Mega Thread 2018 List Management, Free Agency & Trade thread

[maccamk]

Eagles are in the box seat for Lobb.

Freo I would if thought

 

[Lach72]

Let’s say we kept 4 and gave Melbourne 5 and 2019 first.

We get Hogan and take Rankine or Smith.

We have a forward line of:
Walters Hogan Switta
McCarthy Cox and Rankine

Should be able to kick a few


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

[Lachy96]

Ideally,

Out: Neale
In: 4 and 22

Out: 4 and 2019 1st
In: Hogan and 3rd round pick.

Go to draft with 5, 22 and 3rd round pick.

 

[Dirty_banchez]

Freo I would if thought

Lycett to the Power. Lobb to the Eagles.

Lobb gets to pick his destination.

 

[Carson Dial]

Eagles are looking for a ruck, Lobb wants to be a forward/ruck which is what we need, therefore would be a better fit for Freo and Lobb.
Eagles can gagf.

 

[maccamk]

Lycett to the Power. Lobb to the Eagles.

Lobb gets to pick his destination.

With GWS approval.

How are WC going to get Kelly and Lobb?

Eagles are looking for a ruck, Lobb wants to be a forward/ruck which is what we need, therefore would be a better fit for Freo and Lobb.
Eagles can gagf.

eagles won’t have the $ or trade currency

 

[Dirty_banchez]

With GWS approval.

How are WC going to get Kelly and Lobb?

He wants the Eagles.

Not sure. **** the Eagles.

 

[UYD 4 Life]

Is lobb a free agent next year? I can't see them trading him if they manage to get what they want for shiel and setterfield......or unless us or the eagles offer well overs

 

[Snuffaluphagus]

I do like the future first option and say to Brisbane, what chu got? BUT it does handcuff in getting any other trades. We would literally have no available picks to do anything else at all...

 

[Wally Walpamur]

With GWS approval.

How are WC going to get Kelly and Lobb?

eagles won’t have the $ or trade currency

Kelly - Gaff compo pick
Lobb - Lycett compo pick

 

[UYD 4 Life]

That's only the same club happy to deal, seemingly unaware of the injury reoccurring until another club had a look.

Is Melbourne still using the same staff?

Yeah I think seemingly is probably the key word there.

Same footy manager

 

[TheMcManusNose]

With GWS approval.

How are WC going to get Kelly and Lobb?

eagles won’t have the $ or trade currency

I would have thought they would have the currency pretty easily.

GC 2nd. Gaff pick, Lycett pick, WCE 2nd. So ~21, 22, 24, 40 when the dust settles. Should be able to parlay those into Lobb and Kelly pretty easily. Money wise Gaff is the single biggest cost so you would think they'd be fine there.

 

[TheLastCall]

Hogan is will be 24yrs old next season. We will have skipped the development years and obtained a very good KPF that should have 7-9 yrs left in the system barring disaster.

Easily worth two 1st's. Pick 5 and our 2019 1st rounder. The Neale trade can get us back in the draft with some nice picks.

This is about right, I'd hope for another pick back, late 2nd or 3rd.

 

[Mr Fonebone]

Anybody know of this

 

[wayToGo_]

We gave up picks 2 and 13 for Hogan in 2012

Just to make this factual because I've heard this argument a lot. You gave up #3 and #14 for Hogan's pick, pick #20 and Dom Barry. So you spent 2 1st rounders but got a 1st rounder back.

I'm expecting us to pay fair value but #5 and #6 is overs in such a strong a draft with ~6 standout key prospects at the top of the draft. I think something more fair is either a pick inside 6 and a late 1st or two mid 1sts (eg 9 and 10). Which would you prefer if given the choice?

 

[wild side]

Just to make this factual because I've heard this argument a lot. You gave up #3 and #14 for Hogan's pick, pick #20 and Dom Barry. So you spent 2 1st rounders but got a 1st rounder back.

I'm expecting us to pay fair value but #5 and #6 is overs in such a strong a draft with ~6 standout key prospects at the top of the draft. I think something more fair is either a pick inside 6 and a late 1st or two mid 1sts (eg 9 and 10). Which would you prefer if given the choice?

yep, its a strong draft, so I would give them 1 first rounder, and then something else.
2 first rounders is overs imo

 

[Son of a Wizard]

Just to make this factual because I've heard this argument a lot. You gave up #3 and #14 for Hogan's pick, pick #20 and Dom Barry. So you spent 2 1st rounders but got a 1st rounder back.

I'm expecting us to pay fair value but #5 and #6 is overs in such a strong a draft with ~6 standout key prospects at the top of the draft. I think something more fair is either a pick inside 6 and a late 1st or two mid 1sts (eg 9 and 10). Which would you prefer if given the choice?

About the most sensible thing I’ve read today.

 

[PavlichsNeighbour]

New member but I just went on the Demons part of the forum to see their opinions on Hogan trade.

Picks 4, 5 and Tom Langdon is more than fair according to our counterparts.

 

[Purpellian Anchor]

We must irritate some of the Vic clubs with our driv

New member but I just went on the Demons part of the forum to see their opinions on Hogan trade.

Picks 4, 5 and Tom Langdon is more than fair according to our counterparts.

its settled then...he wont be coming to freo

 

[Wally Walpamur]

New member but I just went on the Demons part of the forum to see their opinions on Hogan trade.

Picks 4, 5 and Tom Langdon is more than fair according to our counterparts.

New poster, claims to support Freo, doesn’t realise that Tom Langdon doesn’t play for the team he ‘supports’...

Seems legit.

 

[Purpletown]

New member but I just went on the Demons part of the forum to see their opinions on Hogan trade.

Picks 4, 5 and Tom Langdon is more than fair according to our counterparts.

Lol,lol and lol.

 

[free at last]

Melbourne can get ****ed.

Hogan wouid be worth 2 firsts if he was raring to go on day 1 of the preseason but he ain't.
I'd personally offer what we get for Neale assuming it's 5&22-take it or leave it.

 

[Moo]

New member but I just went on the Demons part of the forum to see their opinions on Hogan trade.

Picks 4, 5 and Tom Langdon is more than fair according to our counterparts.

One poster and your trolling was obvious & unamusing.

 

[DannyTheDoorman]

Kelly - Gaff compo pick
Lobb - Lycett compo pick[/QUOTE

Good Onya Wal what you have suggested makes sense in the Chimpanzee psyche but they have to thrown in a can of paint (British Brand of course)

 

[Dale147]

Good job the muppets on the Melbourne board don’t do the trades then.