List Mgmt. 2016 Trade/Free Agency Part 4 - Toby Nankervis asks for trade to Richmond

[poppa pump]

Is the guy who went for a wank back, if so now we know how long u last.

Motlop to melb, ,motlop pick to tigers, lids to cats.

 

[prodigy]

Giving up pick 6 for Prestia tells me that we're desperate to remain semi-relevant now, maybe get a few top 8 finishes, rather than aiming for real success in the future. We NEED that pick 6 and we need to use it wisely.

I feel like we're sticking with the ol' Dan Richardson mentality by trading it.

Everyone has been telling me that Balme is the saviour, but if he signs off on us using pick 6 without plans of trading back into the top 5 then what good is he compared to what we have previously been dealing with.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

[Tigez 4 Life]

People are losing their shit in here tonight.... Calm your farm guys

If everyone was calm then there would be no entertainment...

 

[Alfar]

Giving up pick 6 for Prestia tells me that we're desperate to remain semi-relevant now, maybe get a few top 8 finishes, rather than aiming for real success in the future. We NEED that pick 6 and we need to use it wisely.

I feel like we're sticking with the ol' Dan Richardson mentality by trading it.

Exactly. It's the best pick we've seen in years and I'll back the boys to climb back up that ladder a little bit meaning our future first rounders won't be as good as pick 6. If pick 6 isn't part of some super secret mega trade then we need to take it to the draft and get some star youth into our club. Yes I'm aware of our history with conca but you'd hope we learned from that mistake and won't make it again.

 

[Mr Unbelievable]

I feel like we will under achieve again this year.

Sent from my SM-G935F using Tapatalk

We already did

 

[tigercam]

So this is us being aggressive?
Lol
Richmond cop it up the arse, doodah doodah

I hate to admit that i had a bit of a chuckle at this.

 

[Tiger_4_Life]

who is ******* losing their shit ya ******* moron ******** fat useless ******** campaigner

Hey I may be fat, and I may be a useless campaigner but..... What was the other one you said?

 

[joelsyt]

Perfect time of year to organise your ignore list this thread makes it very easy for a sneaky little tidy up

The problem is if I ignore everyone overreacting for no bloody reason I won't have anyone to talk to next season. Might make the Richmond board a happier place for me though.

 

[Rubber Hips]

So this is us being aggressive?
Lol
Richmond cop it up the arse, doodah doodah

 

[exceptional design]

What's a Lee Majors grandpa?

haha 6 Million Dollar Man (probably 60 Million now), who had bionic parts fitted.


But I only really watched it for Farrah Fawcett

 

[fargothegreat]

Is the guy who went for a wank back, if so now we know how long u last.

Motlop to melb, ,motlop pick to tigers, lids to cats.

Melbourne don't have a first

 

["The Roar Is Back"]

Hey I may be fat, and I may be a useless campaigner but..... What was the other one you said?

moron

 

[Tiger_4_Life]

If everyone was calm then there would be no entertainment...

Yeah true... But no use getting all riled up over an article from Jake Niall, I mean have you see what the guy looks like?

 

[THE_GUN]

Just to gauge, Cats have a salary cap problem with bringing in players would you guys think a deal of
Delidio+#26 for Caddy+ Motlop be interested ?

 

[Tiges1229]

Giving up pick 6 for Prestia tells me that we're desperate to remain semi-relevant now, maybe get a few top 8 finishes, rather than aiming for real success in the future. We NEED that pick 6 and we need to use it wisely.

I feel like we're sticking with the ol' Dan Richardson mentality by trading it.

We should have gone the full rebuild

 

[RichoLedio]

Is the guy who went for a wank back, if so now we know how long u last.

Motlop to melb, ,motlop pick to tigers, lids to cats.

I've had threr now. Each three times longer lasting than the last

 

[prodigy]

Yeah true... But no use getting all riled up over an article from Jake Niall, I mean have you see what the guy looks like?

Just the fact he used the words "almost certain" drove me bananas.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

[docko911]

I just don't think it is worth getting too upset about not having a pick in the top 10 if we retain at least two in the 20s.

Look at it this way

In the 2009 draft

If we had pick one we would have taken Scully... is Scully worth pick 1? **** no.

After Martin the next best was Cunnington at pick 5 (good player but no world beater), the next decent player was Talia at 14 followed by Fyfe at 20.

So in the top 20 there were 5 players worth grabbing and probably Fyfe, Martin and Talia were the only 3 worthy of top 10 picks.

In the next 10 picks went Carlisle, Duncan and Gunston.

Now look at 2008 draft

Much better players in this draft yet 2 of the 3 best midfielders went at 29 Beams and 30 Hannebery. The other was Ziebell at pick 9. There were good KPP's in this draft but that is more like next years draft than this years draft. Still plenty of plodders popped up in the top 20.

If we take 3 midfielders before pick 30 we will land at least one player worthy of a top 10 pick.

 

[tigercam]

Richmond when we end up giving away Lids, Pick 6 and Vickery for Prestia to the haters.

 

[French Tiger]

I would prefer to keep 6 , but some are carrying on like we trade our 1st every year ! Who knows we may get a 2nd or 2 back & then can package them up to get back into the 1st

 

[TigermanM2]

Year after year nothing happens until the last few days of the trade period. You would think we would learn but no.

 

[prodigy]

Year after year nothing happens until the last few days of the trade period. You would think we would learn but no.

It's been two days...


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

[Capitano_Cotch]

Everyone needs to chill out in regards to trading 6. We'll butcher it anyway, so who cares. Plus, pick 6 is cursed and we already have 2 on our list (Yarran, Conca)

 

[tigercam]

It's been two days...


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

I think thats his point

 

[NaturalDisaster]

Everyone needs to chill out in regards to trading 6. We'll butcher it anyway, so who cares. Plus, pick 6 is cursed and we already have 2 on our list (Yarran, Conca)

Maybe they want to get rid of it cos they don't trust FJ

Year after year nothing happens until the last few days of the trade period. You would think we would learn but no.

Hardly any club has yet, it's been a very quiet start...