List Mgmt. 2020 Trade Thread - Part II

[Yawkey way]

fair enough. the goal will be an early second/late first from richmond's perspective i think.

That’s pretty unrealistic, I’m sorry I don’t mind Higgins but he’s not best 22 at richmond and will struggle to to start at the saints.

The hard sell won’t change that and I guess we already know what richmond want or we wouldn’t have bothered putting an offer to the kid. If you’re looking for that sort of return then I guess he’ll stay at richmond and you’ll need to move someone who’s uncontracted.

I’m not trying to go dodoro on you but that’s just how I see it. He’s arguably a potential small upgrade on a guy like lonie who we’ll be lucky to get a third round pick for.

 

[LiterallyNobody]

This is probably not the place to ask this but I don’t care - does anybody know what that song is that plays before Dwayne’s world on SEN. All we ever hear is the instrumental intro and then nothing. I’ve googled it and nothing comes up so no idea how to find it.

 

[Elvis Winmar]

Haha hero. Righto legend. I'm allowed to have an opinion after seeing that pathetic video. Now I'm a sexist because of it? Embarrassing

Describing a woman you’ve never met as a ‘mutt’ isn’t an ‘opinion’.

It’s offensive, incel-esque BS. I thoroughly enjoy the banter in here, and I’m definitely no wowser, but that kind of rubbish we can do without.

 

[Joffaboy]

Get rid of Lonie and send that pick for Higgins.


What we we get for any of the others package some up and improve our picks

Lonie, Dunstan and Webster all gone. Kent next year with Joyce and DMAC

 

[Sully111]

FB: Paton Howard Wilkie
HB: Coffield Carlisle? Long
C: Hill Steele Billings
HF: Gresham Membrey Higgins
FF: Butler King Marshall
RR: Ryder Clark Crouch
IC: Bytel Hannebery Jones Battle

 

[LiterallyNobody]

Get rid of Lonie and send that pick for Higgins.


What we we get for any of the others package some up and improve our picks

yep I like that. Who gets Lonie though??? Carlton would be a good fit for him.

 

[LiterallyNobody]

Lonie, Dunstan and Webster all gone. Kent next year with Joyce and DMAC

Will we ever get rid of Ed?

 

[Diehard Saint]

Saints, the Tigers reserves team. Lets get Higgins into the AA squad for 2021.

So far, just with Butler alone, the Tigers reserves have done better for us than all the GWS reserves did for Carlton.

 

[Stevi_Tigers]

Is Higgins only a small forward, or can he play midfield?

Can run through the middle as well good mark for his height as well

 

[bird_man]

We don't have a glut of small forwards. How many would we have playing VFL ( if we had VFL 2020 ).

We still would have had Parker and Hind or Lonie playing VFL this year.

 

[Tommy Wigs]

i actually think this is a bad idea.

his misso posted the rant on a private instagram story that got leaked to media. stupid but a bit dodgy ethically to report on.

his character, bubbliness and excitement got us over the line in many a game in 2018 where we were mentally cooked. he was our best finals player, unbelievably.

I could see his number on the backs of kids jumpers quickly

 

[Jay Beast]

i actually think this is a bad idea.

his misso posted the rant on a private instagram story that got leaked to media. stupid but a bit dodgy ethically to report on.

his character, bubbliness and excitement got us over the line in many a game in 2018 where we were mentally cooked. he was our best finals player, unbelievably.

Definitely do not want to kill his character although maybe a little bit of media training is warranted

 

[StCicatriz]

as far as price goes, probably a second rounder gets it done, maybe with a saints-favoured third round pick swap in there too. but you guys haven't a second or third, so maybe:

richmond get: pick 15, pick 55
st kilda get: J. Higgins, pick 32, future 2nd round.

dealing wit tigers supporters is like chalk and cheese with adelaide

richmond supporters seem to be very realistic in terms of trade value and tbh pretty damn fair

 

[Aussieviking1]

If you listen to he ITKs he was on a big contract and if he was to stay he was taking a significant hair cut. I wouldn't be surprised if we sent him to market to see he's over valuing himself hoping he'll come back for less.

Hope so mate unless Satan has some big fish.

 

[Armoooo]

Haha hero. Righto legend. I'm allowed to have an opinion after seeing that pathetic video. Now I'm a sexist because of it? Embarrassing

Of course you're allowed to have an opinion, even if it is disproportionately based on a single Instagram story. But when you express a stupid opinion, will quite rightly call you out for being an idiot.

If you don't think referring to a woman as somebody's mutt girlfriend, is sexist, well that's probably because you're sexist.

 

[StCicatriz]

if the Higgins news is true, it sounds like the Tigers will move him on in a sympathy trade. which means a 2nd rounder should get it done.

it also means the writing is on the wall for Lonie. Similar for Crouch to Dunstan.

it should be pretty damn obvious to all now what Lethers and Gags think of Trouts recruitment.

 

[LordMarbury]

Describing a woman you’ve never met as a ‘mutt’ isn’t an ‘opinion’.

It’s offensive, incel-esque BS. I thoroughly enjoy the banter in here, and I’m definitely no wowser, but that kind of rubbish we can do without.

Absolutely. Not cool at all, 'Max'. It was low even by footy forum standards.

 

[_Maximus_12]

13 years between posts.

How the hell did you even remember your password?

Hard to forget when we’ve only won one flag.
Gosaints66

 

[Joffaboy]

dealing wit tigers supporters is like chalk and cheese with adelaide

richmond supporters seem to be very realistic in terms of trade value and tbh pretty damn fair

3 flags in 4 years will do that for you.

 

[Spider Eater]

13 years between posts.

How the hell did you even remember your password?

I believe his last scoop was Lovett to St Kilda.

 

[StCicatriz]

3 flags in 4 years will do that for you.

i'm willing to experience that

 

[Diehard Saint]

dealing wit tigers supporters is like chalk and cheese with adelaide

richmond supporters seem to be very realistic in terms of trade value and tbh pretty damn fair

If it was Dusty, maybe not....

 

[HarryZLA]

I know that Crouch has committed and a lot of talk about Higgins but i still believe there will be another "name" player that St Kilda will target and land over the trade period.
Watch this space!!!!

What do you have to lose by naming said player?

Is it going to somehow come back to you behind this 4 post account?

 

[Ducky Tie]

Two posters making their first posts in ten years. All happening. Destination board.

 

[St Neil]

as far as price goes, probably a second rounder gets it done, maybe with a saints-favoured third round pick swap in there too. but you guys haven't a second or third, so maybe:

richmond get: pick 15, pick 55
st kilda get: J. Higgins, pick 32, future 2nd round.

Future second?