That or trade them both out, get Tomlinson, Plowman, Sumner etc...but swap picks 20 and 21 for pick 8. We have picks 1, & 8 to use in the draft, Picks 59 & 60 for SOSOS plus the raft of GWS players.
-
AFLW 2024 - Round 10 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
List Mgmt. 2015 LIST Discussion - trades, free agency etc
- Thread starter HARKER
- Start date
- Tagged users None
- Status
That or trade them both out, get Tomlinson, Plowman, Sumner etc...but swap picks 20 and 21 for pick 8. We have picks 1, & 8 to use in the draft, Picks 59 & 60 for SOSOS plus the raft of GWS players.
The Old Dark Navy's
Moderator
- Moderator
- #17,252
GWS won't need the points. 8 will be a live pick for them. Hopper will be covered by 7, 8 live and then they will cover Kennedy with the pick we give them for Plowman and co, and their own 27.
A good try...lol.
- May 1, 2002
- 12,051
- 20,446
- AFL Club
- Carlton
Port winners. Crows even. Collingwood lose...yeah! and Melbourne - well it's official, they are worse than us at this!
Yes, very much this. That trade would have looked so much better if we went the above scenario.
While we all think no clubs will bid on Jack, at least not high, reality is it is still possible a club will bid on him especially given it is a shallow draft, so, I'd be staggered if Carlton didn't retain one of 20 or 21 in case we need to use it to secure Jack. Another club could do it to keep us honest.
But that shouldn't be a problem assuming Richmond get their shit together and we get a decent pick for Yarran. Then we still have three other decent picks to leverage in any trade.
But that shouldn't be a problem assuming Richmond get their shit together and we get a decent pick for Yarran. Then we still have three other decent picks to leverage in any trade.
Given Brisbane's firm stance now that Aish will only be traded for a 1st rounder & Collingwood committing both theirs to the Treloar deal I'm thinking it's starting to become more likely Aish ends up in the PSD.
i think we are doing well so far. picks 1, 20, 21, 59, 60, 77 plus first rounder 2016
will get plowman sumner lamb & phillips & possibly kerridge.
draft weitering & SOSOS plus 4-5 more kids
still to organise yarran pick which may be 12 & 30 for yarran & 21. 30 for the gws players.
could next years henderson pick get us tomlinson or swap for gws 2nd & 3rd this year as they have to trim list?
and hopefully SOS has one or two more surprise deals to sneak through and a gun through psd.
will get plowman sumner lamb & phillips & possibly kerridge.
draft weitering & SOSOS plus 4-5 more kids
still to organise yarran pick which may be 12 & 30 for yarran & 21. 30 for the gws players.
could next years henderson pick get us tomlinson or swap for gws 2nd & 3rd this year as they have to trim list?
and hopefully SOS has one or two more surprise deals to sneak through and a gun through psd.
- Oct 4, 2015
- 13,168
- 24,807
- AFL Club
- Carlton
Why the hell would we do that?
Forget pick #8 this year, I'd definitely rather hang onto the first rounders for next year's draft. If we end up with 3, we can pick up 3 gun midfielders to go with Cripps, we could turn our fortunes around in one draft.
- Oct 4, 2015
- 13,168
- 24,807
- AFL Club
- Carlton
I'd prefer if we got pick #12 for Yarran and offered #20 + #21 for Tomlinson and co.
Blue and Silver
Brownlow Medallist
Kerridge is out of contract. I think Adelaide will let him walk if he agrees to our deal.
By which I mean we will trade him for next years third round
By which I mean we will trade him for next years third round
be okay with that. reading some of the phantom drafts we could get a curnow or burton at 12 which i think we need. a pick 20 or 21 could be a collins mckay mathieson dunkley clarke or oliver. all look like good players
TheCoach16
Brownlow Medallist
- Sep 16, 2015
- 17,135
- 44,418
- AFL Club
- Carlton
- Banned
- #17,267
Yes ! Do that ! ... 5 quality young kids plus pick 1 and 8... We'd be the biggest winners of the draft period... Do it!
just reading some of the phantom drafts. at the end of the trade & draft period we could end up with plowman sumner phillips lamb kerridge weitering curnow collins mckay sosos rioli and maybe 1 or 2 more and an extra first ropund pick next year. that's around 12 new players. big effort. add these guys to cripps graham buckley docherty boekhurst byrne and we have some good young talent. good start to a rebuild i reckon
- Thread starter
- #17,270
Toumpas seems broken to me. Watched him play VFL and I couldn't help seeing Kane Lucas in him.....I hope that changes though.
Kennedy should be a good player at Melbourne but because Collingwood seem to have let him go cheap.......there may be something there.
Melbourne huge losers
Collingwood lose big as well, Howe isn't that good and they haven't got anything to trade for Aish now.
Crows pretty fair
Port the big win I reckon.
It's a losing affair really
Collingwood lose big as well, Howe isn't that good and they haven't got anything to trade for Aish now.
Crows pretty fair
Port the big win I reckon.
It's a losing affair really
Not sure who wins it either. But Melbourne originaly invested pick 4 in Toumpas and could have got pick 6 for Howe if they traded him this time last year.
I'd say the Pies win as they only lose two players that were not in there best 22, for one player who most likely will be.
Crows look like they are trying to bring in some run, with Seedsman and Hampton.
The Old Dark Navy's
Moderator
- Moderator
- #17,273
Pies have their second rounder and the second rounder they will probably get for Freeman.
However if the Saints have to spend their second rounder to get Carlisle done, then they miss Freeman, Pies miss Aish and the PSD probably has some choices in it.
Magruder
Brownlow Medallist
- Nov 14, 2012
- 12,420
- 20,444
- AFL Club
- Carlton
Agree on Menz, not on pick 1. Just doesn't feel right unless Dogs cover a chunk of Boyd's contract.
Well thought out though.
- Status
