2008 Official BigFooty Phantom Draft

Remove this Banner Ad

Here's my write up for Pick 38, Sam Wright

Wright is an elusive sort of player with plenty of versatility. Physically he bears a striking resemblence to Dale Thomas, and his style of game isn't too different, though I'd say that Wright has more of an inside game as well as a good outside game.

At 188cm he's got a good height for the sort of player he is. Early in his TAC Cup career he was pigeon holed as a small/medium forward for the Bushrangers. Around the half way point of this year they moved him up the ground a bit, where he played in the midfield and across the half back line. He rebounded well when played back and he was pretty handy in the clearances when was in the guts. He was usually able to bob up for a goal as well, and only went 6 games (out of 21) this TAC Cup season without scoring a goal.

His kicking is a bit inconsistent. His best kicks are really good, but he doesn't hit them sweetly often enough for my liking. I know that can be said for a lot of players, but I think it's particularly prominent with Wright. What is really important to note is that he improved his efficiency quite a lot as the season went on and also started looking a lot more fluent on his non preferred side. I'm always really encouraged by a player who can improve consistency in their disposal. His kicking for goal from set shots still concerns me, but he's got good goal sense in general play.

He's a pretty opportunistic type of player, which is complemented really well by his good ground skills. He's quite clean below his knees. Wright is also a good reader of the play, so if he can't be in a marking contests he's great at getting front and centre to a contest to crumb a goal, or at least keep the ball in the forward line.

His overhead skills for his size are excellent and I consider this to be one of his greatest strengths. He's a tough player to match up on, because he's equally adept in the air and on the ground, so it takes a very specific sort of player to match him in both of those aspects.

I like his work ethic too. He runs hard to receive and he keeps this up all game, so I'd suggest he'd at least have decent endurance. His speed and agility also look fine to me. I'd obviously be keen to see how he tests, but I reckon that would only confirm that he's a good all round athlete.
 
Give me a sec for my next pick. Obviously I've been spending the last hour or so in a Sam Wright state of mind and I've got a few in contention for this pick.
 
Pick 77 - Tom Gillies - KP Defender

You won't find a Youtube clip of Tom Gillies. I'm just guessing to be honest, because I haven't searched for one, but my point is that he's a no nonsense, dour defender. Not exactly highlight reel material, but an important player none the less.

Gillies is your typical, old school key back. He has good awareness of his opponent (good touch and feel) and does all the disciplined things you'd want to see from a defender.

He is a neat kick of the ball, not damaging, just neat. He's not going to be the sort of player to turn it over often at all, but it's unlikely he'll be spotting up a guy 60m in the clear out the back of a pack.

He's got good commitment to the contest and body lines the ball, so he's not afraid to put his head over it. When it's his turn to go for the ball he'll have no hesitation in running a straight line towards it, no matter who's in the way. He's got a strong body and good tackling technique.

I like his balance, which is very important for a key defender and I didn't see him get beaten too often. He was named Dandenong's BOG in the Grand Final and was one of very few Stingrays who could hold his head high after that game.

For a bloke of his size, he's bloody quick - once again something that's very important for key defenders, especially these days. He ran a 2.94 at Victorian State Screening and he also took out the Stingrays Best & Fairest award this year.

I know Port have a few unfashionable, reliable defenders in their back line, but at this stage of the draft you're looking for a diamond in the rough and I reckon Gillies has the potential to be this player. He's strong, quick, reliable and disciplined. I see him playing the sort of role that Ben Rutten and Dale Morris get praise for from people who can appreciate the work of a classic defender.
 

Log in to remove this ad.

Pause draft!

I just read that Nathan Carroll got delisted today and that Melbourne will now take seven picks in the ND. I've sent a PM to McLean_4_Captain. Hopefully he didn't want Bennell or Gillies. If so, we might have to go back and re-do the last couple of picks.

Did anyone else get delisted at second list lodgement?
 
As expected Shane Crawford's name does not appear on the updated Hawthorn playing list after he announced his surprise retirement last week, but also delisted were Leigh Brown of the Kangaroos, Demon Nathan Carroll and young Saint Brad Howard.
 
Nice pick up Ysaye. Jamie grew on me as the year went on and he started stringing some really good matches together at the end of the year. He's been playing SWFL league for the past 2 years as well. Likes to fly for anything if it's in his area, I imagine he would have been great at king of the pack at school.:D Good attacking HBF who will move through the middle of the ground as he develops I reckon.
 
