List Mgmt. 2015 Draft, Trades and Retirements Thread Pt 1

[ponsdale]

Would clubs spend a first round pick on a small lockdown defender though? That's basically my argument.

He's worth a lot more to us than he would for an opposing side.

I agree that he's worth a lot more to us.

But I do think a lot of clubs would trade a first round pick (and a high one at that) for Smith. Easy.

 

[Ticky009]

I agree that he's worth a lot more to us.

But I do think a lot of clubs would trade a first round pick (and a high one at that) for Smith. Easy.

There will be no trading of Smooch...if that happens I will be having a tanty of epic proportions.

 

[Swansujelly]

There will be no trading of Smooch...if that happens I will be having a tanty of epic proportions.

and I shall join you.

 

[The King!]

So now Heeney would of cost us pick 18 37 38 and 57 with the new rules in last years draft

 

[Swansujelly]

So now Heeney would of cost us pick 18 37 38 and 57 with the new rules in last years draft

way too much for 1 player. I know eddie can't see that, what with the chins in the way, but surely somebody with some sense would.

 

[The King!]

way too much for 1 player. I know eddie can't see that, what with the chins in the way, but surely somebody with some sense would.

And as if teams wont just bid now and play ducks and drakes

 

[Greg Ryan]

So now Heeney would of cost us pick 18 37 38 and 57 with the new rules in last years draft[/QUOTE]

A hypothetical.

We secure pick 1 in the trade period. We use pick 1 to secure Mills.

Do we still get the 20% discount (600 points) to push up another draft pick or get an additional draft pick?

- 600 points would give us pick 31 if we wanted another pick.

- If we had a predicted pick 17 we could use the 600 points to move that pick 17 up to pick 8.

Is this how it would work if we used our own picks to bid for an Academy or Father / Son prospect?

 

[Heeney2Franklin]

So you look at it this way would you give up pick 18,37,38,57 for pick 2?

 

[The King!]

How did we get pick 1 is the problem with that scenario

 

[Heeney2Franklin]

How did we get pick 1 is the problem with that scenario

I think i have a idea..

Hanners and Smith for pick 1 (no thanks)

I rather we give up picks in 2016 if it came to that, trading out Hanners and Smith will cripple our flag window.

 

[Greg Ryan]

How did we get pick 1 is the problem with that scenario

Hannenbery.

 

[The King!]

If its the suns or carlton they probably would be better keeping pick 1

 

[Greg Ryan]

If its the suns or carlton they probably would be better keeping pick 1

It would only be a Victorian club in this scenario. Hanners won't go to the Lions or GCS. Maybe Carlton or Melbourne though.

 

[Heeney2Franklin]

I think it's fairer than the proposed system back in January.

 

[The King!]

Its a load of shit, just means you have to risk all your picks that some kid the media (driven by flogs like eddie) beat up and pay almost 2 mill a year for the privilege

 

[Heeney2Franklin]

Its a load of shit, just means you have to risk all your picks that some kid the media (driven by flogs like eddie) beat up and pay almost 2 mill a year for the privilege

Yer but did you expect anything else?

 

[Greg Ryan]

I think it's fairer than the proposed system back in January.

I would have preferred it to be a 20% discount for father and sons and 25% for Academy selections.

 

[The King!]

Yer but did you expect anything else?

Not at all but still think its stupid

Bend over sydney and take it should be the title of the report

 

[FreeAgent1]

Did anyone else notice this part of the article:

"Dunkley, who plays for the Gippsland Power in country Victoria, is considering his options and is no certainty to nominate as a future Swan"

Does anyone know a reason why he wouldnt want to??

 

[Lakeside Swan]

Might wander down to my old stomping ground in Box Hill next week and have a squiz at young Jackson Kelly.

I was there this morning for a seminar. Who is Jackson playing for?

 

[Troystenvic]

Sick and Fuc$king tired over being bent over by the AFL and Co for playing by the rules. They might as well fold us and Share our players between Collingwood and Hawthorn

 

[Heeney2Franklin]

Not at all but still think its stupid

Bend over sydney and take it should be the title of the report

I think we will only have a issue if both players are bid on inside the top 10.

Harley made a statement a few mins ago sounds reasonably happy especially with the sliding fixed discount of points.

It is what it is man and i think we are in a superb position if we manage to get Mills and Dunkely regardless what it costs.

 

[Heeney2Franklin]

Folks who are unhappy answer my question would you do the following trade

In : Pick 2 (Heeney)

Out : 18,37,38,57

If you said yes well its the exact same thing.

 

[The King!]

Folks who are unhappy answer my question would you do the following trade

In : Pick 2 (Heeney)

Out : 18,37,38,57

If you said yes well its the exact same thing.

We shouldnt have too imo

 

[Lakeside Swan]

Bird for Schoenmakers? lol

We'd be losing out in that trade.