in September and it largely served them well. Maybe If they were fully fit with a full list but I'm not sure the Ferari is in working order anymore. Which leaves us...

But how do you tackle the tiger problem? 1) out skill them? 2) beat them at their own game? 3) other (either revolutionary or existing tactic)?

Josh if you and others can perfectly understand what I was saying so can 'they'. They are choosing to act this way. Trying to reason with them is like trying to have an intelegant conversation with a trump supporter. Not hard to imagine why he comes to mind. Make Hawthorn great again? As a...

Few other teams could improve as well... Bears, WC, Pies, Giants etc but on this years form it's wide open other than the tiges.

Outside Richmond it's a bang average league at the moment and even they are only an B+ to A- side (discounting future natural improvement) Their game plan is just perfectly built to capitalise on an era of non elite skill. They are built on a Klopp model and our 3 peat team was built on a Pep...

No one needs that level of Eric Bana 😆

Was there are a half price sale on straws champ? Thank god you interjected though, he would be lost without you. I even detected a smidgen of humour in his last response, I can see why you like him.

How are you a moderator? Is arrogance, and deflection a prerequisite?

I actually thought he was a better leader than player, in a lead by example kind of way. Except for those few early years at WC where he was a rediculous athlete. Fyfe has a much more well rounded game.

It's not silly. but it is close minded to not think about the bigger picture and scoff at those who do just because you have a different opinion. That's why I asked questions... It's better to ask people to think than it is to tell them how to think. He is a great player and there would be no...

Absolutely, the person asking reasonable questions and being made fun of is the troll. Time to bring out the pitch forks!

Nice one, another condescending attitude with zero substance. I thought Hawthorn supporters looked at the bigger picture.

Abassi why do you view Fyfe as so important to Fremantle? Do you think he is crucial to their success? Do you think he will be a part of their success? Judd had better leadership skills and West Coast won that trade by a landslide even without fully utilising pick three.

Acting prick cost Hodgey Roughs 250th. No thanks, can play but makes my skin crawl.

That carlton bloke is from WA, welcome to Hawthorn Patrick Cripps 😆😆😆

Talk about a team that should be pushing for picks 1 & 2 +. They are trending backwards and have a premium asset that isn't gonna be in their first premiership. Said it last year and was mocked but believe it firmly. Freo should be bold and set up their club for the future. Fyfe is worth way...

Kelly > Conigs Whitfield > Conigs Kelly is sublime, shame he keeps getting Injured. Whitfield Has potentially a higher ceiling and suits us more because we need directness and speed. Conigs is solid but more of what we have and far less special than the other two. What about Hopper, he and...

Pick 10 for Gaff could go either way. Gun mid for 2-5 years or 1 bad injury and a solid 3 Year player at best. Our strategy probably means if their is no Lachie type option it would be worth a punt. Best case scenario is we do well and create excitement to lure players like Lachie here next year.

Can we just knock off the 50% Selwood part and add an extra 50% Hodge?

Sorry other people were, i read posts backwards so I must have confused myself with that worry lingering in my mind.

I have absolutely no issue with the quantifiable value of a CHB but I would be worried about using a high end pick on drafting one with a view to short term success. Big fellas take longer to hit their straps, if we go to the draft but need our selections to impact in the next two to three...

Is anyone else worried the Patton deal was/is tied to the Scully deal?

Not sure what good could come from this

So acquiring the future 3rd gives us the ability to trade next years first again!!! What you got cooking GW???

Hard to believe if no more to it, so I’d wait and see. Would be completely ignoring ports considerably weakened bargaining position, that they even acknowledged themselves!

Flog face cornes just totally soft cocked asking big Gil about the Scully/hawks deal.. What an absolute pretender