As expected Shane Crawford's name does not appear on the updated Hawthorn playing list after he announced his surprise retirement last week, but also delisted were Leigh Brown of the Kangaroos, Demon Nathan Carroll and young Saint Brad Howard.
Thanks sinepari and GTD regarding this.

Luckily St.Kilda haven't missed a turn yet, so we can easily just slot Bourky23 into this round.

I thought Leigh Brown got delisted at List Lodgement 1 though.

Also, do the Hawks get an extra pick for Crawf given that he was on the Veterans List? I'm not too sure how that all works.
 
Thanks sinepari and GTD regarding this.

Luckily St.Kilda haven't missed a turn yet, so we can easily just slot Bourky23 into this round.

I thought Leigh Brown got delisted at List Lodgement 1 though.

Also, do the Hawks get an extra pick for Crawf given that he was on the Veterans List? I'm not too sure how that all works.
Crawford was outside the list so they don't get an extra pick.
 
The only changes you have to make is add Melbourne into selection 76, with everyone after them pushing back. StKilda into selection 83, with Port pushing back to 84 and Carlton to 85. Hawthorn and North do not have any more picks.

71. Nth Melbourne
72. Adelaide
73. Collingwood
74. St Kilda
75. Hawthorn

Round 6
76. Melbourne
77. Fremantle
78. Port Adelaide
79. Essendon
80. Carlton
81. Brisbane Lions
82. Brisbane Lions
83. St Kilda

Round 7
84. Port Adelaide
85. Carlton

http://www.afl.com.au/News/NEWSARTICLE/tabid/208/Default.aspx?newsId=69793
 
you are good foj1 - you didnt even have him in your mock. I had him around 50 in mine and he was right in the slot for my last

He could go anywhere after the second round I reckon. Has a heap of talent, I only completed 4 rounds of the mock and would have slotted him a bit later. I actually think he will go a bit earlier now.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Yeh he is eligible to be rookied.

In fact, he could have been taken as a bottom-ager last year.
:thumbsu:

I assumed he was bottom age. :eek:

The other club's can blame Melbourne's dodgy work in delisting the contracted Carroll if they had Gillies or another player targeted for a late pick. :thumbsdown:

Carlton will use pick 85 in the PSD on Johnson.
 
:thumbsu:

I assumed he was bottom age. :eek:

The other club's can blame Melbourne's dodgy work in delisting the contracted Carroll if they had Gillies or another player targeted for a late pick. :thumbsdown:

Carlton will use pick 85 in the PSD on Johnson.

They sure will. As long as Johnson gets past Essendon, although there is some speculation that Essendon may re-draft Hislop in the PSD.
 
Not sure whos pick it is. Essendon I suspect would pass their last pick while I would be inclined to take it as there are a few player left that are bottom aged who I would certainly draft.
Are we awaiting Melbourne's pick?
 
Not sure whos pick it is. Essendon I suspect would pass their last pick while I would be inclined to take it as there are a few player left that are bottom aged who I would certainly draft.
Are we awaiting Melbourne's pick?
Yeah, since Melbourne delisted Carroll they should have one extra pick and I've notified McLean_4_Captain, but he hasn't been online for a couple of days. We'll probably have to give his pick to someone else I guess.

As for Essendon's last pick, once we get Melbourne out of the way you might as well use it even though they might pass.
 
Yeah, since Melbourne delisted Carroll they should have one extra pick and I've notified McLean_4_Captain, but he hasn't been online for a couple of days. We'll probably have to give his pick to someone else I guess.

As for Essendon's last pick, once we get Melbourne out of the way you might as well use it even though they might pass.

Seeing as though we have a bit of time to complete it, could we not give him another 24 hours for him to come back online? Seeing as though he has already missed one selection along the way, it would be nice for him to get his final selection.
 
Well VC asked me to take the pick, and because I was on my way out, I pm'd it to him.

However, given that he hasn't posted it, I am happy to wait for Mclean to come online.
 
I ended up asking two people to take the pick. First I asked macca69 because he was the first I noticed to be online at the time. Then after I sent the PM I noticed he'd gone offline, so I quickly asked sinepari (who was also online at the time).

I guess we can wait for M4C until tomorrow morning. Maybe he'd gone away for the weekend or something. It's also understandable that he wouldn't realise he has another pick. If he doesn't show then basically the two players suggested were Matthew Martin (macca69) and Tom Gillies (sinepari). I've got no problem with taking my pick again since I took Gillies out of turn (even though I didn't know it was out of turn at the time ;)).

We'll wait until tomorrow morning to see if M4C shows and if not we'll give Melbourne one of those players.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

2008 Official BigFooty Phantom Draft

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top